The Official Simpsons Griefing Thread

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Yeah, this whole reacasting nonsense has only highlighted the problems with not only the show itself, but the people involved. I'd say "fuck Hank Azaria and his cowardly ass", but considering how the bitch let that Problem with Apu whiner go to town on him, he'd probably like that.
 
Ozzy Osbourne - Mama, I'm Coming Home
homernheaven.png
 
Groening speaks out:

The Simpsons creator Matt Groening on equality, memes and monorails

The Simpsons creator Matt Groening doesn't do many interviews. Apparently, he announces at the start of ours, he doesn't "have much more to say".

Forty minutes later, after diving through topics from his latest Netflix show to memes and... er, monorails, it's clear he was wrong - there's plenty still to discuss.

Not least, accusations that some of The Simpsons' ethnic minority characters, all historically voiced by white actors, encourage harmful stereotypes.

After a backlash prompted by a 2018 documentary called The Problem With Apu, the show has spent the last year re-casting its non-white roles.

"Times change," Matt tells us, "but I actually didn't have a problem with the way we were doing it.

"All of our actors play dozens of characters each, it was never designed to exclude anyone."

At first, the show's response was along these lines too. Within an episode, Lisa looked directly into the camera, saying: "Something that started decades ago and was applauded and inoffensive is now politically incorrect. What can you do?"

Eventually, though, The Simpsons backtracked and announced it was making changes after all.

The latest came on Monday, when it was reported that Harry Shearer is to be replaced as the voice of Dr Hibbert by Kevin Michael Richardson, known for his voice work on American Dad! and Family Guy.

Asked whether he regrets how they handled it, Matt says: "At a certain point it doesn't matter what you say. You're going to be attacked by whoever, you know?

"We're not going out of our way to comfort bigots. On the other hand, if you do any kind of gesture and people perceive a weakness, you'll be criticised."

He does, however, accept that change was needed - and not just with actors, but across the entire industry.

"I absolutely agree with that. And we're trying to make it better," he says.

"Bigotry and racism are still an incredible problem and it's good to finally go for more equality and representation."

Matt is speaking to us over Zoom from the chair he's been "sitting on since the beginning of the pandemic".

He's working on new episodes of his Netflix series, Disenchantment, but before we got into that, we had to address the monorail in the room.

When he first doodled a smiley yellow family, he probably didn't expect, 30 years later, to be apologising to the monorail community.

He looks a bit upset when we point out that The Monorail Society, made up of 14,000 members worldwide, is on record saying The Simpsons has a lot to answer for.

"I don't know what to say, I'm sorry," he laughs, "That's a by-product of our viciousness."

The episode we're talking about - one of the show's most iconic - is Marge Versus the Monorail, where the town of Springfield is conned into ploughing all its money into a doomed public transport system.

It was first shown in 1993, but became so popular with fans that it's been blamed for the fact single-railed trains aren't always taken as seriously as their double-railed cousins.

"You're up off the ground and you're above traffic. Monorails are great," Matt says.

"So it makes me sad, but at the same time if something's going to happen in The Simpsons, it's going to go wrong, right?"

A small impact on town planning is possibly not that big a deal in the context of a show that's been going longer than many of its fans have been alive, is broadcast in dozens of languages, and has predicted the future several times.

"It's unbelievable," Matt says. "I just couldn't have imagined it back in the day when I was a struggling cartoonist, drawing on a wobbly card table in my kitchen."

All big Simpsons fans probably spend more time than we'd like to admit scrolling through Simpsons meme pages.

But surely the man who invented the whole thing can't be as sad as the rest of us, can he?

"Yes! Of course I look at the memes", Matt laughs, "some of them are great, some of them make me cringe.

"Back in my pre-animation days, I had a weekly comic strip called Life in Hell. I remember walking down the street and seeing a newspaper in the gutter covered with water, but it had my strip on it.

"It made me feel like I'd arrived, that I was part of the landscape. Now with fan art and cosplay and memes, it's just a global version of the newspaper in the gutter."

Disenchantment, which is now on its third series, is about "taking the genre of fantasy and fairy tales and seeing how far I can go with it," Matt says.

Even though he's technically crept past retirement age, he's got no plans to stop any time soon - and says he's got ideas in the pipeline for other shows too.

"Doing Disenchantment is about the most fun I ever have. I get to work with some of the funniest smartest people around and play with them and tell stories. It's just a blast.

"I have a bunch of kids, and they're downstairs right now playing and I feel like I'm up here in my office playing too."

 
One joke I like from "crappingly new" episodes is when Bart pronounces "cottage" in cottage cheese as "coat-a-heh".
 
"Times change," Matt tells us, "but I actually didn't have a problem with the way we were doing it.

"All of our actors play dozens of characters each, it was never designed to exclude anyone."

. . .

Asked whether he regrets how they handled it, Matt says: "At a certain point it doesn't matter what you say. You're going to be attacked by whoever, you know?

"We're not going out of our way to comfort bigots. On the other hand, if you do any kind of gesture and people perceive a weakness, you'll be criticised."

He does, however, accept that change was needed - and not just with actors, but across the entire industry.

"I absolutely agree with that. And we're trying to make it better," he says.
I wonder if you could hear the gun cock behind Matt in the zoom call.
 
The sad decline of The Simpsons

In the latest episode of 'Americans Do the Funniest Things,' it has emerged that The Simpsons is to replace the white voice actor for the character of Dr. Julius Hibbert with a black actor.

Hibbert, for those who don’t know him, is a mainstay of the show — a family doctor recognised by his white lab coat, gentle manner and signature chuckle. He is perhaps the least offensive character, despite being a Republican, a suspected morphine addict, and a member of Mensa, who revised his official position on the safety of binge eating after buying a 12 per cent stake in an all-you-can-eat restaurant, and who won’t conduct unethical procedures himself, but is more than happy to give you the number of a doctor who will.

Over the years, The Simpsons has had an interesting relationship with racial stereotypes — often wrong-footing the assumptions of the era: a character with Hibbert’s traits would almost certainly have been cast as white in any other show. But then if you were a fan, you’d know this show was never lazy — its other major black character, nuclear technician Carl Carlson, despite his flaws, is, like Hibbert, the only capable professional in his line of work. The Simpsons' only Jewish character, meanwhile, Herschel 'Krusty the Clown' Krustofsky, is wildly successful despite being desperately unfunny (at least, when he tries). The Simpsons knows all about America’s views on its minorities, and loves to poke fun at those prejudices.

But of course, any show that acknowledges that race is a factor in American life is liable to be attacked before others for drawing attention to itself. And The Simpsons' has been here before. Harry Kondabolu's documentary on the character of Apu, the Indian-American owner of the Kwik-E-Mart convenience store, resulted in the removal of the white voice actor who played the part, Hank Azaria.

The logic was that white actors shouldn’t be allowed to depict the 'lived experiences' of groups to which they don’t belong. What’s more, they shouldn’t be taking paid acting jobs from minorities. It’s a strange time to be in the profession — though this famously liberal industry would never admit it.

While white actors must not take on roles that are too dissimilar from their own lives, we've also witnessed the rise of 'colour-blind' casting in shows like Bridgerton. A black woman must be allowed to portray Anne Boleyn, for instance - to do so makes an important statement about the inclusivity of the present vs the exclusivity of history. Accuracy matters little when the politics is right on.

The same professional minefield surrounds sexuality on screen. Woe betide a straight man cast as a gay character, say, who cannot possibly know the struggles such a person has undergone. The nonsense of all this, of course, is that we’re talking about acting - a profession that, in its essence, is about convincingly embodying another person's experience.

Replacing Dr Hibbert’s actor with a person of colour will neither add to the character nor detract from it — the show’s writers wouldn’t have dared pick someone whose voice differed too greatly from Shearer’s, so established is the role. But it erects barriers in a profession where artistic freedom ought to be at the centre of how business is conducted.

US viewing figures for the Simpsons have steadily declined over the years from just under 15 million in 2001 to 3.1 million in 2019. The Simpsons somehow stumbles on decades after its launch precisely because, all those years ago, artistic freedom created a masterpiece of pop culture. If it stops being able to poke fun at the society that engendered it then fans will continue to switch off.

 
So out of morbid curiosity, I watched the new episode to see how Hibbert's new VA sounds like.

Much like Carl's new VA, he's practically the uncanny valley. He sort of sounds like Harry, but it's just so... off.

Oh, and the show acknowledged Social Justice Warriors, and gave them a very flattering description. So... yeah.
 
So out of morbid curiosity, I watched the new episode to see how Hibbert's new VA sounds like.

Much like Carl's new VA, he's practically the uncanny valley. He sort of sounds like Harry, but it's just so... off.

Oh, and the show acknowledged Social Justice Warriors, and gave them a very flattering description. So... yeah.
Honestly if you didn't tell me if they recast Judge Snyder I probably wouldn't have noticed. Probably because Judge Snyder is one of the least memorable original characters the Simpsons have who only served to move the story along. His voice was just styled to be one of authority so such a change doesn't hamper anything.

But Dr. Hibbert, yeah this is a bad change. In my ears he just doesn't sound anything like Dr. Hibbert whose voice by Harry Shearer reflected a friendly caring warmth.

Anyway I came to the thread because I'm seeing people discuss Jim Henson's Dinosaurs. It reminded me of how classic Simpsons threw direct shade on that show.
I really don't understand why The Simpsons writing team clearly thought Dinosaurs was ripping them off. I guess you could argue that the lead Earl SNEED Sinclair was a Homer Simpson-esque TV Father as he was a bumbling but well meaning blue collar Dad. But The Simpsons certainly didn't invent such a character, could argue that Dinosaurs was likely inspired by John Goodman's "Dan Connor." The alleged ripping off totally falls apart trying to say Robbie and Baby Sinclair were rip offs of Bart and Maggie.

The Dinosaurs Wikipedia page does say that the show only got Greenlit due to The Simpson's breakout success, but I don't see how The Simpsons team could have been mad that American television was daring to be more experimental in an attempt to produce more breakout comedies. Still this scene is one of the odder moments of the show being downright petty.
 
Back
Top Bottom