Sperg about comic books here

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
This is exactly why I could never get into DC as much as Marvel. It's such a goddamn mess and so many continuity resets.
Honestly, DC was a fucking huge mess continuity-wise before Crisis. Black Canary's origin was a flaming dumpster involving 5th Dimensional genies, cursed babies, and swapping minds with a comatose daughter. Crisis just simplified it to "The first BC retired, and her daughter with a meta-human scream took over and let Green Arrow go balls deep on her a lot. The End".
 
Yeah - Valor/Mon-EL/Lar Gand and Laurel Gand (later known as Andromeda) because the post-Crisis stand-ins for Kal-El and Kara.
Valor wasn't a bad idea per se, but needed more setup and integration.

Andromeda is an idk. I remember some Laurel Kent getting outed as a manhunter robot in the millennium event.
I really miss the post Crisis Starman, as well as Yolanda and Beth. He and the others you mentioned got merked by Eclipso during the "EVIL WITHIN" crossover event.
Yeah will payton's pretty underrated. Even James Robinson just wrote him as being a dude who had little knowledge of the legacy, but decided to spend his life doing good in his corner of the world just because he was a good man.

NGL the single thing that gets me weirdly pissy over '90s era JSA/Infinity Inc related merking is how they killed the original Atom right before they integrated the original GL/Flash into those comics again as elder statesmen. Now, the Atom isn't the biggest legacy but it's been a constant one in the teams. Imagine a book where Al Pratt teaches everyone who takes after his legacy (Which, is a surprising amount of people. Especially since Atom Smasher and Damage kinda had plot beats about being in need of guidance after all that violence and depression. Not to mention Al Pratt going awol and Ryan Choi debuting only to get fucking merked a few years later. )

I do wonder what would have happened if Al Pratt lived. Hell, just let James Robinson write that in a miniseries.
The new Stargirl TV show uses Yolanda and Beth as part of the "new JSA", so I get my Infinity Inc fix that way. They've also introduced Jade and Hourman II (Rick, not the android), and i imagine Obsidian will be showing up next.

>write alan scott as LGBT
>push Obsidian, one of the more relevant and famous of DC's historically LGBT heroes to the side.

fuckin modern DC makes me laugh at times. Weird because I do love the original Infinitors. Skyman also deserved better.
Honestly, DC was a fucking huge mess continuity-wise before Crisis. Black Canary's origin was a flaming dumpster involving 5th Dimensional genies, cursed babies, and swapping minds with a comatose daughter. Crisis just simplified it to "The first BC retired, and her daughter with a meta-human scream took over and let Green Arrow go balls deep on her a lot. The End".

Oh yeah the Black Canary thing was 100% a clusterfuck.

Don't forget the whole mess that was trying to explain the Red Tornado. Dude's still an iconic and recognizable superhero, but there's a reason the 2010s kinda tried to just put him in the background.

Anyone remember the whole thing that the JL-Detroit and All-Star Squadron were trying to do in explaining how Earth-2's Steel traveled to Earth-1 after the war and his son became the JL-Detroit's Steel? That shitshow happened during the original Crisis and by god.

It was a mess.


I'll be honest though, most of the comics that came out after the original crisis and before the major "dark and edgy" shitshow of the 90s were really fun. I enjoyed all of Byrne's superman, the perez wonder woman stuff, all the batman stuff, JLI, titans, and so on.

The Millennium event kinda stunk a little bit imo but it solidified the Manhunters as a major threat, so it gets a pass.

That and it introduced the absolute meme that is the New Guardians.
 
Honestly, DC was a fucking huge mess continuity-wise before Crisis. Black Canary's origin was a flaming dumpster involving 5th Dimensional genies, cursed babies, and swapping minds with a comatose daughter. Crisis just simplified it to "The first BC retired, and her daughter with a meta-human scream took over and let Green Arrow go balls deep on her a lot. The End".

It was complicated, but they went to far in the other direction.

For over fifteen years, Supergirl couldn't be Kryptonian because Clark had to be the Last Kryptonian. (Byrne). Earth 2 couldn't exist, nor could Earths S or what have you. So Captain Marvel got fucked until Ordway came along in 90s.

The difference between DC Crisis and Hickman Warz was nothing from Hickman's run mattered. The Ultimate universe doesn't exist? Bullshit. Miles is there, Maker is there. The whole Multiverse still exists. Tony is evulz and fights Steve? So fucking what? They're having beers together within a year. Nothing changed, no one sacrifice truly mattered, and it all may as well have had the impact of fly on a screen. Which would be fine by Hickman Warz ran for multiple years across more than a hundred issues!

Compare that to the crises. CIOCE was just twelve issues. The Multiverse was destroyed. It didn't come back. Barry Allen died and stayed dead for over fifteen years.

s-l400.jpg


In Zero Hour, five issues, the DC universe was actually changed. Character died, sacrificed. It continued to impact everything that happened around it for years.

zh02jsadown.jpg


I loathe Identity Crisis/Infinite Crisis. But the same. Final Crisis is the only one that failed the basic task of real stakes and real consequences.

And it's not as if Marvel didn't have crises. Jim Starlin wrote the first Marvel crisis in 1977 (Thanos Final threat). Jim Shooter's Secret Wars was little more than a toy commercial and it had more impact than Hickman's redux.

Speaking of, with the She-hulk series coming out, when will she go back to calling herself She-hulk in the comics?
 
The Ultimate universe doesn't exist? Bullshit. Miles is there, Maker is there. The whole Multiverse still exists.
It didn't go away - it just got folded into the 616 Universe. Maker is convinced he can get back to it, and tried to steal the Venom symbiote in an attempt to get back there.
Tony is evulz and fights Steve? So fucking what?
Evil Tony happened because of AXIS (same goes for Evil Havok and Good Sabretooth) All three remained "inverted" for a while after AXIS ended, but then they eventually "reverted". Tony was EVEEELLLL during Superior Iron Man, but then it ended due to Secret Wars 2015 happening and then Tony just got gud again with no seeming explanation (that I know of). It was stupid as Electric Superman turning back to Original Recipe Superman with no explanation.

Stevevil aka Hydra Cap was due to Secret Empire, so that can't be blamed on Secret Wars.
Compare that to the crises. CIOCE was just twelve issues.
It was, but there were a LOT of tie-in issues showing what was going on all around the DCU. They've even been collected in a big ass box set that cost around $550, but can be found on Amazon for about $250-300 now.

Speaking of, with the She-hulk series coming out, when will she go back to calling herself She-hulk in the comics?
A new series has just been announced, and Jen will be back to being a busty smart lawyer - the Gamma irradiated Ally McBeal we all know and love. Thank the lord. I HATED when they made her grey and stupid, and hated it when they turned her green but kept her stupid in Hulk mode. If it's anything like Dan Slott's run on Jen, I'm buying it.
 
It was complicated, but they went to far in the other direction.

For over fifteen years, Supergirl couldn't be Kryptonian because Clark had to be the Last Kryptonian. (Byrne). Earth 2 couldn't exist, nor could Earths S or what have you. So Captain Marvel got fucked until Ordway came along in 90s.

The difference between DC Crisis and Hickman Warz was nothing from Hickman's run mattered. The Ultimate universe doesn't exist? Bullshit. Miles is there, Maker is there. The whole Multiverse still exists. Tony is evulz and fights Steve? So fucking what? They're having beers together within a year. Nothing changed, no one sacrifice truly mattered, and it all may as well have had the impact of fly on a screen. Which would be fine by Hickman Warz ran for multiple years across more than a hundred issues!
Yeah Hickman kinda removed half the FF, oh nooooo.

But we all know why.

And then they didn't really do much aside from revert the changes with the FF/Doom. Whee. There were like 3 relevant Ultimate universe chars that came to the normal Marvel Universe- Miles, Jimmy Hudson, and The Maker.

Well there may have been others but I recall them getting immediately shafted because noone cared.
Compare that to the crises. CIOCE was just twelve issues. The Multiverse was destroyed. It didn't come back. Barry Allen died and stayed dead for over fifteen years.

s-l400.jpg


In Zero Hour, five issues, the DC universe was actually changed. Character died, sacrificed. It continued to impact everything that happened around it for years.

zh02jsadown.jpg


I loathe Identity Crisis/Infinite Crisis. But the same. Final Crisis is the only one that failed the basic task of real stakes and real consequences.

And it's not as if Marvel didn't have crises. Jim Starlin wrote the first Marvel crisis in 1977 (Thanos Final threat). Jim Shooter's Secret Wars was little more than a toy commercial and it had more impact than Hickman's redux.

Speaking of, with the She-hulk series coming out, when will she go back to calling herself She-hulk in the comics?
Final Crisis kinda killed the New Gods for a good while. It also brought back Superboy, Bart Allen, Barry Allen, and so on. It also resulted in the death of J'onn J'onzz, which was somewhat unexpected to me.

The sheer amount of spinoffs it got was kinda wild, but I think the issue with Final Crisis was that Morrison needed to lay off the drugs to tell a more coherently planned tale.
It didn't go away - it just got folded into the 616 Universe. Maker is convinced he can get back to it, and tried to steal the Venom symbiote in an attempt to get back there.

Evil Tony happened because of AXIS (same goes for Evil Havok and Good Sabretooth) All three remained "inverted" for a while after AXIS ended, but then they eventually "reverted". Tony was EVEEELLLL during Superior Iron Man, but then it ended due to Secret Wars 2015 happening and then Tony just got gud again with no seeming explanation (that I know of). It was stupid as Electric Superman turning back to Original Recipe Superman with no explanation.
Lol Evil Havok and Good Sabertooth at least got turned back to normal in the X-Books. I think Havok got mind-fucked by Emma Frost into becoming normal again. Sabertooth at least had a moment in the end of the Weapon X series where he reverted to beastiality in order to revive his son, Graydon Creed.

Tony, uh. We know he died during the final incursion so I guess he reverted when the universe got put together again? Fucking Tony always reverts back to normal. Just look at Heroes Reborn. The first thing that happens is Tony realizing he had 3 seperate lifetimes in one body.

Axis was a fun idea that wasn't executed well.
Stevevil aka Hydra Cap was due to Secret Empire, so that can't be blamed on Secret Wars.
Oh man I unironically love Stevil Rogers as a villain, but I don't want him to be overused. Let him chill in the background for a while.
It was, but there were a LOT of tie-in issues showing what was going on all around the DCU. They've even been collected in a big ass box set that cost around $550, but can be found on Amazon for about $250-300 now.


A new series has just been announced, and Jen will be back to being a busty smart lawyer - the Gamma irradiated Ally McBeal we all know and love. Thank the lord. I HATED when they made her grey and stupid, and hated it when they turned her green but kept her stupid in Hulk mode. If it's anything like Dan Slott's run on Jen, I'm buying it.
Jen as a grotesque Ewing style Hulk was interesting, but it wore out after a while.

That and the grotesqueness only really works in the fucked up hellscape of Ewing's Immortal Hulk. I do hope they don't do SJW with the new Shulkie book though.
 
I remember some Laurel Kent getting outed as a manhunter robot in the millennium event.
That was a descendant of Clark's that only had invulnerability due to her Kryptonian bloodline being "diluted". After Crisis, they erased any connection to Superman, and thus made her a Manhunter that killed itself once it realized the Millennium event happened an actual millennium ago and the Manhunters has failed. *sad trumpet noises*
Now, the Atom isn't the biggest legacy but it's been a constant one in the teams.
Go read the whole mid-2000s Manhunter series (about the lawyer lady, not the crazy dudes that seem to pick up the mantle). It turns out that Al was not just the godfather form Nuklon/Atom Smasher and the genetic "father" for Damage, but was connected to Iron Munroe, Phantom Lady, and Lady Manhunter herself. Obsidian also showed up and came out as gay in the book.

Speaking of, Infinite Frontier brought Todd back, and Alan coming out has brought him closer to his dad. Now if DC was smart, they take advantage of the Infinity Inc characters showing up on Stargirl, and bring the II back in the comics. I miss seeing Todd, Jenny, Yolanda, and Albert together.

That and it introduced the absolute meme that is the New Guardians.
That series was a clusterfuck. The team was made in order to "create the next evolution of mankind", yet the members were either non-organic (RAM, Floro, and Betty Clawman), infected with AIDS (Jet and Harbinger), or not interested in breeding with the opposite sex (Extrano). WTF?

At least Snowflame was interesting, and they need to bring him back

I AM POWERED BY COCAINE!
 
That was a descendant of Clark's that only had invulnerability due to her Kryptonian bloodline being "diluted". After Crisis, they erased any connection to Superman, and thus made her a Manhunter that killed itself once it realized the Millennium event happened an actual millennium ago and the Manhunters has failed. *sad trumpet noises*
That was a genuinely interesting thing they did.

Didn't the post-crisis LOSH get explained as existing due to some pocket universe that saw its own Superboy die?
Go read the whole mid-2000s Manhunter series (about the lawyer lady, not the crazy dudes that seem to pick up the mantle). It turns out that Al was not just the godfather form Nuklon/Atom Smasher and the genetic "father" for Damage, but was connected to Iron Munroe, Phantom Lady, and Lady Manhunter herself. Obsidian also showed up and came out as gay in the book.
Oh yeah and the reluctant villain, Cyclotron, was the actual dad of Nuklon and Al somehow got the same power set.

man i miss the 90s and early 2000s and how they'd just have fun with legacy heroes. the late 90s and 2000s era JSA was a good example of just having dumb fun.

Even if Ma Hunkel was probably wayyyy too old to have been alive.
Speaking of, Infinite Frontier brought Todd back, and Alan coming out has brought him closer to his dad. Now if DC was smart, they take advantage of the Infinity Inc characters showing up on Stargirl, and bring the II back in the comics. I miss seeing Todd, Jenny, Yolanda, and Albert together.
ten bucks says DC makes them all genderqueer and we somehow wind up in a timeline where they have Obsidian turn out to not really be Alan's son by blood and this results in a relationship.

Infinity Inc. shouldn't have ended as grimly as it did. Christ. Skyman could have been a legitimately long lasting name if they played the cards right.
That series was a clusterfuck. The team was made in order to "create the next evolution of mankind", yet the members were either non-organic (RAM, Floro, and Betty Clawman), infected with AIDS (Jet and Harbinger), or not interested in breeding with the opposite sex (Extrano). WTF?

At least Snowflame was interesting, and they need to bring him back

I AM POWERED BY COCAINE!
I love how Harbinger just got added to the team and then we never really see her get used again. . .

until she got murked in the early 2000s.
Reg977J-D2X_5B43d6vaKUtM_9MVjwE4Lj-MJrU_cW9gADTz4qpJDeYQjmrAE4LFgtbBvM0qKUVaxA=s867-c-fcrop64=1,00000000ffffe18f-nd


Oof. Who woulda thunk that this would happen?

man his work's fine, but you get the feeling that he didn't see the show?
 
That was a genuinely interesting thing they did.

Didn't the post-crisis LOSH get explained as existing due to some pocket universe that saw its own Superboy die?

Yes, Byrne's Superman Run. Because he didn't have Superboy as his design.
Oh yeah and the reluctant villain, Cyclotron, was the actual dad of Nuklon and Al somehow got the same power set.

man i miss the 90s and early 2000s and how they'd just have fun with legacy heroes. the late 90s and 2000s era JSA was a good example of just having dumb fun.

Even if Ma Hunkel was probably wayyyy too old to have been alive.

ten bucks says DC makes them all genderqueer and we somehow wind up in a timeline where they have Obsidian turn out to not really be Alan's son by blood and this results in a relationship.

Infinity Inc. shouldn't have ended as grimly as it did. Christ. Skyman could have been a legitimately long lasting name if they played the cards right.


No, that was rough.

Jerry Ordway and Toddy McFarlane. Amazing art. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't remember Obsidian being gay in those Infinity Inc issues?

I love how Harbinger just got added to the team and then we never really see her get used again. . .

until she got murked in the early 2000s.


man his work's fine, but you get the feeling that he didn't see the show?

I feel like what he focuses in his work is different than what a healthy, well adjusted person sees.

You and I see a shitty adaptation that loses what little appeal the original work had, its humanity and capturing the horror of half the human population dying. He looks at it and sees a political tract with art around it. Lose the art, like the show did, and he's still proud of it because the art was never what he loved about it.

It's like going into the Boys and removing Huey's relationships and Butcher's relationships and keeping the over the top violence, anti-christian, and other crap. The Boys did the opposite and got rid of or improved on allot of that stuff and wouldn't you know it got multiple seasons.
 
That was a genuinely interesting thing they did.

Didn't the post-crisis LOSH get explained as existing due to some pocket universe that saw its own Superboy die?
The first Post Crisis Superboy that was not the butt baby of Clark and Lex came from an Earth that the Time Trapper saved from being wiped into non-existence by stashing it in a "pocket dimension" . This Superboy died to save "Pocket Earth", and the LOSH mourned him until the full effects of Crisis took hold and made them forget him. This Pocket Earth later had three Kryptonian criminals in the Phantom Zone let loose, where there killed 99% of the population. The Lex of that place made the protoplasm Supergirl based on Lana Lang, who starred in the mid 90s Supergirl series. The Post Crisis Clark came back there, first using Gold Kryptonite to permanently depower them, then that Earth's Green K to KILL THEM, since they openly bragged about trying to get their powers back so they could go to his Earth and murder everyone there too. (K on that Earth had no effect on Clark, since it had a different wavelength than K from his Earth. This is why K on our Earth had no effect on Superbrat Prime)
Oh yeah and the reluctant villain, Cyclotron, was the actual dad of Nuklon and Al somehow got the same power set.
Cyclotron was Nuklon's grandfather. The same accident that gave Terry Curtis his powers also irradiated his wife and baby daughter. His wife died as a result, and his daughter was terminally sick. Ultra-Humanite blackmailed Cyclotron into villainy by kidnapping the baby and promising the cure her if Cyclotron did his dirty work. He died helping the JSA and his daughter got raised by the second Firebrand and Shining Knight. This same radiation that affected Terry's daughter altered her DNA so that her son Albert Rothstein would develop powers at puberty.
ten bucks says DC makes them all genderqueer and we somehow wind up in a timeline where they have Obsidian turn out to not really be Alan's son by blood and this results in a relationship.

Infinity Inc. shouldn't have ended as grimly as it did. Christ. Skyman could have been a legitimately long lasting name if they played the cards right.
So far, everyone on the show is straight and cis. Even DC isn't retarded enough to have Alan and Todd be fuck buddies.

I agree on Skyman, though. The series was on the chopping block and I guess DC wanted to go down the grim and gritty route popular in the later 80s. On the Stargirl show, Sylvester is a character, but they call him Starman and had him using the Starman staff. Most likely a choice in order to simply the already convoluted continuity.

Jerry Ordway and Toddy McFarlane. Amazing art. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't remember Obsidian being gay in those Infinity Inc issues?
Then Ordway was creating the team, he intended Todd to be openly gay from the start, but he or DC got cold feet (he was also going to get illusion based powers like the Golden Age Harlequin, but then they decided Thorn was going to be their biological mother instead). Todd did go on dates with two women, but the first date went nowhere, and the second woman turned out to be the new Harlequin, working as an agent for the Manhunters to destroy the team from the inside. She started out dating Norda/Northwind, but moved onto Todd after Norda left to go back to his people in Greenland. It was obvious to my not-quite-out-myself gay ass that Todd did not play on the same team as Al and Hector.

Later on, when he and Nuklon joined the Justice League in the mid 90s, Todd admitted that he was possibly not straight but not full on calling himself gay, and hinted that he was in love with Al as well.

Then in the mid 2000 Manhunter series, Todd shows up dating Kate's male Co-worker, Damon Matthews. Finally confirming his gayness decades later, a la Northstar.

Speaking of, the similarities between those two is bizarre: Both are gay dudes with twin sisters, they both came out late in life, with one sibling having schizophrenia (Todd/Aurora), both were separated at birth, and both discovered their twin sister in adulthood. It's the like the Man-Thing/Swamp Thing or X-Men/Doom Patrol thing all over again.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone in the Marvel universe likes Scarlet Witch anymore?
She seems to be doing her own thing and only Pietro seems to tolerate her.
House of M was literally Magneto and Prof. X refusing her a therapist and trying to kill her because she was going under an actual mental breakdown. It's been a wildride of Byrne not liking robots, which Vision is synthetic man like the OG Human Torch, and Bendis going with that. Pretty sure Vision should have a working dick, but the Pym side of Marvel is ignored for some reason. Pym is actually interesting outside of the slapping Janet when she deserved it, he had a Hungarian wife who got killed by Soviets and then he went on a tear. Rage of Ultron was actually good because it actually did a character study of Ultron and how he hates himself for being created solely to stroke his fathers ego.

If they wanted to do something interesting revive the Pym-Richards rivalry to the point of Ultron literally threatening to oust Kang and do a fucking Infinite Crisis. Ultron is actually the good guy and resets shit before Spider-Man sold his daughters soul to the devil because the Editor-In-Chief went through a messy divorce, the X-Men became Israeli, and Iron Man is literally two people because of time shenanigans. Also I hate Captain America for a number of reasons, but mainly because he's boring and is only ever a mouthpiece. It was set up a while ago that Kang/ Immortus/ whatever he calls himself has rigged the game so that he wins, Cosmic bs be damned.

I wish people would stop raising the stakes to absurd levels, Hickman or Starlin, it stops being interesting. It becomes an autismfest when characters have big ass powers, it's why Superman breaks narratives and you have to write around him. I mean now that the in-universe Superman is gay just have him be the Gaeton Dugas of DC and spread space AIDS unknowingly and then knowingly do it once he is diagnosed then you can just say that he wasn't taking his anti-virals because he wanted to spread the gift and his powers were weakened.
 
Pretty sure Vision should have a working dick, but the Pym side of Marvel is ignored for some reason.
When Vision was taken apart in WCA, his disassembled "corpse" did not contain a penis. When he got put back together and showed up buck-ass naked issues later, he was smooth as a Ken doll down there. I'd imagine that Ultron - a machine that has no need or inclination to get his fuck on - had no reason or need to make Vision as "fully functional" as Dr. Soong did for Data.
 
>Truth, Justice and the American Way
>Truth, Justice and a Better Tomorrow


One of these things sound inspirational, while one of them also sounds like a paid for, paid by the PR firm for a literal superhero that‘s not even from planet Earth.
 
When Vision was taken apart in WCA, his disassembled "corpse" did not contain a penis. When he got put back together and showed up buck-ass naked issues later, he was smooth as a Ken doll down there. I'd imagine that Ultron - a machine that has no need or inclination to get his fuck on - had no reason or need to make Vision as "fully functional" as Dr. Soong did for Data.
All I remember is that Ultron used leftover Human Torch shit, also no one really gave a shit about Scarlet Witch fucking a robot until Byrne and then Bendis. OG Human Torch had the machinery. I liked the whole thing of Wanda conjuring up kids because they couldn't have them and getting pissed at the nannies for losing them when her concentration would wane and they would disappear.

Back to the previous shit, anytime you bring Magneto into the Scarlet Witch or Quicksilvers life writers ignore how abusive Magneto was and character assassinate Wanda and Pietro to make him sympathetic. Wanda is actually understandable because she wants to have a family and forgives him in hopes of that, but Pietro really should hate him for being a power hungry dick who wants to be greater than everyone. Pietro is honestly a great character when he's not out-of-character working for Magneto.
 
Yeah - Valor/Mon-EL/Lar Gand and Laurel Gand (later known as Andromeda) because the post-Crisis stand-ins for Kal-El and Kara.
I've had a soft spot for Laurel Gand, particularly the SW6 version of the character as the Andromeda costume kicked ass with the star field and loin cloth. I was not too fond of how they turned her into a xenophobic cunt after the reboot. Granted, she repented and earned her redemption.
I really miss the post Crisis Starman, as well as Yolanda and Beth. He and the others you mentioned got merked by Eclipso during the "EVIL WITHIN" crossover event.
Well, the "good" news is that Will Payton returned in Scott Snyder's Justice League. As for Yolanda and Beth, Geoff Johns brought them back to life in Doomsday Clock.
Compare that to the crises. CIOCE was just twelve issues. The Multiverse was destroyed. It didn't come back. Barry Allen died and stayed dead for over fifteen years.
By my count, Barry stayed dead for twenty-two years. As for CoIE, I heard rumors that DC did contemplate a total reboot. Greg Weisman (of Gargoyles/Joung Justice fame) was an editorial assistant at the time asked why they didn't just do it at meeting and the answer was that New Teen Titans was their top seller at the time and a reboot would basically kill the title. Ironic considering that George Perez's Wonder Woman turned Donna Troy's history into a continuity knot. @Water-T went over the Crisis' effects on the LoSH. The Hawkworld retcon royally fucked over the Hawks. Frankly, the post-Crisis DCU was even more confusing that the pre-Crisis multiverse because of their selective retcons, which created a cascading effect of more retcons and reboots that never ends. Hell, I even look at the New 52 as a failure right out of the gate because DC refused to reboot Batman and Green Lantern's histories. If you want to reboot your universe... commit to the fucking bit.
 
The first Post Crisis Superboy that was not the butt baby of Clark and Lex came from an Earth that the Time Trapper saved from being wiped into non-existence by stashing it in a "pocket dimension" . This Superboy died to save "Pocket Earth", and the LOSH mourned him until the full effects of Crisis took hold and made them forget him. This Pocket Earth later had three Kryptonian criminals in the Phantom Zone let loose, where there killed 99% of the population. The Lex of that place made the protoplasm Supergirl based on Lana Lang, who starred in the mid 90s Supergirl series. The Post Crisis Clark came back there, first using Gold Kryptonite to permanently depower them, then that Earth's Green K to KILL THEM, since they openly bragged about trying to get their powers back so they could go to his Earth and murder everyone there too. (K on that Earth had no effect on Clark, since it had a different wavelength than K from his Earth. This is why K on our Earth had no effect on Superbrat Prime)
I remember the protoplasm supergirl solely for getting OHKO'd in the doomsday fight and not much else.

didn't she kinda simp for luthor and then uh

just merge with some girl for the "Earth Born Angel" Supergirl that peter david worked on?

Yeah, I remember some really odd Supergirl thing that was essentially "Matrix merges with girl to save life. Somehow this leads to an Earth born Angel." and then we never see her again after the run.
Cyclotron was Nuklon's grandfather. The same accident that gave Terry Curtis his powers also irradiated his wife and baby daughter. His wife died as a result, and his daughter was terminally sick. Ultra-Humanite blackmailed Cyclotron into villainy by kidnapping the baby and promising the cure her if Cyclotron did his dirty work. He died helping the JSA and his daughter got raised by the second Firebrand and Shining Knight. This same radiation that affected Terry's daughter altered her DNA so that her son Albert Rothstein would develop powers at puberty.
It was the All-Star Squadron iirc.

Cyclotron was a decent reluctant villain.
So far, everyone on the show is straight and cis. Even DC isn't exceptional enough to have Alan and Todd be fuck buddies.
if DC makes them fuckbuddies in the future, please include the screencap of this post in the 4chan greentext.
I agree on Skyman, though. The series was on the chopping block and I guess DC wanted to go down the grim and gritty route popular in the later 80s. On the Stargirl show, Sylvester is a character, but they call him Starman and had him using the Starman staff. Most likely a choice in order to simply the already convoluted continuity.
it's a shame because Infinity Inc characters kinda mostly ran the 90s out as B listers.

Dr Midnite/Wildcat- Died in that Eclipso book.
Hourman- Lived, lucky him.
Nuklon/Obsidian- Joined the Gerard Jones JLA. I remember it because Nuklon turned down a relationship with Fire because of his heritage and religion.
Brainwave Jr. - Extreme Justice appearance as a hackneyed villain. Cool design but we try to forget that ever happened.
Jade- joined the New Bloods in their team book as the leader. Later was Kyle Rayner's GF, I guess?
Fury- shitshow. Sandman books.
Hector Hall- Also a shitshow iirc. Came back as Dr. Fate and died before Infinite Crisis?
Norda- I don't really know but I think he cameo'd in some JSA and Robinson's Starman stuff? He didn't do much until that Infinite Crisis era JSA shitshow with Black Adam.
Power Girl- JLI Meme.
Skyman- Murked.
Harlequin- I dunno. She popped up as the daughter of the OG golden age villain, the Gambler?
Jonni Thunder- not an official member but I think she's legit been forgotten lmao
Huntress- crisis casualty.

I recall Jesse Quick was introduced in that JSA series that happened riiiight before Zero Hour. It had good art iirc.

Then Ordway was creating the team, he intended Todd to be openly gay from the start, but he or DC got cold feet (he was also going to get illusion based powers like the Golden Age Harlequin, but then they decided Thorn was going to be their biological mother instead). Todd did go on dates with two women, but the first date went nowhere, and the second woman turned out to be the new Harlequin, working as an agent for the Manhunters to destroy the team from the inside. She started out dating Norda/Northwind, but moved onto Todd after Norda left to go back to his people in Greenland. It was obvious to my not-quite-out-myself gay ass that Todd did not play on the same team as Al and Hector.
Didn't they also intend to have a gay male Harlequin character in the original drafts, but then it never went anywhere?



Later on, when he and Nuklon joined the Justice League in the mid 90s, Todd admitted that he was possibly not straight but not full on calling himself gay, and hinted that he was in love with Al as well.

Then in the mid 2000 Manhunter series, Todd shows up dating Kate's male Co-worker, Damon Matthews. Finally confirming his gayness decades later, a la Northstar.

Speaking of, the similarities between those two is bizarre: Both are gay dudes with twin sisters, they both came out late in life, with one sibling having schizophrenia (Todd/Aurora), both were separated at birth, and both discovered their twin sister in adulthood. It's the like the Man-Thing/Swamp Thing or X-Men/Doom Patrol thing all over again.
Well I don't remember Northstar's backstory that much but didn't Todd get extremely abused as a kid?
House of M was literally Magneto and Prof. X refusing her a therapist and trying to kill her because she was going under an actual mental breakdown. It's been a wildride of Byrne not liking robots, which Vision is synthetic man like the OG Human Torch, and Bendis going with that. Pretty sure Vision should have a working dick, but the Pym side of Marvel is ignored for some reason. Pym is actually interesting outside of the slapping Janet when she deserved it, he had a Hungarian wife who got killed by Soviets and then he went on a tear. Rage of Ultron was actually good because it actually did a character study of Ultron and how he hates himself for being created solely to stroke his fathers ego.
the 2010s tried to focus on the Pym side bc of the movies and the push away from the f4/X-Men, but they kinda bungled Age of Ultron.

and Pymtron was inconsistent as fuck.

West Coast Avengers did give Pym good character growth.
If they wanted to do something interesting revive the Pym-Richards rivalry to the point of Ultron literally threatening to oust Kang and do a fucking Infinite Crisis. Ultron is actually the good guy and resets shit before Spider-Man sold his daughters soul to the devil because the Editor-In-Chief went through a messy divorce, the X-Men became Israeli, and Iron Man is literally two people because of time shenanigans. Also I hate Captain America for a number of reasons, but mainly because he's boring and is only ever a mouthpiece. It was set up a while ago that Kang/ Immortus/ whatever he calls himself has rigged the game so that he wins, Cosmic bs be damned.
I doubt we'll get something that interesting because twitter writers like attacking the fans and dissing them lmfao.

Iron Man becoming like 4-6 seperate people would be kinda funny. Traitor Iron Man from the Crossing, Kid Tony, Superior Iron Man, A.I. Tony, Post Heroes Reborn-Civil War Era Tony, and post-rebirth 2029-2021 Tony would all be fucking entertaining.

man when they gonna ressurect Happy Hogan, it's been like 15 years.
I wish people would stop raising the stakes to absurd levels, Hickman or Starlin, it stops being interesting. It becomes an autismfest when characters have big ass powers, it's why Superman breaks narratives and you have to write around him. I mean now that the in-universe Superman is gay just have him be the Gaeton Dugas of DC and spread space AIDS unknowingly and then knowingly do it once he is diagnosed then you can just say that he wasn't taking his anti-virals because he wanted to spread the gift and his powers were weakened.
Cosmic stories can be fun but they have to like a once every 2-3 years shitshow at best. Otherwise we don't get the proper fallout.

I enjoyed the Infinity event but that was mostly a guilty pleasure.

Gay Jon Kent is probably the biggest backfiring move they can do.
All I remember is that Ultron used leftover Human Torch shit, also no one really gave a shit about Scarlet Witch fucking a robot until Byrne and then Bendis. OG Human Torch had the machinery. I liked the whole thing of Wanda conjuring up kids because they couldn't have them and getting pissed at the nannies for losing them when her concentration would wane and they would disappear.

Back to the previous shit, anytime you bring Magneto into the Scarlet Witch or Quicksilvers life writers ignore how abusive Magneto was and character assassinate Wanda and Pietro to make him sympathetic. Wanda is actually understandable because she wants to have a family and forgives him in hopes of that, but Pietro really should hate him for being a power hungry dick who wants to be greater than everyone. Pietro is honestly a great character when he's not out-of-character working for Magneto.
oh yeah that was covered in that '90s Avengers miniseries iirc. Vision is made from a temporal copy of the OG torch?

I agree that Wanda-Pietro-Magneto have been great when written well. We've had a focus on Wanda recently with the Darkhold Stuff and the X-Men books where she's sorta dead again?
Pietro's "Avengers No Surrender" spinoff miniseries was nice too, but not well executed.
I've had a soft spot for Laurel Gand, particularly the SW6 version of the character as the Andromeda costume kicked ass with the star field and loin cloth. I was not too fond of how they turned her into a xenophobic cunt after the reboot. Granted, she repented and earned her redemption.
yeah i thought she was fun.
Well, the "good" news is that Will Payton returned in Scott Snyder's Justice League. As for Yolanda and Beth, Geoff Johns brought them back to life in Doomsday Clock.
Yeah they sort of brought him back, only to have him fucking die again asfaik.

Nice of them to use a legacy hero that thematically connects the JSA-JLA-Future League stuff.
By my count, Barry stayed dead for twenty-two years. As for CoIE, I heard rumors that DC did contemplate a total reboot. Greg Weisman (of Gargoyles/Joung Justice fame) was an editorial assistant at the time asked why they didn't just do it at meeting and the answer was that New Teen Titans was their top seller at the time and a reboot would basically kill the title. Ironic considering that George Perez's Wonder Woman turned Donna Troy's history into a continuity knot. @Water-T went over the Crisis' effects on the LoSH. The Hawkworld retcon royally fucked over the Hawks. Frankly, the post-Crisis DCU was even more confusing that the pre-Crisis multiverse because of their selective retcons, which created a cascading effect of more retcons and reboots that never ends. Hell, I even look at the New 52 as a failure right out of the gate because DC refused to reboot Batman and Green Lantern's histories. If you want to reboot your universe... commit to the fucking bit.
I wish they'd finished the original Katar Hol Thanagarian Invasion shit that was happening before they brought Hawkworld into the mix. Shit got confusing and I couldn't really figure it out despite being a comics sperg.

Like, suddenly the Silver Age Katar Hol was Fel Andar all along, an alien sleeper agent? But then he got some human woman to simp for him and become his Hawkgirl?

But then the golden age hawkman never factored into this?

Don't get me wrong, I like the edgy grim Hawkworld Hawkman/Woman, it's just that their inclusion was a little after the Crisis and it felt like a weird after-thought. Plus,I NEVER understood what the fuck that astral "Hawkgod" thing even was when the series got into the '90s. Like dude, I wanted to like it but the entire thing got fucked up.

at least the grimdark Katar Hol was acknowledged as having existed by the time the 2000s rolled around. His Hawkwoman also died heroically in one of the Starlin cosmic DC miniseries things too (Along with the last of the Darkstars too iirc. I think they all died fighting that Starbreaker dude from the '70s JLA books?)

Hawkman continuity is fucking weird because the 2000s suddenly brought Golden Eagle (the semi sidekick) back to life, but as the son of the traitorous Fel Andar and he had a hate boner for Carter Hall? Weird.

Then uh, the whole Onimar Synn introduction and Carter somehow being able to bless a vat of holy water because he was a bishop in a past life?

Man I wish they played up the reincarnation knowledge of Hawkman as a thing more often. It was literally the premise of why the Batman Who Laughs considered him a big enough threat to "Infect", but we never get good Hawkman stories it seems.

Oh yeah the recent Hawkman series had the revelation that Hawkman's original life was as a galactic scale mass murderer/warrior named K'Tar Deathbringer or some shit and that the reincarnations were a curse from The Presence iirc. Also something about Shayera's original life being that of an Angel?


Hawkman's fucked up mythos gives the entirety of the X-Men a good run for their money in being a clusterfuck. But I'd rather have that than more twitterizing.
 
You know, if the JSA is going to get a continuous comic series like before, I hope they flesh out the characters more.
 
I was not too fond of how they turned her into a xenophobic cunt after the reboot. Granted, she repented and earned her redemption.
To be fair to her, xenophobia was an ingrained part of Daxamite culture. Their weakness to lead was genetically created to punish then for leaving Krypton, leading then to stay on the planet lest they get exposed and die from such a common element. This eventually led to them becoming distrustful of other species and becoming extremely hateful of aliens.

I can't seem to quote reply @King Koalemos recent post, so i'll just do a quick run through on the Infinity Inc crew:

The evil Harlequin was the niece of the Dan Richards Manhunter. She died after Solomon Grundy killed her in a rage for tricking him into killing Skyman by pretending to be Jade, who he was obsessed with at the time (but in a puppy dog way, not a rapey way)

Hazard was the granddaughter of the Gambler, using dice as a focus for her bad luck powers. She felt guilty about helping Injustice Unlimited murder Skyman, and used her bad luck powers to allow Stripesy and his son to escape before the team could murder them too.

Jade did date Kyle Rayner for a while, after her inborn powers were burned out. He made a duplicate ring for her, and after he was boosted by the Ion entity that used to live in the Main Power Battery on Oa, he reignited her natural born powers again.

Hector was a douche, but he got fucked over hard. Due to a family curse, he was born without a soul, allowing the Silver Scarab demon to slowly take over him from within and be used as an agent to awake an ancient weapon. He literally SHED off Hector's skin, leaving an empty husk. Unfortunately for him, Lyta was pregnant with his baby, making him "impure" and thus unable to control the weapon, leading to his death. A few months later, he ended up in the Dream Dimension ruled by the Sandman that Kirby created in the 70s, and visited Lyta in her sleep. They reunited and got married, and then a bunch of stuff involving the 90s Sandman resulted in Hector dying again and Lyta's baby Daniel becoming the new Sandman of the Endless. Then Hector was reborn in a new body and took over as the new Dr. Fate. Eventually he and Lyta were welcomed into the afterlife together by their son Daniel, leading one of Kent Nelson's descendants to take over the role.

Norda stayed in limbo after II ended, until the 2000s JSA series. His tribe further evolved into hawk-headed people with no ability to speak, and were given asylum in Black Adam's country after their colony in Greenland collapsed in exchange for becoming Adam's personal Air Force.

Rick (Hourman II) gained the ability to see an hour into the future, as well as visit his father who was trapped outside of time. He eventually rescued his dad, and married Jesse Quick, who then took on her mother's mantle of Liberty Belle.

Early drafts of Inf Inc showed that Todd was planned to be a male Harlequin AND openly gay, but they opted for shadow-based powers to contrast with Jade's light-based ones. He eventually embraced his love for cock. And yes, his adopted father was an abusive alcoholic, but when Todd was full-blown evil due to the influence of Ian Karkull, he dragged Mr. Rice to the Shadow Dimension and tortured him to death. *plays tiny violin*
 
Back
Top Bottom