I watched Night of the Reaper, and...it was pretty OK. First off, no niggers, which was great. There weren't very many kills in it, and none of them had gore, but it was much more about the tension and "mystery" than the killings.
No one was pants-shitting retarded in it, which was a breath of fresh air. Neither the killer nor the victim nor even any of the supporting cast did absolutely dumb shit (outside of baby-sitter horror trope dumb shit, which is acceptable).
Now, I (an autist) saw the first twist a mile off, but my wife (a normie) didn't, and didn't even believe me when I told her what was coming (what a jerk). But the killer's identity I didn't guess (because it was pretty dumb, and my idea was way better). But it didn't really bother me.
I only really had 3 quibbles with the movie. The acting wasn't great, to put it mildly. The kid actors were definitely kid actors but they're not in it enough to bother you all THAT much. But the supporting cast kind of really sucked in most scenes. The main chick was OK, but she kind of looks and holds herself like Anna Faris, which kept making me feel like I was watching a Scary Movie. It was weird, but that's probably only me.
The ending is kind of a let down - but only relative to how good the rest of the movie was. It wasn't dumb or had people acting out of character or anything, it was just a little rushed and "let's just end it here"-ish. Basically no denoument. I give it credit for not being retarded though. It had an ending that was set up and made sense and tied everything up.
Very minor bonus quibbles- there's like a five minute stretch with like 8 jump scares in it. I mean not the shitty music sting jump scares in shitty movies, but diagetic ones that, while they made sense, still got a little laughable and old. But I get it, it was just that one stretch and it was the tensest part of the movie.
No nudity. Ok fair enough, it's a babysitter movie, so it wouldn't really be appropriate, but come on, shoehorn in a shower scene for the dads out there. TBF there weren't any chicks in the movie I'd want to see topless anyway, so they'd really need to do a whole other scene.
I'd give it a solid 3.5/5. No hateable protagonists, everything made sense, people talked and acted like actual humans. Even when there were a couple things where I thought "Hey there's no way she would know that yet," they circled back and showed how she did know it. Very solid picture despite no gore and no titties. By far the best Shudder movie so far, and probably the best sequel to Halloween ever (outside of Season of the Witch if you count it).