Prayer works in a roundabout way. Knowing that somebody gives enough of a shit about you to take a minute out of their life makes you a little more hopeful / less stressed, which I think is an underemphasized medical concern.
Indeed, and studies have proven both sides of this coin. If someone sincerely believes in the power of prayer, they should pray if they're in trouble. If you're trapped in a cave, for example, being calmer will help you use less oxygen, increasing the odds you're rescued.
However, whenever prayer has been studied "in the lab," the results have never been better than chance: The prayed-for person gets better half the time and gets worse half the time. Interestingly, the only time we see a non-chance outcome is when the prayed-for person
knows they're being prayed for. In that case, they get worse.
Jack growls into his phone to make a post on X lying about scooting up to people to brag that he’s going to pray for them
This reminds me of that one F As In Frank where Jim revealed that Jack randomly texts him things like, "I just prayed for you." Cringe because fake.
There is nothing cringe about
sincerely praying for people to succeed in a mean, often cruel world. But when you make your whole personality,
Look what a good Christian I am! while you seethe about all the American cities you "hope burn to the ground," not only do I not care if you get curbstomped, but also I hope your beating is filmed and set to Yakety Sax.
If god were real, he would already know that the person was sick or whatever and prayer would do no good because he'd already know what he's going to do.
I understand you're talking about the classic Abrahamic god (which Jack and probably the vast majority of us here believe in), but there is no rule stating that a god must be all of the "omni's." If a god who is omnipotent but
not omniscient and who
can be swayed by requests is out there, then your statement is 'defeated.'
But again, I understand the spirit (no pun intended) of the dilemma you're trying to point out. I'm not at all chuffed and am replying only as someone who enjoys rhetoric.
Edited to be less wordy. Still failed! Ha.