mrolonzo is going to squirm and execute every escape move he knows to get out of this question, but ultimately he won't be able to answer it
i think he can say the USSR could have destroyed all German documentary evidence of resettlement, which may have been millions of documents. they would have needed a veritable army of document destroyers to get every single one before they were discovered but I suppose it would be possible, if they were extremely lucky. but the thing about the silenced witnesses is unresolvable, or would require some form of technology yet unknown to man
Having thought about this thread it becomes more clear what's going on.
1. HS and Chugger generally wish to engage us as long as they think they can get a point or get one over on us rhetorically.
2. Stan simply wishes to abuse and manipulate us.
3. Aves tries the good cop routine, offering a friendly, understanding tone, then when satisfactory answers aren't provided goes "just tell us where they are!", refusing to undertake to understand the issue.
When they cannot get one over on us rhetorically, as often with me, they instead simply;
1. Stop actually quoting what I say and either address me on another point.
2. Refer to me in posts to each other when as usual slapping each other on the back for being so smart.
Again we see, the point here is dissemination of their propaganda. Not discussion.
Anyhoo…
1. Our peddlers, as said previously, have admitted they cannot defend their holocaust on the physics or the technical details.
2. They can however, offer carbon copies of documents that imply terrible deeds and simply repeat at us about the "mountains of evidence", tell us and each other that we are dumb etc.
3. And what they can also do, is ask questions about the demographic numbers.
They can tell us that "there must have been traces of these millions of Jews in the east!!"
'Why? Because I say so!'
'There would be easily enough Jewish people for a city!!
Where is this Jewlantis!! Here is a meme I created about Jewlantis! It's even got Mike Enoch and Matthew Heimbach on it! I don't know why! It just does!'
If there is no Jewlantis, then, they tell us, the Jewlanteans must instead of sinking under the sea were sunk under the earth. By the nazis.
However, just like Atlantis residents were never found under the sea, neither have the residents of Jewlantis been found under the earth.…
How do we know? Because whenever codoh asks our peddlers to outwit us all by providing such evidence they refuse to answer. Our Chugger here even going so far as to tell us that it doesn't matter that he for example cannot provide bodies from Belzec!
But nevertheless, where there are gaps, our peddlers can then tell us that these gaps are Jews currently buried in Auschwitz, the AR camps, Babi Yar and various unknown locations around eastern Europe where the four EG groups operated.
No need for actual hard evidence, bodies, credible mechanism etc.
........
However, Revisionists have actually not shied away from the numbers issue.
I myself, less than a mere novice having done limited reading written no essays and conducted no studies, tend to think very few relatively died.
However, that's just me, and my opinion, like our peddlers opinion, none of us being serious scholars of the subject, is worthless.
………..
So the first famous demographic contribution ( there are many other reports and studies as you might imagine but they are limited in scope as far as I know) was, as far as I can tell, was by political science Don Raul Hilberg in 1961. Despite the struggle to get published in the end it's a major success...
en.m.wikipedia.org
Later, Walter Sanning spoils the party and writes The dissolution of the European jewry 1983 originally then updated in 2015;
New Insights into the Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry
by Walter N. Sanning 2017
This study dramatically undermines any six million notion, bringing it down to several hundred thousand at most of Jews dead in ww2.
Obviously, holocaust peddlers were not happy, so this is published a few years later;
Wolfgang Benz editor/ contributor 1991 Dimension des Völkermords (The Dimension of
Genocide)
Institut für Zeitge-
schicht.
This is the general Orthodox or exterminationist study of the demographic statistics. Wolfgang Benz oversees a number of different authors taking each country in turn.
Then we have Germar Rudolf's comparative analysis of these two studies;
Holocaust Victims: A Statistical Analysis
W. Benz and W. N. Sanning – A Comparison
GERMAR RUDOLF
codoh.com
Which includes reference to a detailed analysis of The Koherr reports by Steven Challens who concludes that Koherr mis represents the amount evacuated east by about 1 million for the purpose of saving face for Himmler.
Richard Korherr and His Reports:
A Translation and Commentary
by Stephen Challen
Germar details the clear difference between these in approach.
You will not be surprised to see which is the better study.…
Obviously again, our peddlers are not happy.
But did any subsequent major work come out from exterminationist or peddler scholars to combat all this?
Not so far. But,
When recently, two months ago, analysis by Alt Hype, a young man who definitely understands statistics, in a video format mostly following Sannings work …
…..comes out with maps shown as attached and a relevant codoh thread;
our own HS, refusing to let this stand, says this;
"Also, it is interesting that Faulk/Alt Hyp ignores the Nazis own data on the number of Jews under their occupation, as reflected in the Wannsee protocols and the Korherr Report. The Nazi data was based on censuses (the Polish Jews, after being stuffed into ghettos, had to conduct regular censuses of their numbers, and these data informed the Kroherr Report and the Wannsee data.)"
He is then asked by codoh if he has these censuses.
He declined to respond. This was two months ago.
But this critique of his was actually already tried ten years before by Jonathan Harrison on the HC blog, who HS and Chugger regularly go to while criticising everyone else when we post revisionists authors. Thereby just wasting everyone's time instead of sticking to the points.
Criticism of Walter Sanning from Jonathan Harrison of the holocaust controversies blog;
This critique of Sanning is then reviewed by codoh. Jonathan Harrison wants to defend himself on the thread of course. It doesn't go well. He complains that the nazis conducted censuses just like HS years later. He is asked to produce these. The thread ends there.
Analysis by the codoh forum of the said review by Jonathan Harrison with also contribution in the thread by Jonathan Harrison;
........
And finally, why do peddlers focus on resettlement?
Why , indeed, because if they could show us a holocaust they wouldn't need to focus on resettlement!
Additional;
On the problem with the question,
Well, where are they then? - Wilfried Heink
"In reality, the question is a declaration of bankruptcy, because by asking it is admitted that no solid case for mass murder can be made, for if it were, there would exist no need to ask the question."
J. Graf and the illogical canard: 'Where did Jews go then?' / & more
