Back with more thoughts. The reason why so many Sam Hyde fans were convinced that Sam was just doing a bit the whole time is that, just like Harland was attempting to be funny the whole time by humiliating Sam, Sam was attempting to be funny the whole time by humiliating Harland. Harland had an overall better performance, but the only part of the podcast that could be described as comedic was the gorilla nest chimp out, which was itself Sam trying to reverse the joke on Harland, "I'm a big dumb nigger, huh? Let's see how you handle this gorilla." After this, Sam does a complete reversal because he realized that he fucked up, so he tries to grovel to Harland to win him over and convince him he was just trying to have a back and forth, which actually convinced the Sam Hyde fanbase, but Harland couldn't be fooled because this was what he wanted the whole time. Now, Harland is apparently very bad at improv, so he couldn't think of any way to make it funny and resorted to editing in jokes and saying after the fact, "It turns out I'm busy for the rest of my life". I saw someone in the Sam Hyde thread get mad at Sam for saying "so you finally bring it up" when Harland lets him think it's time to shill, but Sam was trying to play it off as if they were just being playful the whole podcast, and he thought Harland was going to play along (it should be mentioned that censoring Sam Hyde in post helped to reinforce this in the eyes of a Sam Hyde fan, it makes it seem like Extreme Peace is too hot to air, so it has to be censored).
Also, people have said that Sam's comedy is really mean-spirited and Harland was able to take advantage of this by being the bigger gorilla, but this isn't true, and I stand by my original analysis of why Harland was able to win. Sam Hyde has certainly done a lot of mean-spirited or biting comedy, that's probably what Fishtank is, although I've never cared to watch it, and some of his more popular bits like "Jews Rock" and the American Sisyphus sketches or the Ted talk, but his best work like the "First Date" sketch or his "Natty Monster" sketch, or the Idubbbz documentary, are ones where he plays the fool, so like I said, Sam building a gorilla nest would not be out of place at all in his own work. I will say, Sam didn't really have any other options than to either ingratiate himself to a more normie audience and giving a performance that makes him look bad to his core audience, or do some avant-garde exaggerated grovelling to make him look bad to a normie audience, but good to his core audience, or to humiliate himself like what actually happened. There was no way for Sam Hyde to get what he wanted and he should have avoided trying. Also, Sam's comedy is generally reliant on the physical aspect, and that doesn't translate well to a podcast format.