I randomly decided to watch They Live (1988 ) for the first time last week because it's Halloween season and it's shameful that I haven't seen all of John Carpenter's (good) movies. It's a classic, so just some random thoughts.
- They Live is not a great movie, but it is a good one, and it could not be improved with a remake, because even if the remake failed, it would not "fail" in the endearing ways the original does. It's not Carpenter's best movie, but it's well-directed. Roddy Piper isn't a great choice for the lead, but his strange performance is so iconic I wouldn't want to see anyone else try it. The dialogue isn't perfect, but it is what it is and shouldn't be changed. The movie is conceptually a mile wide and an inch deep, and some of the elements are kind of cringeworthy in retrospect (people being brainwashed to MARRY AND REPRODUCE when we're facing a truly disastrous lack of both now), but it's still a great concept that's well-executed. Basically, it's a movie that shouldn't "work" on paper, but it does.
- The alien effects are so great. You can tell the budget isn't huge, but it doesn't matter because the look they went with is so shocking and effective.
- It was nice to see George "Buck" Flower get a more substantial role than I'm used to seeing from him. He's a good actor.
- The stupidly long fight scene is absurd, but it's great! Keith David and Piper choreographed it well.
- Jay from RLM pointed out in some video that Carpenter has said he's always wanted to direct a Western, and you can hear that in the They Live soundtrack. Piper is kind of doing a (discount) stoic, "Man With No Name" thing.
So yeah, I loved it. I started the original Assault on Precinct 13 (1976) right after it was over, but I haven't gotten to finish it yet.