- Joined
- Nov 4, 2017
When bad things happen, it's never the fault of the method those people use to communicate that they did the bad thing. The paternalist in all of us can be seduced by the lulling rhetoric of "we must stop fake news because it's causing lynchings." However, you boil that down to its Orwellian essence and you get "we must control the information people see in order to control their behaviour" which doesn't sound nearly as good. Does any of us really want someone in charge of deciding for us what is true and what is false, and how long do you think it's going to be before they start using that power to manipulate us for their own benefit?
What's happening in India is what is bound to happen when you drop first world telecommunication infrastructure on a third world community. This is exactly how criminals and other reprobates were handled in the pre-modern era. Before we had jails and police, social ostracism, banishment and lynchings were the tools people used to enforce societal norms. Many, many Indians still live in that society. There's amusing expressions of the fact we have pre-modern people on our modern internet, vis. show bobs and vagene, and there's the less amusing part that people are forming themselves in to lynch mobs to tackle criminals, and sometimes they get their targets wrong. India needs to work on trust in the police and making it so most people's encounters with officialdom are positive and not excuses to extort a bribe. Blaming their societal ills on a messaging app is just stupid.
This is a really good post, inspite of the Firefly clip.