Listened through the Forward and the Prologue. I wanna just say, for the record, that I salute
@IJustWantToSeeAttachments for embarking upon this endeavor. ... I do hope that you remain sane toward the end.
So, one thing I noticed was said in the prologue was that apparently our lovely little Gloria Tesch puts herself among people like Stephen King, J.K. Rowling, and Stephanie Meyer.
For starters, lol at Meyer being on that list, and
double lol for that statement in general.
As for the prologue... I think the one thing that bugs me the most about Tesch's writing is her... dialogue. Dialogue has, imo, always been one of the biggest elements of a story for me. Good dialogue can immerse you into a story and help flesh out characters and the world that they're in. Bad dialogue... is just
bad. Like, it's painfully obvious that no one would ever speak like this in real life. Maradonia's writing is squarely in the latter. I mean, seriously:
"The failure to prepare is the preparation to fail."
"Two children will arrive in your country and will show you your limitations and they will harm your empire."
The latter fails to be imposing as a prophecy in any way. It's literally the shit I would expect to see scribbled in a teenage girl's notebook, underneath some doodles of MCP and some black roses or some shit. The former is... the worst attempt at sounding "wise" I've ever heard. It's not even pedantic. It just... it's like some snotty brat who picked up a dictionary and was trying to use it to sound smart.
The dialogue issues in Maradonia spread into the diction of this story in general. Sentences just sound...
weird. Like, it just feels awkward to listen to it. I really don't know how to describe it beyond "No one else I have ever met writes like this."
And there's
several books of this. And a
movie. This is glorious.