A question for the guys [serious]

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

eDove

Coo coo
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
Joined
Dec 29, 2020
I have a female friend who's, in theory, perfect trad-wife material. She's 25-26 years old (unsure of the exact age), an ardent believer in Christ, having grown up in the church her father pastored. She is a fine cook, a great homemaker, and very, very sweet. There's no corruption or craziness whatsoever, and she is looking forward to being married and starting a family.

There's one problem though and it's a glaring one. She puts zero effort into her appearance, maybe even less than zero. She brushes her hair and has color-coordinated outfits, but that's about it.

Let it be known that I am not a woman who fusses with her appearance much at all. I don't look down on those who choose the natural approach. I don't wear makeup. I don't style my hair. I don't even have pierced ears... but I do try to make myself look appealing. She doesn't.

What am I talking about specifically? For starters, she was born with a condition where one of her eyes is way droopier than the other. I think it's called ptosis. It's whatever. It's kind of out of her control (I'm pretty sure there are corrective surgeries but you get the point).

She has a THICK unibrow which can be fixed easily. You try to avoid looking at the droopy eye and there's a big 'ole unibrow staring back at you. Based off that alone, you'd be right in assuming she doesn't manage the hair anywhere else on her body. One hot day, I saw the entirety of her calves and they were covered in long hairs.

Her teeth are crooked, bucked, jutting, and always look like they're covered in plaque. This is a big point of cringe for me. I don't know what's going on there. Maybe she doesn't brush her teeth? I haven't asked. It's a vulgar thing to say, but I highly doubt she keeps her pubic hair trimmed or shaves her asscrack, nor deliberately washes those places, if you cratch my drift.

She presents herself in a way that'd only attract creepy dudes, in my opinion. It's hard to describe, but nothing in her wardrobe is mature or flattering to her body. Very boxy, a step down from the Amish, shape-wise. She dresses like a modest 9-year-old girl.

You can absolutely be modest while coming off as an adult... I guess she doesn't realize that. You wouldn't believe she was a grown-up if you saw her, especially since she's shorter than me and I'm only five feet tall.

She's confused that guys ignore her and I truly think they're mistaking her for a kid half of the time. Being sheltered her whole life made her naive, mousy, and unable to hold a conversation. She looks and acts like a little kid.

I've tried very gently to tell her how she can attract male attention, where she could make broad improvements. Her response is always, "my mom says I don't have to change myself at all. If I have to change myself for a guy, then he's obviously not the right one."

Well, yeah... there's a big difference between maintaining your appearance and changing your personality to suit a guy. I've told her that too. She doesn't get it.

If it wasn't obvious, she's still living with her parents. They're basically hundred-year-old boomers and who seem unrealistic/deluded in this regard. Women in their day didn't have to compete with exposure to literal super models and porn stars.

I don't want to be mean or hurt her feelings but I'm woried about her. She so, so badly wants to have a boyfriend and get married. She's convinced God's gonna bring him to her any day now 'cause she's having "dreams" and old church ladies are telling her God's "preparing" her for a husband 'cause she's had to do more house work lately. But maybe a potential mate is already around, he just has a hard time getting past her appearance?

There's a single guy she has a massive crush on at church who she's known for years. He seems reasonably disinterested even though she checks all his boxes.

My Kiwi dudes, does this kind of stuff actually matter to you or am I being a huge superficial bitch? This is a genuine question. Is my concern unfounded? Would you take the trad-wife pill under these circumstances?

I don't think she'd extend the same no-effort courtesy to a boyfriend. She's into the clean-cut guys who dress well.
 
Last edited:
How would you view a guy in this same scenario? That's probably how most men would feel about her. It indicates that there's something wrong in her head and that's going to put anyone off of her before they get to know her as a person.

She could try to get with a metalhead though. Those guys live and eat grime and I doubt they'd care to much if she doesn't brush her teeth or shave.
 
How would you view a guy in this same scenario? That's probably how most men would feel about her. It indicates that there's something wrong in her head and that's going to put anyone off of her before they get to know her as a person.

She could try to get with a metalhead though. Those guys live and eat grime and I doubt they'd care to much if she doesn't brush her teeth or shave.
That's my perspective too. If a guy didn't take care of his appearance it'd be a turn-off. This applies to every human being, period.

She'd 100% think metal music is evil, and men having long hair. In fact, when I met her, she didn't listen to any music at all except for hymns at church. She just recently started dipping her toes into country music 🙃
 
Last edited:
I'd honestly assume she had some kind of condition. One or even two of those things isn't a dealbreaker but all of it combined with her attitude about it makes me think she's got some kind of mental defect or that she's been in a neglectful household. Being so short, having fucked up teeth and being so out of touch with people all together? It seems a bit too much to be a coincidence and I'd assume something has to be behind it.
 
I don't believe it, I don't believe someone like that doesn't have some weird shit you're going to find out that they conceal under normal circumstances. She probably keeps baby dolls and is hiding a jar of old used tampons under her bed.

Also it isn't just for the opposite sex, it's also about looking presentable in general. You are expected to kind of adhere to some standard of social grace in how you dress and style yourself, so your partner feels proud, or at least not embarrassed, to bring you into public.

There are a lot of women out there that are fairly average in the looks department but are loving and make an attempt, and that counts for a lot, but if some <5' bitch with a unibrow, hairy legs, and brown crooked teeth is walking around in doll clothing you're going to assume there's something wrong with her.

Anyways, none of the most vocal trad-wife fetishists on the internet would go for a homely trad girl regardless. When these dudes say they say they want a "trad wife", they actually mean they want a young virginal 10/10 knockout blond who will have sex with them and take care of them like their mother, and expects almost nothing out of them in return.
 
She'd 100% think metal music is evil, and men having long hair is evil. In fact, when I met her, she didn't listen to any music at all except for hymns at church. She just recently started dipping her toes into country music 🙃
Get her into Christian metal. Power Wolf is good.

I'd sit her down and explain to her that yes, she shouldn't have to change her whole personality, but people are going to judge her by the way that she presents herself and if she's looking for a boyfriend/husband that first impressions mean everything. Give her baby steps, try to start out with dental hygiene and work her up from there.
 
One or two of those things, maybe forgiven. All of them at once would make me feel like something was wrong with her, and make me completely disregard all else.

Get her to brush first. Everything else can be slowly improved, but having someone not want to step near her disqualifies any other work she may put in.
Ask her if a guy with her same interests approached her, except he doesn't shower, shave, work out, wears dirty clothes, never brushes his teeth, and lived with his parents, if she'd go gaga for him.
 
I'd honestly assume she had some kind of condition. One or even two of those things isn't a dealbreaker but all of it combined with her attitude about it makes me think she's got some kind of mental defect or that she's been in a neglectful household. Being so short, having fucked up teeth and being so out of touch with people all together? It seems a bit too much to be a coincidence and I'd assume something has to be behind it.
I don't think you're far off the mark. She's the second youngest of nine siblings. Was homeschooled. No Internet, TV, or non-church friends. Nothing. I feel bad for her 'cause she's extremely naive about societal expectations. Her parents repeatedly tell her she doesn't have change one bit and God will bring her a man. All she has to do is wait. It seems quite negligent.

Her brothers and sisters all look nice. Her parents also make an effort to look nice, so I don't know why they're sabotaging her. Maybe they don't want their baby to grow up and fly the nest?
 
Maybe they don't want their baby to grow up and fly the nest?
I actually knew of a case kind of like this with a girl before. For her though she wasn't even homeschooled but she at least was able to watch TV and use the internet. For her, her mother wanted to basically use her to take care of her as she got older. She had an older sibling if I remember correctly but he cut contact with the mom and wasn't that great of a person either, but it seems like the mother didn't want a repeat of having a kid totally cut themselves out of her life.

Have you ever been to her house before? The girl I'm referring to, her mother was a hoarder and the house was in abysmal condition. I also agree with @Hitchhiker on starting with the teeth first:
Give her baby steps, try to start out with dental hygiene and work her up from there.
You can make her dental issues all about her health and making her feel better without any part of it being about getting approval from others. Rotting teeth are a major health concern and can lead to serious infections -- beyond just the decline in quality of life from bleeding from your gums daily and the pain. Also if it's dental plaque then it's an issue with flossing, more likely. You need to make it clear to her that she needs to see a dentist on that ASAP or else her gums will recede enough that she'll lose teeth.
 
You will grow old, fat, ugly, and gay and so will your spouse. Beauty is fleeting.

But since your friend looks like a mutated molerat, I can see why anyone who dates her might develop resentment.

My ex put zero effort into her appearance to the point where she was wiping her dirty hands on her clothes after eating. I gave her a pass since she was physically hot.

Inb4 TMI react
 
Have you ever been to her house before? The girl I'm referring to, her mother was a hoarder and the house was in abysmal condition.
I have been to their home. Thankfully, it's in excellent condition. Organized. Comfortable. It seems like the naivete runs deep and they're unwittingly setting her up for disappointment. Although, I'm pretty sure she's the only kid who didn't move out of state, so maybe they are trying to keep her undatable. Perhaps without realizing it? I understand them not wanting to see their daughter as a sexual being, but she's gonna be thirty in a few years.

Your story reminds me a lot of the last maladjusted girl who glommed onto me. Youngest of seven, mom was super involved in her church, yet all her kids were messed up degenerates—except for the youngest, who behaved like an 11-year-old at the age of twenty. She was cute, but I remember her teeth being kind of gross too. Her mom relied on her for babysitting the thousand or so grandkids.

She ended up having a tween rebellious phase in her mid-twenties, decided she was an atheist, a lesbian, and then starting crushing on guys again a few months later. She was (mis)diagnosed as Bipolar and made a big deal about that, then she was finally diagnosed as autistic. I didn't have the energy for that shit, lol.

The dental hygiene is good advice. It's tricky when you're dealing with someone who's convinced themselves that not beautifying yourself at all is a virtue.

***I want to add that she'd be quite attractive if she made some of these changes.
 
I have been to their home. Thankfully, it's in excellent condition. Organized. Comfortable. It seems like the naivete runs deep and they're unwittingly setting her up for disappointment.
That's good at least. I do wonder about her diet though. Being short and having malocclusion(crowded teeth more so) are associated with malnutrition growing up. Since you mentioned her being very naive and she's quite set in her ways, I can't help but wonder if she might not also be autistic. Older parents at the time of conception raises the likelihood of the resulting child being autistic(and just having disorders in general), but normally it's not an issue until the parent(s) hit about 40 as that's when the rate significantly increases. Just look at CWC's parents and their ages. If she is autistic though then it might help to check in on her diet to see what she eats and it's very likely that her diet growing up wasn't too good.

Also, that other girl sounds like a handful. Hope things work out with this sweet church girl though and she gets to marry the guy of her dreams.
 
I despise this misguided idea that being Christian means you can expect to be an unfuckable slob and it's everyone else's problem that you can't land a guy/girl. Loving God is not an acceptable excuse for not trying at all to look in any way decent of you want to also have a mate.

I am with other people itt that the parents want to keep her around as a house nigger. It happens. A lot of her problems won't be solved until she moves out and accept that she is a human being with agency.

Tell her to read song of Solomon. That is downright smutty.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom