Idk what you're on about with this being natural movements for the dog. She gets up to stretch, sees him reaching over his desk (even if he didn't shock her then and it was just the vibrate setting, she's been conditioned to expect a shock from him reaching like that) then immediately gets back onto the bed while continuing to look at him and only settles back down onto the bed once his hand is returned back from whatever he was reaching (sorry, stretching) towards.
This is the behavior of an animal that is expecting a negative reaction to doing something innocuous, and it's farcical to have a cognitive dissonance that the spot training is cruel but also that hasan isn't/hasn't actively been negatively reinforcing "if you move off the bed I'll reach over here and you'll be sorry".
When you use negative reinforcement to condition an animal to expect pain or discomfort when they do something you don't want, sometimes just waving the proverbial loaded gun is enough for them to stop the behavior. It's a continuing abuse of the poor dog and I don't see why you would acknowledge the conditions he keeps her in are bad but also give him the benefit of the doubt, like "sure he might be keeping her in a perpetual state of discomfort but at least she's not yelping in pain when he does so!".
As a reminder, in the Shocktober 7th click Kaya immediately headed back for the bed as soon as she saw Hasan reach for the remote, he shocked her while she was getting back on the bed, just like in this current clip. She has clearly been conditioned to expect punishment for taking even one step off the bed, I think that Hasan usually uses a lower shock setting or the vibration setting (at least on stream) and she decided it was worth it to stretch for a second or two (sort of like when you injure a joint and it hurts to extend it, but sometimes the need to stretch outweighs the fear of the pain, so you stretch it anyway), but in Shocktober he accidentally pressed the wrong button or turned the dial up to high. If he did actually cut off the prongs
before the incident then that could actually explain it too, the collar wouldn't lose the ability to shock, just the ability to deliver a consistent shock so he might have turned it higher, and on the seventh it happened to be making fuller contact with her skin than usual (maybe it wore away enough fur underneath it since he clearly keeps it on too tight).
The dog doesn't react in any way. Even if you just tap a dog on the back it will look at it.
If you don't regularly tap your dog on the back it doesn't know how to respond so it responds the way anyone does when they receive a new stimuli, they investigate the source. If you do regularly tap your dog on the back that tells the dog that you are there and probably want their attention, so they look at you because that's a reasonable response to the stimuli.
If instead you trained your dog that if you tap it on the back it needs to run to the corner immediately or else you'll smack it then it will run to the corner, no need to investigate and risk being smacked, just hurry on over there.
And the cunt wonders why he is hated... And he will say that clip is out of context... I am sure the full context is even worse.
The context is that he's defending a mob gathered in front of a synagogue chanting "we support Hamas", and then he shocks his dog for taking a step off of her bed.