🐟 Fishtank Fishtank.Live General - Jet Neptune's Pisces Aquarium Internet Reality Show w/ Host Bam Margera

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Official KF Fishtank livechat here!

With a (questionable) W from James Drake, how would you rate season 5 of Fishtank?

  • 1 Star — Absolute disaster. Unwatchable, boring, production fucked it up bad, the fish were lame

    Votes: 57 7.3%
  • 2 Stars — Pretty bad. Some funny moments, dragged, too many vibe repair days. Barely worth checking.

    Votes: 91 11.7%
  • 3 Stars — Average. Solid entertainment in spots, some good chaos and crashouts, but nothing special

    Votes: 177 22.8%
  • 4 Stars — Really good. Lots of hilarious moments, strong fish personalities, solid content and vibes

    Votes: 406 52.2%
  • 5 Stars — Peak Fishtank / Masterpiece. Non-stop insanity, legendary fish and production, pure chaos

    Votes: 47 6.0%

  • Total voters
    778
El estanque got the YouTube feat stamp of approval… with 17 viewers. DEI but the cool kind
IMG_1565.webp
 
Isn't there already enough material for one before fishtank was even a thing?
For sure, but if Jet continues to sperg out and Fishtank dies because of him being a total retard then oh boy would that be the cherry on top of any potential thread
 
Jet takes credit as the creator of Fishtank, but when will he take credit as the ruiner?
 
Turns out season 3 has the most activity after season 1 here.
Better graphs where they're overlayed on each other
Full
2025-08-01-200117.webp
Zoomed in:
2025-08-01-200017.webp


Had the Christmas holiday not nuked activity it looks like Season 2 would have clean sweeped Famous house arc and been neck-and-neck all the way until Alex's wife arrived. These graphs are actually really disgusting because it shows that The Famous House arc wasn't really that good in retrospect, just tossing random fans into the house like in S1, S2 and S4 yield just as much or more chatter than purchasing a million dollar mansion, two rounds of casting agencies and large amounts of preparation. Season 4 was slop tank and Sam spent half the time fucking around on his laptop and there was more talk in the threads than Season 3's Famous House arc.
 
Better graphs where they're overlayed on each other
Full
View attachment 7724882
Zoomed in:
View attachment 7724883


Had the Christmas holiday not nuked activity it looks like Season 2 would have clean sweeped Famous house arc and been neck-and-neck all the way until Alex's wife arrived. These graphs are actually really disgusting because it shows that The Famous House arc wasn't really that good in retrospect, just tossing random fans into the house like in S1, S2 and S4 yield just as much or more chatter than purchasing a million dollar mansion, two rounds of casting agencies and large amounts of preparation. Season 4 was slop tank and Sam spent half the time fucking around on his laptop and there was more talk in the threads than Season 3's Famous House arc.
Not buying this "UMM ACTUALLY FAMOUS HOUSE SUCKED CAUSE NORMIES" narrative. Fuck off. S3 was peak (until it wasn't) but easily cleared everything before it for the sole reason that it wasn't filled with MDE fanboys who wanted to scream THINK IT DREAM IT DO IT
 
These graphs are actually really disgusting because it shows that The Famous House arc wasn't really that good in retrospect, just tossing random fans into the house like in S1, S2 and S4 yield just as much or more chatter than purchasing a million dollar mansion, two rounds of casting agencies and large amounts of preparation.
While useful, these graphs fail to mark important dates like when the site was down nor does it note the thread getting featured more outside of season three. It also fails to consider engagement outside of this thread. It looks like season two and season three were pretty neck and neck until, as you said, the wife arrival rather than a total blowout. Even still, it’s important not to assume engagement automatically corresponds to enhanced show quality. Bloodgames is pretty acclaimed here, and it has the lowest post activity out of any season.
 
the thread getting featured more outside of season three
Looking at the graph, it seems like front page feature doesn't really impact activity on the thread. Season 3 was featured on the first week but has the lowest activity compared to other seasons during that period. Season 4 outperformed others on the first week (ignore S1 huge spike due to lack of sneedchat) without getting featured until it was at the end of season.
 
While useful, these graphs fail to mark important dates like when the site was down nor does it note the thread getting featured more outside of season three. It also fails to consider engagement outside of this thread. It looks like season two and season three were pretty neck and neck until, as you said, the wife arrival rather than a total blowout. Even still, it’s important not to assume engagement automatically corresponds to enhanced show quality. Bloodgames is pretty acclaimed here, and it has the lowest post activity out of any season.
Just looking at thread posts alone doesn't take into account the engagement with Sneedchat, which from my experience has only increased with each season and is where a lot of the regulars will be while the show is live.
 
Just looking at thread posts alone doesn't take into account the engagement with Sneedchat, which from my experience has only increased with each season and is where a lot of the regulars will be while the show is live.
I spent the least time in thread during S3 (until near the end) because it was action packed and I was watching live and engaging on sneedchat constantly (until near the end.)
 
That faggot Josh got booted, Fenix was sent to the hospital. Josh's girlfriend was due to arrive but instead had to deal with her sperg boyfriend's crashout and the possible legal fallout. Fortunately Fenix did not want to press charges. Paula (Josh's girlfriend) joined the house and was decent content for the two days she was present. It seems the event has been swept under the rug with some NDAs.

Josh meanwhile has been seething in his San Salvador motel watching the show and stalking the Estanque discord (allegedly) and constantly bombarding Production's dms and attempting to control the show's narrative and delivering ultimatums, threatening to pull his girlfriend. Josh made a final ultimatum where he wanted to return to the show to hang out with his girlfriend. Production really did not feel like entertaining the legal liability that is Josh and so after a few phone calls in the basement Paula said farewell to the house and left with her twink bf. Somewhere in that whole saga Josh broke the terms of his NDA and lost all the money he made on the show. Roberto gave him 100 USD and a hotel room to stay at for the night. Unsure if any transport as been arranged for him.
 
That faggot Josh got booted, Fenix was sent to the hospital. Josh's girlfriend was due to arrive but instead had to deal with her sperg boyfriend's crashout and the possible legal fallout. Fortunately Fenix did not want to press charges. Paula (Josh's girlfriend) joined the house and was decent content for the two days she was present. It seems the event has been swept under the rug with some NDAs.

Josh meanwhile has been seething in his San Salvador motel watching the show and stalking the Estanque discord (allegedly) and constantly bombarding Production's dms and attempting to control the show's narrative and delivering ultimatums, threatening to pull his girlfriend. Josh made a final ultimatum where he wanted to return to the show to hang out with his girlfriend. Production really did not feel like entertaining the legal liability that is Josh and so after a few phone calls in the basement Paula said farewell to the house and left with her twink bf. Somewhere in that whole saga Josh broke the terms of his NDA and lost all the money he made on the show. Roberto gave him 100 USD and a hotel room to stay at for the night. Unsure if any transport as been arranged for him.
Wow that’s crazy. I got bad vibes from Josh from the start, but he was good content before this. Someone in the YouTube chat called him “El COLUMBINO” because Josh has a school shooter type of vibe lol
 
Josie recently got a cameo in Edmund McMillen's upcoming game Mewgenics.

Looking into it its part of a massive group of small cameos by large and small celebrities recording cat voices for the random cats you breed. Apparently he has been collecting cat voiceovers for about 4 years or so.
She has some concerns about being cut out but having a huge selection seems like the point so I don't doubt she will be in the final release.

From all the way back in 2021.
cameos1.webp
https://x.com/edmundmcmillen/status/1441509467758030852

cameos 2.webp
https://x.com/edmundmcmillen/status/1649308895641505792
Linked video
 
Josie recently got a cameo in Edmund McMillen's upcoming game Mewgenics.
mew.mp4
Looking into it its part of a massive group of small cameos by large and small celebrities recording cat voices for the random cats you breed. Apparently he has been collecting cat voiceovers for about 4 years or so.
She has some concerns about being cut out but having a huge selection seems like the point so I don't doubt she will be in the final release.

From all the way back in 2021.
View attachment 7725691
https://x.com/edmundmcmillen/status/1441509467758030852

View attachment 7725690
https://x.com/edmundmcmillen/status/1649308895641505792
Linked video
I remember that Mike from RLM had a video where he was recording a voice for it as well so yea its pretty wide spread on the spectrum.
Knowing binding of Isaac and how huge the diversity of things are in it and seeing the trailer I dont really expect her to be cut there is gonna be like 100 cats and even more items and enemies.
 
Back
Top Bottom