The other thread was closed, so I hope you have notifications turned on, because I have got to hear what this is about, it sounds ridiculous.
I hope I'm right in this assumption, is it the Mignolaverse you've been reading? Nothing else is on par, but avatar has a couple that approach it in terms of scope and themes, like God is Dead (after issue six though Hickman leaves, so maybe check seven and eight out and see how you feel, otherwise just get the books of acts) and Alan Moore's Providence if you like Lovecraft (you don't need to read his previous lovecraftian books Neonomicon and The Courtyard, but they are connected).
Actually, avatar and dark horse have a lot of similar output excluding dark horse's licensed stuff, both publishers give a lot of freedom to the creators - dark horse has more editorial input, which results in a higher consistency of good quality work, while avatar is more hands off, which means the quality varies wildly, but the good shit is excellent. Crossed is a good example - it has a reputation as edgelord shit, but the lack of enforced morality results in some amazing stuff, alongside some utter garbage. Uber is also great, and if you haven't read the superhero trilogy Warren Ellis did at avatar (Black Summer, No Hero and Supergod) you should go grab it asap - they're deconstructions fyi, I assume you're not interested in standard superhero comics.
And if you liked Gerard Way's Umbrella Academy you should definitely check out his new Doom Patrol, which isn't quite as good, but is better than Grant Morrison's run, and I say that as someone who is gay for Grant Morrison. Otherwise from the big two there isn't a lot to suggest, aside from Tom King's The Vision and his current Mister Miracle run.