It's similar to how everything that boasts itself as an 80s throwback feels more like a parody of the aesthetic than anything.
I don't know if it feels like a parody so much as....
Specifically the issues I have is that they just have 70s art work, and talk about the blood soaked mysticism... But first here are 3 pages about how its important to respect pronouns and trigger warnings, and then provide only the vaguest plot ideas of how to realize that cool mysticism. "You should totally make the world full of cool weird gods. Like maybe the Flying Spaghetti Monster but real. Yeah do that. Anything that triggers Xtians is good too. Anyway, now let me tell you that Black Lives Matter". Or they use "70's aesthetic" to mean you roll on a bunch of tables and/or zero play testing so things go fucky at the ends of the scale.
(80s is a little hard to unpack because most people don't get the point that while the 80s was full of self-satire, it was 'earnest satire'. You're supposed to laugh with the ads in Robocop, not at them. There is supposed to be one or two asshole corporate raiders fcking it up for everyone, not the a whole screed about capitalism bad. Just want to "LOL Neon, Ronnie Raygun and Ahnold")
To follow up on your point about the OSR spergs, I think the problem there is that a lot of the people who identify with the OSR see it as part of a broader "anti-SJW" movement, like Gamergate, Comicsgate, etc. Any "anti-" movement is going to attract useless and annoying people because they are motivated by spite ("we gotta own the libs!") rather than a genuine love for the thing they are fighting over. The bullshit that the woke segment of the D&D audience pumps out is pathetic and cringe because it's obvious to everyone else that it's intended to either virtue signal or spite the non-woke segment, which means it didn't come from any kind of enjoyment of the game. I think it's equally pathetic and cringe to make things just because you are attempting to signal that you are based or spite the woke segment because that also doesn't come from any enjoyment of the game.
It seems clear to me that anything good which has come out of the OSR has been made out of genuine love for tabletop gaming, and I think that's what people should be focusing on rather than turning the hobby into another battleground.
I agree. Terminally unfun spergs ruin games and communities no matter what side they're on.
And I think a lot of the OSR things are made by people who legitimately enjoy the game but don't want to read through a 300-page rule book, and its based on Gygax's material at its purest.
Also I think the things that have stopped OSR from becoming a PBTA-hellscape is that there is a minimal amount of math required acting as low-level gatekeeping, and PBTA acting as a honeypot.
Credit to Matt Colville again, he has a really good take about this kind of thing: Wizards of the Coast may own the IP, but Wizards doesn't own D&D because D&D (and the tabletop hobby as a whole) isn't an IP, it's a tradition we all participate in. [ ... ] If you don't like the current direction that Wizards is going, you are free to play non-woke D&D or other tabletop games in private with your friends, and blue checks on the internet can't do anything about it. The woke fags can publish as many useless supplements and broken new editions as they want, but no one is really going to play with these and enjoy them. [ ... ]The woke nonsense has no power to detract from your own enjoyment of the game unless you allow that to happen.
I've got to disagree here. There is a lot of pissing your pants in the snow that goes on in regards to politicizing/'wokening' D&D, which is everyone just says "Well, no one in my group is like that" or "We just ignore those rules". But one day you'll need to replace a player, or you'll need to join a new group. And you'll find the player base is majority genderspecial "disabled" and aggressively communist.
Wizards might not control your table, but they do wield vast influence on the community as a whole.
Well it doesn't help that there are scam artists like Darrick Dishaw, who mostly uses it as a piggybank from anti-woke paypigs so he can then put that money back into Disney's pockets since he's criminally addicted to Disney World. He recently fleeced 700 paypigs out of 11k money for just this:
This shit pisses me off. Lazy sociopaths doing a lazy grift for virtue signalers regardless of their politics.
I'm not ashamed to say that I got almost halfway down your list before I realized it was satire.
Well that's why I ended as I did, since everyone knows there is no way WotC would use a slur like Sc*ly.
The getting rid of dice was supposed to be the give away