- Joined
- Dec 25, 2017
This is the weirdest part for me. The set protagonist implies a heavy emphasis on story, but everything about their marketing made it clear story wasn’t their goal, gameplay and exploration was, which is what pissed critics off and confuses potential players. Elden Ring as an example has a very very lose plot, so lose it basically doesn’t exist and what little is there isn’t explained clearly and is mostly a set of context clues for what the narrative might be. Because of this, you can make your character whatever you want and it doesn’t matter, you’re just the Tarnished.Probably should have had create a character instead of a set protagonist.
These MMO lite sandbox games are always way more fun if you can play as Shrek or whatever.
Basically all of From’s games do that to great success,
Maybe it was to avoid a black desert situation where every character is just a big tittied girl in a skimpy outfit, but fans would argue that’s a big selling point of the game.
Either way, the reviews do seem suspect to me, and this game seems like something designed for critics to hate. The real test is when people can play it. If this game really as as expansive and large, it might do well from word of mouth and when streamers start showing off the crazy stuff.
I do think they shot themselves in the foot by being so insanely cryptic about the game. There are a lot of people and even reviews that call it an RPG while they themselves say it isn’t one as an example. The genre should be the thing explained the clearest.