I'm six months late but this pisses me off. The X-Men
have always been symbols for inclusion and diversity, and that's exactly why making them literally gay/black/jewish is fucking retarded. Mutants are already stand-ins for all of those things, and any other marginalizing trait a reader might project onto them. The entire premise is an allegory for the experience of being discriminated against, without any of the real-world baggage and prejudice associated with blackness or gayness specifically. It's effective, and inclusive, specifically because the demographic experiencing discrimination
isn't fucking real, and that allows you to both 1) sympathize with them without bias, and 2) project your own experiences onto them, regardless of whether that's about race or sex or orientation or religion or disability or ideology or nationality or culture or whatever. It was
already a story about being black or gay or retarded; making the conflict about being literally black or gay or retarded defeats the purpose, undermines the allegory, brings in real-world biases,
excludes every other marginalized group besides the specific one you picked, it's clumsy, it's retarded, you're retarded, go fuck yourself.