The Holocaust Thread - The Great Debate Between Affirmers, Revisionists and Deniers

[Bonesjones]

you stupid you

Oh look you can't read nor are unable to not selectively quote things trying to prove a point you don't understand.

Years later, while noting that American and British Jewish leaders were "very helpful to our work behind the scenes, [but] were not notably enthusiastic about it in public",

Since we know jews were instrumental in changing census questioning about religion in the post wars in an attempt to hide the large amount of jews immigrating to the united states, it's just more evidence in support of that fact.

So we can add yet another country jews filtered through to the united states instead of dying in the holocaust.

Edit: you also missed the part where Hitler supported expulsion openly. Another nail in the coffin for extermination.

 

[Chugger]

They worked against it private as well.

I'll enlarge it for you, you stupidoso

Disagreements among the numerous Jewish organisations on how to handle the refugee crisis added to the confusion.[16][17] Concerned that Jewish organisations would be seen trying to promote greater immigration into the United States, executive secretary to the American Jewish Committee, Morris Waldman, privately warned against Jewish representatives highlighting the problems Jewish refugees faced.[18] Samuel Rosenman sent President Franklin D. Roosevelt a memorandum stating that an "increase of quotas is wholly inadvisable as it would merely produce a 'Jewish problem' in the countries increasing the quota."[19] According to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, during the discussions, five leading Jewish organisations sent a joint memorandum discouraging mass Jewish emigration from central Europe.[19] Reacting to the conferences' failure, the AJC declined to directly criticise American policy,[20] while Jonah Wise blamed the British government and praised "American generosity".[18]

They did both. History isn't a cartoon.

 

[Bonesjones]

They worked against it private as well.

I'll enlarge it for you, you stupidoso

If you had basic literacy you'd understand what words mean:
highlighting
increase of quotas
sent a joint memorandum

All of these support the fact that they were doing clandestine operations to help jews and publicly not supporting it. I know reading is hard for you. Maybe take some remedial English classes?

They did both. History isn't a cartoon.

Says the guy who thinks the Nazis used Rube Goldberg devices to kill jews.

 

[Chugger]

All of these support the fact that they were doing clandestine operations to help jews and publicly not supporting it. I know reading is hard for you. Maybe take some remedial English classes?

I don't know man, for example the AJC (probably the most prominent Jewish organization in America) sent Roosevelt a private memo saying he shouldn't increase the quotas. The Evian conference was also a massive fail. You're a stupidoso, sorry.

 

[Bonesjones]

I don't know man, for example the AJC (probably the most prominent Jewish organization in America) sent Roosevelt a private memo saying he shouldn't increase the quotas. The Evian conference was also a massive fail. You're a stupidoso, sorry.

I'm sorry your brain doesn't work nor are you able to read nor comprehend simple arguments. Increasing quotas is public support, instead of just allowing illegal immigration, which is what actually happened.

 

[Chugger]

I'm sorry your brain doesn't work nor are you able to read nor comprehend simple arguments. Increasing quotas is public support, instead of just allowing illegal immigration, which is what actually happened.

Samuel Rosenman sent President Franklin D. Roosevelt a memorandum stating that an "increase of quotas is wholly inadvisable as it would merely produce a 'Jewish problem'

You just keep digging yourself deeper don't you

 

[Bonesjones]

I'm glad you still don't understand what I'm saying and also making it abundantly clear.

 

[Chugger]

I'm glad you still don't understand what I'm saying and also making it abundantly clear.

Oh yeah I see now. Well there wasn't any illegal immigration of Jews into the country so . . .

 

[The Tall Man]

Tall Man and Bonesjones aren't going to change their minds and will continue to call you nasty names.

I am not dogmatic about anything. If Chugger presents me with a more rational explanation for anything, I will adopt it.

Well they've been blatantly wrong about certain things like (like Mattogno thinking the gas chamber was forged) so I want to see it I can get them to reckon w that at least.

The Dachau gas chamber an American forgery by Carlo Mattogno
You keep calling other people dumb and uninformed, but you only ever show yourself to be those things.
That's why it's especially amusing when you claim your opponents demonstrate the Dunning-Kruger effect.

I will start addressing your concerns about the layout, door, Mattogno, etc, once you answer my last question about the scary pipes. Quid pro quo.

Come on, Chugger, I’m still waiting for you to respond to the issues with the layout and the retrofitted doors.
I am looking forward to your counter argument.

 

[Chugger]

The Dachau gas chamber an American forgery by Carlo Mattogno
You keep calling other people dumb and uninformed, but you only ever show yourself to be those things.
That's why it's especially amusing when you claim your opponents demonstrate the Dunning-Kruger effect.

I already posted about this. Upon examining the evidence more closely he changed his mind.

"The evidence in favor of the American forgery seemed convincing, and I too assumed its validity in my paper cited earlier (first published in German: Mattogno 2011, pp. 258-264), but I soon renounced this explanation in the article "The Dachau 'Gas Chamber': New Perspectives," which appeared in 2015 on the Olodogma website, of which the present study is a radical reworking."

That's a quote from the article you posted by the way.

 

[Bonesjones]

Oh yeah I see now. Well there wasn't any illegal immigration of Jews into the country so . . .

There you go people an admission of his own retardation. It only took him 4 or 5 times reading one sentence to understand it.

I couldn't find whatever bullshit you are talking about above but it did link me to this:

http://www.deathcamps.org/editorial2013.html

Hey look proof holocaust controversies engaged in forgery and why you quote them so often. Pathetic.

They also refuse to debate the holocaust because they are so correct, you know despite showing how wrong they are. More hubris from holocaust promoters.

 

[Chugger]

There you go people an admission of his own retardation. It only took him 4 or 5 times reading one sentence to understand it.

Well there's no evidence these organizations privately encouraged illegal immigration so your entire thesis is nonsensical.

 

[Bonesjones]

Well there's no evidence these organizations privately encouraged illegal immigration so your entire thesis is nonsensical.

So what does private assistance from the US government mean then exactly?

 

[Chugger]

So what does private assistance from the US government mean then exactly?

I have no idea what you're talking about. Where do you see that?

 

[Bonesjones]

I have no idea what you're talking about. Where do you see that?

I'm not here to get you hooked on phonics, retard.

 

[The Tall Man]

I already posted about this. Upon examining the evidence more closely he changed his mind.

"The evidence in favor of the American forgery seemed convincing, and I too assumed its validity in my paper cited earlier (first published in German: Mattogno 2011, pp. 258-264), but I soon renounced this explanation in the article "The Dachau 'Gas Chamber': New Perspectives," which appeared in 2015 on the Olodogma website, of which the present study is a radical reworking."

That's a quote from the article you posted by the way.

Chugger you need to read the whole article, you are getting confused again.
Mattogno is talking about the fact the he revised his opinion on the construction of the ceiling of the Brausebad as presented by Dalton.

Stop going off on silly tangents and give me your counter argument for the layout and the doors.

 

[Chugger]

Chugger you need to read the whole article, you are getting confused again.
Mattogno is talking about the fact the he revised his opinion on the construction of the ceiling of the Brausebad as presented by Dalton.

Where in that article does he say it's a forgery? He says "I renounced this explanation".

Stop going off on silly tangents and give me your counter argument for the layout and the doors.

If you want me to talk about the doors, you talk about the pipes.

 

[Hyper Vigilant Dumbass]

Jewish leaders practicing Usury and Central banking led them to this. Yeah it sucks that good common Jews died, but if the camps were filled with Jew bankers the world would've been better off. I guess it also lead to the enslavement of mankind as well. Jews can whine all they want about the holocaust, but they wipe their tears with stacks of cash from the banks.
I don't think 5 gorillion died either. Probably more like a million or something.

 

[The Tall Man]

If you want me to talk about the doors, you talk about the pipes.

I have already answered your two questions about the pipes, but you still haven't given your counterargument about the doors and layout. This is not how quid pro quo works, Chugger.

But sure, I don't mind. Ask me another question about the pipes, but I expect you to come up with a proper counterargument regarding the retrofitted doors and layout.

 

[Chugger]

But sure, I don't mind. Ask me another question about the pipes, but I expect you to come up with a proper counterargument regarding the retrofitted doors and layout.

Show me in the book where Mattogno says they are water pipes.