different strokes for different folks. for example konosuba is popular and I even got a few mates raving about it, but that kind of humor simply doesn't work for me.
as for slice of life, it's easy to cram everything under that genre since it's broad af, but not everything is the same. comic girls is one of my favorite anime and as moeshit as it gets, meanwhile I couldn't finish takagi-san since it's basically the same every time with the protag getting dunked on which is just boring for me, both technically count as SoL.
if you liked nagatoro and uzaki, the rom-com stuff might be more your thing (nothing wrong with it I like that shit too, and it's not really something you find in the west anymore unless you go full HAM with hallmark movies). aharen-san is currently airing (although I wouldn't necessarily call that romantic), my dress-up darling from winter this year, some of doga kobo's (nozaki-kun, engaged to the unidentified S2 never ever, maybe even all in with tadakoi), blend s etc. might even be worth to check out one of the classics like k-on (no romance but the definition of SOL) or other kyoani stuff like chuunibyo. or maybe go in the other direction with some "haremshit" like 5toubun, bokuben or saekano oreimo if you want to rage hard. there's also nisekoi and toradora but haven't watched them yet.