@BrunoMattei I had forgotten all about our mini New Nightmare sperg because of the downtime/work/blah blah life in general.
I agree with most of your points but honestly I felt that New Nightmare was actually the scariest one since NOES II. Sure, part of the plot didn't make complete sense, the franchise was in a sort of decline since the horror boom of the 80s and the 90s had a whole new culture which demanded new kind of horror / slasher. I'm going more off feeling here. Freddy
felt threatening, he felt menacing, he felt fucking scary. Legitimately the last time he felt like that was in II before they turned him into a complete caricature and comedic relief. It's why I like The Evil Dead over Evil Dead II : Dead By Dawn. The sequel is a fucking comedy movie. As for the marketing? New Nightmare came out in 1994. I was seven years old, I barely paid attention to the marketing because who the fuck markets slasher movies to a child? My sister took me to see it with her and her boyfriend, like they usually did with big releases coming out. Fuck, I saw Terminator 2 with my dad in theaters. I barely remember it in the theater but I know I saw it.
All that aside, is New Nightmare a perfect movie? God no. It's not even a good movie by standards, but I enjoyed it, and others in this thread have enjoyed worse.