- Joined
- Jan 3, 2017
I don't get when people say Tobey Maguire was a bad Peter Parker. He wasn't the wise-cracking joke maker, but he perfectly captured the tragic side to Peter Parker. And not in a whiney way. The guy who is traumatized by his role in his uncle's death and struggles with his job as Spider-Man.
Maguire perfectly captured the frustrated and tormented side of being Peter Parker. Constantly letting those he loves down on a personal level, struggling to manage all his duties and never really getting to be happy the way he wants to be. I don't get what people wanted from Tobey Maguire to think he wasn't perfect for the role.
Mostly we're missing the quips, I think. Spider-Man is not just a smartass; that's practically his calling card. The few times we see him actually give some smart aleck response it's usually pretty flat. "Did your husband make it for you?" is probably the best one, and he's not even really Spider-Man yet (no costume; hasn't lost Uncle Ben). "You're the one who's out, Gobby!" is one of the worst lines in the movie, although it's as poorly written as it is poorly delivered.
Rich overstated this as "Peter Parker is an asshole," which is ... well, let's say I think a fair amount of projection is involved.
Like I said, I think Maguire is acceptable, and better out of the costume than he is in it. It's definitely a more vulnerable Peter than is generally depicted in the comics, but I don't know that that's a bad thing. Whatever his shortcomings might be, I don't think it's enough to drag the film down to the level Rich seems to believe.