As someone who's been to a psych ward, I gotta contest, sorry.
I am too, because it's time for statistics, because
anecdotes do not change the data. Individual experiences don't generalize. Psychiatric studies disagree with you. The people you treat as experts themselves said this, so saying "it's good" while disagreeing with the system itself saying it's bad is literally incoherent. You cannot simultaneously say "psychiatry is fine and good" and ignore psych itself saying it is not.
tl;dr psychiatric studies over millions of patient years and multiple decades indicates a systemic problem and you don't need to go "BUT I LIKED IT" over the bodies of a lot of dead people. Behold the dead people.
All-cause Standard Mortality:
Norway (2020) 5-year prospective study. All-cause SMR 6.7. First two years post-discharge 8.3 (male) 6.1 (female).
Frontiers in Psychiatry, "Mortality Among Patients Discharged From an Acute Psychiatric Department"
Taiwan (2024) Adolescents and young adults after first psychiatric admission. 3-fold increased risk of death from any cause (HR: 2.97-2.83) 10-fold increased risk of suicide (HR: 11.13-9.23)
Journal of Affective Disorders, "All-cause and suicide mortality after first psychiatric admission"
UK Readmission Study (2022) Dose-response mortality by readmission count. 1 non-identical readmission: HR 2.4 (2.2-2.7). 2+ non-identical episodes: HR 3.0 (2.7-3.4). 1 identical readmission: HR 4.7 (3.6-6.1). 2+ identical episodes: HR 5.0 (3.8-6.7). Source:
PubMed, "Frequent identical admission-readmission episodes"
Suicide-specific Mortality:
Chung et al. (2019) -
BMJ Open, 34 papers, 29 studies:
- First week post-discharge: 2,950 suicides per 100,000 person-years (95% CI: 1,740-5,000)
- First month post-discharge: 2,060 per 100,000 person-years (95% CI: 1,300-3,280)
- 24 studies, 1,928 suicides in 60,880 patient-years (first week data)
- 29 studies, 3,551 suicides in 222,546 patient-years (first month data)
For context, the global suicide rate is approximately
11.4 per 100,000 person-years. That first-week rate is roughly
~300x the general population. First month is 180x. First 3 months 100x. 3-12 months 57x. 1-5 years 44x. 5-10 years 32x. 10+ years 24x. Note this is times, not percent.
Diagnosis specific SMRs exist from Germany: Males with depression 111x the gen pop, females with depression 41x; males with schizophrenia 66x, females with schizophrenia 110x.
A notable thing is the lack of followup care (and the fact that it is refused for reasons that should be obvious, being locked up, drugged up, and tied up fucks people up). However, for people who had meaningful and desired follow-up within 7 days, they had a much lower suicide risk. At any rate, only 50% of discharged patients get help the first week and 67% the first month. The fact that they need such aftercare is also an admission of harm.
Inpatient (as in still in the ward) suicide is 50x gen pop, and has gotten worse over the last three decades.
Frontiers in Psychiatry.
The key to this from the
MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study is: Coercion -> Suicide attempts.
Restraint leads to PTSD. 25-47% (yes the error bars are shit) get PTSD after restraint across multiple studies. 52% of ED patients have trauma history.
Honestly I'm glad you had a good experience! I'd rather someone not be uselessly traumatized into being worse. Unfortunately, the majority of everyone else does not, and, Psychiatry itself admits it's killing people.
PHP/IOP works better anyway. I'll get to that.
Most psych wards are separated into floors, depending on how severe the issue is.
I've visited wards. The ones I remember had a "forensic" floor through glass, while the one I went to was much more open, and full of suicidal people, AND anxious people, AND people detoxing. The detoxing people were cons and were bullying everyone else as the nurses let it happen. The person I was visiting went on a 72h hold for yapping and released the very moment the 72h hold was finished. My anecdote doesn't change your anecdote, your anecdote doesn't change mine, and neither of them have anything to do with
Psychiatric studies show that SMRs and suicide rates are sky fucking high.
here's plenty of studies saying shit like ohhh you'll wanna kill yourself ohhhh it'll make you worse, but you have to remember they are interviewing the insane and expecting a coherent response.
This is factually wrong.
The studies showing elevated suicide risk aren't self-report surveys where someone answers incoherently. They're mortality data. Death certificates, national registries, cohort tracking. Dead people don't fill out questionnaires. Dead people don't fill them out
insane or otherwise, coherent or otherwise.
90% of the time when I met someone who went to a psych ward and they said they got suicidal from it, their reasoning was "The nurses deadnamed me

". The other 10% was "The nurses misgendered me

".
It is now clear you're ego-protecting what you went through. This is Kiwi Farms. Someone leaping in front of facts (being a faggot) will be called a faggot.
You're a faggot. Sorry you had mental health issues. Please do not be a faggot. The facts I speak to come from the very experts you trust to hold yourself and others captive, so how do you coherently disagree with those very people, precisely?
I was improved from my psych ward visit, not only cause I got help but also it was AMAZING to know people like me ARE out there. But I am crazy, like coocoo crazy, so if you're not coocoo crazy it's not worth it really. Very expensive.
I'm glad you were helped. I never said some people are helped. I never spoke about who was helped. I spoke about mortality rates and suicide rates in particular. Some people being helped while others kill themselves at sky high rates can both be true.
It is a lot of money so only go through with it if you're actually crazy, if you're just depressed then the money to help ratio just isn't worth it.
So you concede there are people who aren't helped by it, but again, you side-step "the people you yourself hold to be authorities and trustworthy experts say people die from it." Right.
The IOP section.
The Cochrane Review. Significantly faster decrease in psychopathological symptoms. There is no need for people to suffer. It conservatively states "At least one in five patients currently admitted to inpatient care could feasibly be cared for in an acute day hospital."
Marshall et al. - Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, updated 2011 and 2022. Marshall M, Crowther R, Sledge WH, Rathbone J, Soares-Weiser K.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022, Issue 3. Art. No.: CD004026
Horvitz-Lennon et al. (2001) "A very large body of evidence that acute partial hospitalization is an excellent alternative to inpatient care with equal or better efficacy than inpatient care, yet without some of its deleterious side effects"
Bateman & Fonagy (1999). The Bateman & Fonagy BPD trial. PHP patients showed significant improvements in: Frequency of suicide attempts, acts of self-harm, number and duration of inpatient admissions, depressive symptoms, anxiety, general distress, interpersonal functioning, social adjustment, and most notably standard care group showed
limited or no change on most measures.
You clearly feel the need to rationalize what you went through. You clearly went through something. You trust psychiatry. You either did not feel coerced or feel it was necessary. However, psychiatry itself, the people you trust and validate and defer to, admits it kills a lot of people who are not you.
If you weren't literally boomer-bootstrapping "I got hurt, you should too, IT WAS GOOD FOR ME!!" over something that kills people, I'd be at least 50% less of a dick about it, but you are.