The Holocaust Thread - The Great Debate Between Affirmers, Revisionists and Deniers

[The Tall Man]

You're right, I've been speculating, which is why this conversation is dumb. I don't know exactly how they planned to use the gas chamber, and it doesn't matter, because there's no good evidence it was even used. The only thing that matters here is your assertion that it proves the existence of a hoax to fake a genocide, something which you've lost track of amidst your long line of questions.

Do you believe the Allies added piping to fake a gas chamber?

So you have no idea and you are just speculating and your speculations are completely irrational.
You don't even seem to try and make a rational case for how the gas chamber worked.

So why should anyone take you seriously?

Build a rational scenario of how the gassing of the Brausebad worked.

and it doesn't matter, because there's no good evidence it was even used

You can't prove a negative.
But you failed to even construct a rational scenario.

was part of any industrialized genocide

You didn't manage to make rational case for a single gas chamber, on what basis do you make this assertion?

 

[Bonesjones]

They didn't have access to mobile heaters?

Why would they need them considering there are giant furnaces only tens of feet away? Or did you forget what you are talking about again?

They probably would be freaked out, yeah. But less so because it looked a shower.

"People keep going in this building and never coming out. I bet nothing nefarious is going on, let's go shower"

You're right, I've been speculating, which is why this conversation is dumb. I don't know exactly how they planned to use the gas chamber, and it doesn't matter, because there's no good evidence it was even used. The only thing that matters here is your assertion that it proves the existence of a hoax to fake a genocide, something which you've lost track of amidst your long line of questions.

Do you believe the Allies added piping to fake a gas chamber?

It's dumb because you constantly show your own mental retardation in the truest sense, you can't keep anything straight. You don't know what you are even arguing. You just spout words in a vaguely English language with no basis in anything.

Yes making a fake gas chamber does disprove the holocaust. Why would they need to make fake ones if they had real ones. Why would they need to fake a genocide if they have evidence of a real one?

Why do you constantly have to dig your own grave when the evidence should exist to not do so?

Yeah and waddya know, no one believes it was part of any industrialized genocide, as you stated here

Yeah that's the funny part, no one was killed in a fake gas chamber that someone created. You argue how they would have used a fake gas chamber forgetting that it was fake to begin with.


So why did the Nazis make a fake gas chamber?

 

[Chugger]

So you have no idea and you are just speculating and your speculations are completely irrational.
You don't even seem to try and make a rational case for how the gas chamber worked.

So why should anyone take you seriously?

Build a rational scenario of how the gassing of the Brausebad worked.

Merely saying something is irrational doesn't mean it is irrational. Newton's Laws are irrational. You see how that works?

Like I didn't just say your beliefs about the "scary pipes" were irrational, I explained why, to the extent that now you avoid all mention of them.

 

[The Tall Man]

Merely saying something is irrational doesn't mean it is irrational.

I explained to you why it is irrational, you doofus.
It would take multiple hours. It would cause panic before the brausebad is closed.
The inmates could push the granulate into the drains.
The inmates could swallow the granulate.
The Germans would gas themselves.

If that sounds rational to you, you might be insane.

I explained why

What was your explanation because I don't see it posted in this thread.
You just reposted half of Pressac's explanation from a book by Mattogno that debunks Pressac's explanation.

You have not even made a statement why my beliefs about the "scary pipes" are wrong.

 

[Chugger]

It would take multiple hours. It would cause panic before the brausebad is closed.

Ok let's start with this one. They could preheat the room, as I said.

What was your explanation because I don't see it posted in this thread.
You just reposted half of Pressac's explanation from a book by Mattogno that debunks Pressac's explanation.

You have not even made a statement why my beliefs about the "scary pipes" are wrong.

Sure, I can do this and show you. But what are your beliefs about the scary pipes exactly?

 

[Chugger]

You just reposted half of Pressac's explanation from a book by Mattogno that debunks Pressac's explanation.

I'm not sure about this. Check the book page 43. It's Mattogno's words, unless Pressac talks about himself in the third person lol.

 

[The Tall Man]

Ok let's start with this one. They could preheat the room, as I said.

There are no portable heaters means it didn't happen.

But what are your beliefs about the scary pipes exactly?

So you lied?

Like I didn't just say your beliefs about the "scary pipes" were irrational, I explained why,

How can you explain why I am wrong about my conclusion if you don't know what my conclusion is?

It's Mattogno's words, unless Pressac talks about himself in the third person lol.

You are so smug about being retarded, he talk about how that fan would have been insufficient to evacuate a chamber from poison gas and was for bringing in fresh air.

MATTOGNO ∙ THE DACHAU GAS CHAMBER Page 51



Odd that the fan and motor are missing and only the housing is there.

Anyone with even the slightest clue about ventilation knows this is not big enough to be a evacuation system and is just a simple fresh air ventilation system.

 

[Chugger]

There are no portable heaters means it didn't happen.

What do you mean there are no portable heaters? Like the Germans didn't have access to that technology or what haha

How can you explain why I am wrong about my conclusion if you don't know what my conclusion is?

I think I know what you were saying, I just want to make sure you still believe that.

 

[The Tall Man]

I think I know what you were saying, I just want to make sure you still believe that.

You aren't good at lying you should just stick to telling the truth or being quiet.
I have said very little explicitly so you would not try and derail the conversation, I have not stated my theory about the Brausebad.

What do you mean there are no portable heaters?

Playing or being dumb again, I really can't tell.


Where are the portable heaters they used?
Why is no holocaust propagandist or revisionist speaking about them?

 

[Chugger]

I have not stated my theory about the Brausebad.

You stated that the pipes had no function "they begin and end in the wall" and "are just there to look spooky" :

The Nazis even added scary industrial big valves and pipes on the outside, which only a Nazi or congressman that comes to visity would ever see.
Why did the Nazis add big scary pipes that begin and end in the wall?
They are just there to look spooky, why did the Nazis do that?

You stickin to that buddy?

Where are the portable heaters they used?
Why is no holocaust propagandist or revisionist speaking about them?

I said I was speculating and you said my speculations were irrational. Is my speculation that the Nazis had access to portable heaters irrational?

The reason Holocaust historians aren't talking about them at Dachau (they're mentioned at other camps) is because nobody really cares about the pitiful spergeries of deniers, especially about a gas chamber that is believed to have been non-operational. At Auschwitz and other places minor issues like this have been given some time. On the other hand Mattogno wrote an entire book about the Dachau gas chambers, so it's a much bigger priority for you guys.

 

[The Tall Man]

Is my speculation that the Nazis had access to portable heaters irrational?

It's irrational to believe nobody mentioned that the Nazis had to preheat the Brausebad with space heaters or to assume that they would build something so cumbersome or that there is no evidence of the space heater storage.

On the other hand Mattogno wrote an entire book about the Dachau gas chambers

Funny, he didn't mention anything about space heaters in the Shower.

You stickin to that buddy?

Create a reasonable scenario of how the Brausebad operated, and I will give you mine.

 

[Chugger]

It's irrational to believe nobody mentioned that the Nazis had to preheat the Brausebad with space heaters or to assume that they would build something so cumbersome or that there is no evidence of the space heater storage.

Why is it irrational nobody mentioned they had to preheat? There's no evidence of gassings and yet you demand evidence of the space being preheated for them. This is getting silly.

 

[The Tall Man]

Why is it irrational nobody mentioned they had to preheat? There's no evidence of gassings and yet you demand evidence of the space being preheated for them.

or to assume that they would build something so cumbersome

Can you read?
Where is the nearby storage room with the space heater? Where is the protocol mentioning the space heater?

This is getting silly.

Yes you are being a silly billy.

 

[Chugger]

Can you read?

I want to go through this point by point. I guess you have no complaints with the way I addressed your first point "It's irrational to believe nobody mentioned that the Nazis had to preheat the Brausebad with space heaters", so we can move onto your second, "it's irrational to believe they would build something so cumbersome". I have no idea what you're talking about here, you mean a portable heater?

 

[Chugger]

Create a reasonable scenario of how the Brausebad operated, and I will give you mine.

Oh I missed this. I already gave you mine. So you don't think it's reasonable. Big surprise. Well what's yours?

 

[The Tall Man]

Oh I missed this. I already gave you mine. So you don't think it's reasonable. Big surprise. Well what's yours?

It's objectively irrational.
I was nice enough to explain to you why. Stop being lazy and read the thread.

Come up with something rational.

 

[Betonhaus]

 

[Chugger]

It's objectively irrational.
I was nice enough to explain to you why. Stop being lazy and read the thread.

Come up with something rational.

Even so, what's your view? You said before the pipes "begin and end in the wall" and are just there to look scary, are you still going with that?

 

[The Tall Man]

Even so, what's your view?

If you can't come up with a rational model than admit to your inability to do so, state it clearly.

 

[hideandgoseekchampion]

if i was schindler i'd save alot of jews. only the really hot jewish women though. I would expect blowjobs/sex from them on a daily basis though.