For Christ's sake, it's like he lurks here (especially with the line about the forehead during the flashback to him getting picked on). The reason people disagree with his sketches is that a lot of them aren't funny and are forced, and the analysis can be really obvious. If they were funny and he wasn't unconsciously coming off as pretentious then it would be funny. I mean, sometimes when he adds plots, they can be really good, like the one for Son of the Mask, or the Shining, or The Wicker Man, or Planet of the Apes. Those actually made me laugh. Other times it's "so-and-so has forced me to review this." Oh look, a cutaway gag, gotta use Malcolm and Tamera somehow, if it works for Family Guy...
He made it so that he now has two weeks to write, film, and make a review. He should use that to, you know, actually write jokes that work.
To summarize, it's not the format that's the problem, it's the content.