Google Says It Will Delete Location Data When Users Visit Abortion Clinics - Under pressure from employees and supporters of reproductive rights, the company announced privacy changes for the post-Roe era.

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
By Nico Grant
July 1, 2022, 6:03 p.m. ET
SAN FRANCISCO — Google said on Friday that it would delete abortion clinic visits from the location history of its users, in the company’s first effort to address how it will handle sensitive data in the wake of the Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade.
The location data change will take place in the coming weeks, Jen Fitzpatrick, a Google senior vice president, wrote in a blog post. The policy will also apply to trips to fertility clinics, domestic violence shelters, addiction treatment facilities and other sensitive locations.
Google, which holds reams of intimate information about its billions of users, has come under scrutiny since the Supreme Court’s decision last week to strike down Roe v. Wade, eliminating the constitutional right to an abortion after almost 50 years. Some supporters of reproductive rights have pushed people to delete apps that track their menstrual cycles online, while experts saidsearch and location data from companies like Google are more likely to be used as evidence.
The overturning of Roe has more broadly renewed questions about how much data and digital trails people have produced, which could be used to surveil or target those who try and get an abortion. In states that allow bans or other limits on abortion, law enforcement is expected to be focused on taking action against medical providers, but information about individuals — including location data, payments data and more — is not hard to obtain through data brokers and other sources.

The Alphabet Workers Union, a group representing more than 800 people who work for Google’s parent company, Alphabet, demanded on Tuesday that the search giant delete any personal data that law enforcement could try to use to prosecute those who are getting abortions.
With Friday’s announcement, while Google will delete some location data, it did not commit to automatically deleting search records about abortions, which may also become sought after. Users must individually opt to delete their search history.

Google has been sued by the state of Texas, accused of continuing to track users even when they use the Chrome web browsers’ supposedly private Incognito Mode — which may further erode confidence that the company will purge all data when people try to browse privately.
Google also made no commitments about changing the way it handles government data requests.
“We remain committed to protecting our users against improper government demands for data, and we will continue to oppose demands that are overly broad or otherwise legally objectionable,” Ms. Fitzpatrick wrote.
The company also said that users will soon be able to more quickly delete multiple menstruation logs stored on Fitbit, a health-tracking company owned by Google, rather than one at a time. The company also reminded users to employ existing settings options on Google to improve their online privacy.

 
Actually kinda surprised by this one

Now if only they could erase all location data from its users then it'll be marginally better.
 
Good. Now do it whenever I visit a gun store or gun show. Or hell, how about all trips?

…Wait, you won’t do that? Just “sensitive health clinics” with abortion highlighted? Hmm…

Snark aside, I don’t trust for one second Google is being honest here. They’re too power-hungry to voluntarily give up spying for any reason. That, or they’ll only stop tracking once inside a clinic building itself, but then resume once in the parking lot. Technically that’s not a “trip” to an abortion clinic, so Google can still brag about how private they are.
 
There'll still be location data for the entire trip, it's just gonna mysteriously have a blank spot of activity a block around the clinic. If they were that concerned about users in this situation it'd still be trivial to figure out what they're doing
 
Good. Now do it whenever I visit a gun store or gun show. Or hell, how about all trips?

…Wait, you won’t do that? Just “sensitive health clinics” with abortion highlighted? Hmm…

Snark aside, I don’t trust for one second Google is being honest here. They’re too power-hungry to voluntarily give up spying for any reason. That, or they’ll only stop tracking once inside a clinic building itself, but then resume once in the parking lot. Technically that’s not a “trip” to an abortion clinic, so Google can still brag about how private they are.
Just have your local gun store register as abortion clinics too. Free privacy for everyone.
 
But then won't a random gap in location data be awfully suspicious? Especially if it's heading in the direction of an abortion clinic?
 
Actually kinda surprised by this one

Now if only they could erase all location data from its users then it'll be marginally better.
What if all places were somehow labeled as abortion clinics? That could help delete some data.
 
There is legislation looking to try to criminalize it though I don’t know how well that would hold up constitutionally.
I mean, if you can outlaw sex tourism, you should be able to outlaw abortion tourism.

Also google is lying. "Whoopie-doopsie, we did a fucky-wucky and didn't delete all that confidential data after all." -Them as soon as they get caught
 
"We will track you for everything else you are doing EXCEPT getting an abortion!" isn't the virtue signal you think it is, Google.
There'll still be location data for the entire trip, it's just gonna mysteriously have a blank spot of activity a block around the clinic. If they were that concerned about users in this situation it'd still be trivial to figure out what they're doing
I was gonna say the same thing.
"We were tracking User #2113678 from their house to 08:40 when they entered within 50m of a known abortion clinic then we know nothing about what they did until 14:21 when they resumed travel outside 50m of a known abortion clinic"
 
Wonder when some states will try to stop abortion trips.
Cavanaugh specifically mentions that going out of state is A-OK and legal in the opinion so I don't see how they would hold up in court.

Granted it could take years for such a law to wind its ay through the courts and get stuck down.

It is odd that crossing state lines for this is OK.
Remember Jared from Subway?
He isn't in jail becase he banged an underaged chick.
He is in federal prison becase he crossed state lines to have sex with a girl who was of the age of consent in the state that they had sex but under 18 and he took pictures of it. (Holy run on sentence Batman!)

There are many sates with age of consents under 18.
However the FBI may get involved if you cross state lines to have sex with some one under 18 in them.
FWIW Jared is gross and I don't feel bad for him.
I just don't like the precedent.

If you cross state line to buy Marijuana can the feds make you Jared's cell mate?
It is still just as illegal as heroin as far as the feds are concerned.

Fireworks are banned in my state but legal in most if not all surrounding states.
As it is unless you set someone else's property on fire or are a real jackass about it the cops just ignore it becase they have bigger fish to fry.

Sadly it sounds like the FBI could set up "Operation: Freedom Fighter" (they would be the ones fighting against freedom as usual) and start busting people for crossing state lines to buy somthing that was illegal in their state. They way they prosecute sex crime they could arrest you even if you set the fireworks off in a state where they were legal.
 
Wonder when some states will try to stop abortion trips.

I don't agree with blocking abortions, but if they're going to they should do this. You should not be able to state jump to get one.

Does my position make sense? Probably not.
 
So if a person wanted to log onto a minecraft server and commit a crime, google would help them with the alibi if they targeted certain locations?
 
When will liberals realize they’re just being played by big mega corporations? Mega corporations are also offering women money to travel places to get an abortion so they can go right back to work. They like that you can’t have a family because having time for family means less money for them.
 
Back
Top Bottom