how S L O W everything is in the game
This is a very fair criticism to hold against the game, and modern Rockstar as a whole.
RDR1 is mindless fun with an occasional satirical criticism aimed at society but I never felt it veered into chastising you. You decide the pace you want to play the game at, you decide if you want to visit every Stranger first (and you usually want to visit them ASAP because R* has a nasty habit of locking content to a specific leg of the journey as you play), meanwhile RDR2 you are half if not outright forced to interact with Strangers that lead into the main storyline. You CANNOT avoid doing side content in RDR2, you can't just go off westward, no, you HAVE to talk to Dutch and you HAVE to listen to the plan Arthur.
I have to revisit RDR1 whenever I get my ps3 fixed, alternatively I can just get it on PC now (but fuck paying for a game I already own, and they didn't even add anything to the PC release, in fact the PC port is inferior despite the many years they had to deal with the spaghetti code, if they wanted to).
I do love both games but I feel reluctant to revisit RDR2. I don't want to do a low honour run because I like high honour Arthur a lot (noble criminal, soft masculine personality,
total chick bait that plays right into every single stereotype you can have of women) and the fact that R* never gave us any DLC is upsetting.
Meanwhile RDR1's zombie DLC is fucking BANGER. I cannot overstate how much fun it is.
As a complete aside, I have one massive criticism for collect-a-thon games, particularly spurred on by a set of Stranger missions in RDR2 related to
Algernon Wasp, mega faggot that he is.
If a game dev wants me to complete their game 100%, at least give me a way to track where I have/haven't found the items/persons I need. Not out of game, not on a third party website like the RDR2 interactive map made by fans. Not on an official Rockstar social club page like in L.A Noire. In game.
It can be an item I
have to buy, or NG+ only, or something. Make it worth my time to spend hours picking flowers, if that's how I want to spend my day. Don't make me pull up a checklist with coordinates, painstakingly put together by fans, when you have the technology to easily implement immersive ways for me to keep tabs on things.
Arthur has his ability to track animals and shit, why can't I also get a map tracker like you get with the legendary animals. Arthur writes a lot in his journal, the information could be stored there. Even John fucking Marston, the imbecile that he is in RDR2, keeps a journal.