SU Critical

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Well, I'll still read it anyway. Whether I'll publish a review or not depends on whether it's still a relevant subject or not by the time I'm done reading it.
 
howyadoin said:
Well, I'll still read it anyway. Whether I'll publish a review or not depends on whether it's still a relevant subject or not by the time I'm done reading it.
Click to expand...
Well, there's always the option to start a thread about it.
 
Bellsprout said:
Not to backseat mod but I'm reasonably sure this is like a 16 year old and while it's pretty cringey it's far from really interesting. It's not really cow material it's just a shitty fanfic.
Click to expand...
Don’t be so sure. While they might write like a 16 year old, according to their main blog they’re supposedly in college.

Sadly a very common occurrence on Tumblr.
 
Count groudon said:
Here's a thought, why not actually take that idea and make a separate all male species of space rocks, maybe name them after metals or something, and have them occasionally feature into the plot. Maybe if they added more variety into the superhero rock bullshit and focused a bit more on having genuinely interesting adventures instead of "lol these aliens don't understand people, Steven is so quirky" stories the show might actually be more popular with actual children instead of 25 year old shut in "children".
Click to expand...

I know I'm preaching to the choir, but this is a great idea. Popular action shows like Samurai Jack, Avatar the Last Airbender, and even comedic shows like the Powerpuff Girls all had funny moments and slice of life stuff, but they didn't make up the majority of the series. Another race of gems could really breathe life back into the show too
 
One last update on the CotCG reading: I put it here, and other fanfics can be discussed.

Anyway, here's a criticism of Lily Orchard's SU Rant that's getting popular:

Some SU Critical-related comments on her content:
upload_2018-12-19_16-31-14.png

upload_2018-12-19_16-32-13.png

upload_2018-12-19_16-33-36.png

Glad to see that SU Critical's reputation is getting worse as time goes by.
 
Last edited:
howyadoin said:
One last update on the CotCG reading: I put it here, and other fanfics can be discussed.

Anyway, here's a criticism of Lily Orchid's SU Rant that's getting popular:
https://youtube.com/watch?v=id=CsIKdZZxmZ8;t=1019
Some SU Critical-related comments on her content:
View attachment 618170
View attachment 618171
View attachment 618172

Glad to see that SU Critical's reputation is getting worse as time goes by.
Click to expand...

I really hope this wasn't just made because someone decided to bash this show out (SU) of disappointment of how much better it could have been. I like to think I've been making legit criticism, no matter how unpopular my opinions are. I say that, as it's stuff like this that makes having a different opinion, which is as much a spice of life as having variety in your diet, a real fucking problem I can't stand after too long.

Honestly, if I can't have an honest opinion on anything anymore, especially some thing that pisses me off / disappoints me like SU - cartoon sperg that I am (admittedly, and I'm proud of it, too, as I fucking love cartoons / some anime - the messed up medium(s) as a whole that it is to you fucks!), that's like being told to burn myself... Sorry, can't stop doing that. It's just far too liberating - and fun / good for the soul, too, if you ask me.

To be fair, Lily Orchard is fucking ponyfag / crisscrossing tard, so it's no surprise to me someone decided to do this to "her" at all. Someone like "her" and most of the Tumblr-fucks in SU Critical need to be invalidated, simply for acting the fool too much - I can't argue with that too much, actually.

EDIT - after watching the vid, I'm glad my first paragraph is NOT the case. I've even subbed to her, mostly because her other content isn't too bad, either.
 
Last edited:
If you make a video that's two fucking hours of criticizing a children's tv show you deserve to be mocked.
 
Shokew said:
No, I'm not ever arguing with that. Especially when you don't see other shows getting discussed to this sadass degree / so spergy and nitpicky that it can't be taken remotely seriously.
Click to expand...
You know you're fucking autistic when even "criticizing a show" for 2 hours makes you a complete sperg.
 
Tumblr’s su critical community would implode if it knew how many fag bombs Rebecca Sugar dropped into the dialogue of Pug Davis. It’s a lot easier to m.ilk that for oppression points than reaching for evidence of racism.
 
Last edited:
I watched the Lily Peet video because I hate myself and use longform videos as sleep aids. She spends about 30 minutes of the two hours sperging about Knights of the Old Republic and "why isn't stevie universe just like this", and then calls Rebecca Sugar a fascist in denial because she fucked up writing her villains as redeemable. Also there was 200 mentions of "why does this nonbinary character look like a woman? this is oppressive and rapey"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fat Pikachu said:
I watched the Lily Peet video because I hate myself and use longform videos as sleep aids. S/he spends about 30 minutes of the two hours sperging about Knights of the Old Republic and "why isn't stevie universe just like this", and then calls Rebecca Sugar a fascist in denial because she fucked up writing her villains as redeemable. Also there was 200 mentions of muh racism and "why does this nonbinary character look like a woman? this is oppressive and rapey"
Click to expand...

For anyone who wants to be a fan of this show or wants to understand why fanbases in general (especially this one) are cancer, this is required watching - hopefully you'll change your mind / understand perfectly why we're all starting to make fun of you (as much as it pains some of us to do so.).
 
A new episode "Familiar" came out so I looked for new salt.

Screenshot_20181225-113050~2.png
Screenshot_20181225-113021~2.png
Screenshot_20181225-112919~2.png
Screenshot_20181225-112841~2.png
Screenshot_20181225-113105~2.png

The "gem comb" complaint is ridiculously funny, not gonna lie.
 
"Why was there a gem comb!?"

They're aliens, bruh. I'm actually glad to hear there are gems that don't look so human-like now.
 
Piga Dgrifm said:
"Why was there a gem comb!?"

They're aliens, bruh. I'm actually glad to hear there are gems that don't look so human-like now.
Click to expand...
There was a gem comb because to the evil dictators (keyword: dictators) see them literally as expendable and borderline worthless except asinine tasks. You wouldn't set a piece of gravel you found on the road in 14k gold and use it as an engagement ring.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom