Sonic The Hedgehog Games

[Red flaming panda]

>Kirby is allow to get away with reusing shit, why can't Sonic
The problem isn't they're reusing a level, it's the fact they don't even try to make it unique. Hell, if you know anything about Sonic Team is that they love reusing models (Take for example the current sonic model itself)
This isn't "fake outrage", people are annoyed that Sonic Team are being lazy shits. Dosen't help that Frontiers is suppose to be the big one and they're still rehashing Greenhill
Also Whispy Woods is a boss that takes like 30 secs while greenhill is a whole level, this is apples to oranges

A better argument would be to use Mario
Since all of the New games are literally just rehashes of Mario 3

 

[MooseGump]

Dosen't help that Frontiers is suppose to be the big one and they're still rehashing Greenhill
Also Whispy Woods is a boss that takes like 30 secs while greenhill is a whole level, this is apples to orange

They can also argue that Kirby likes to reuse Green Greens as a first level alongside Whispy Woods but oh wait, each game after Return to Dreamland puts a spin on Green Greens while throwing on a new song that makes the whole thing a blast to go through

And yet when Sega tries to put a spin on Green Hill we get the Sand Hill line

 

[Red flaming panda]

Right enough shitting on Sonic for once, blue sperg already has it bad

IGN made a top ten list of the best Sonic games

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

 

[Celebrate Nite]

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

>Sonic Generations being better than Sonic Mania
lolno. Taxman/Stealth's game blows away Sega's nostalgia fest by miles.

 

[Mr. 0]

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

View attachment 3494384

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

Sonic 06 should always be at the top of the list

>Sonic Generations being better than Sonic Mania
lolno. Taxman/Stealth's game blows away Sega's nostalgia fest by miles.

Taxman/Stealth's game IS a nostalgia fest

 

[Red flaming panda]

>Sonic Generations being better than Sonic Mania
lolno. Taxman/Stealth's game blows away Sega's nostalgia fest by miles.

I'm surprised they didn't put SA2 at number 1 with how much that is the most normie take
But Generations that fucking high up? Games journalist just love having their hands holed like fucking babies

Forces should always be at the top of the list

Ftfy

 

[Liquid Marlon]

>Kirby is allow to get away with reusing shit, why can't Sonic
The problem isn't they're reusing a level, it's the fact they don't even try to make it unique. Hell, if you know anything about Sonic Team is that they love reusing models (Take for example the current sonic model itself)
This isn't "fake outrage", people are annoyed that Sonic Team are being lazy shits. Dosen't help that Frontiers is suppose to be the big one and they're still rehashing Greenhill
Also Whispy Woods is a boss that takes like 30 secs while greenhill is a whole level, this is apples to oranges

A better argument would be to use Mario
Since all of the New games are literally just rehashes of Mario 3

I explained a reason for why it is different already but I'm pretty sure it's simpler, Sonic 4 was the start of SEGA nostalgia baiting but it wasn't the start of the outrage for Green Hills returning.

It was never a big deal at the time and some of the examples that are used nowadays don't even make sense with contexts like Smash Bros or Sonic Battle where one was a stage representing and the other was a secret stage akin to SA2.

Pretty sure the reason why it's a big deal lies inside of Sonic Generations and that's the same reason why people are now fed up with Classic Sonic along with Chemical Plant, Sonic 4 really pissed off Classic fans so that's why when he came back it was a special thing, the hate for Classic Sonic came completely from Sonic Forces and Mania made it sadly worse.

Sonic used to be on the same level as Mario and Kirby when it came to retro callbacks, like nobody is made that Classic Kirby is in Star Allies or the retro style in Odyssey but SEGA captured lightning in a bottle with Gens which they glamorize and put a huge emphasis on because it was really a big deal at the time but then fucked it by trying to do it again in the next anticipated game in the timeline.

 

[NerdShamer]

Right enough shitting on Sonic for once, blue sperg already has it bad

IGN made a top ten list of the best Sonic games
https://youtube.com/watch?v=kdHYNl-IXWM

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

View attachment 3494384

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

It's more or less what I'd expected. Kind of confused why Sonic & Knuckles isn't on that list, though

 

[SSj_Ness (Yiffed)]

Right enough shitting on Sonic for once, blue sperg already has it bad

IGN made a top ten list of the best Sonic games
https://youtube.com/watch?v=kdHYNl-IXWM

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

View attachment 3494384

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

It's not a terrible list (6/10), but mine would probably be entirely 2D (with spin-offs).

 

[MagneticTowels]

Forget Hydro City vs. Hydrossity!

The real question is:

https://sonic.fandom.com/wiki/Aquatic_Relix_Zone

Aquatic Reel-ix or Aquatic Relics?

 

[BrunoMattei]

Right enough shitting on Sonic for once, blue sperg already has it bad

IGN made a top ten list of the best Sonic games
https://youtube.com/watch?v=kdHYNl-IXWM

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

View attachment 3494384

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

Not even putting the Genesis titles in the top 5. WTF is this? Instantly disregarded.

 

[Blitzsneed]

Right enough shitting on Sonic for once, blue sperg already has it bad

IGN made a top ten list of the best Sonic games
https://youtube.com/watch?v=kdHYNl-IXWM

Spoiler: The full list

10. Unleashed
9. Rush
8. Sonic 2
7. Sonic CD
6. Sonic 3
5. Sonic Colors
4. Sonic Advance
3. Sonic Adventure2
2. Sonic Mania
1. Sonic Generations

View attachment 3494384

How do you rate this tier list kiwis

>IGN

Regarding the list: Colors is overrated, it is an "ok" game. How it is on 5th place and especially above 3 and CD is beyond me.

Spoiler: Personal list

10. Sonic Colors
9. Sonic Unleashed
8. Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed
7. Sonic 2
6. Sonic Advance 3
5. Sonic Adventure 2
4. Sonic Generations
3. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
2. Sonic CD
1. Sonic Mania

 

[Liquid Marlon]

3. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
2. Sonic CD

What the fuck is wrong with you?

 

[MooseGump]

What the fuck is wrong with you?

Because 3 stands for Sonic 3 you dope

 

[Kane Lives]

>IGN
and_into_the_trash_you_go.webm

Regarding the list: Colors is overrated, it is an "ok" game. How it is on 5th place and especially above 3 and CD is beyond me.

Spoiler: Personal list

10. Sonic Colors
9. Sonic Unleashed
8. Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed
7. Sonic 2
6. Sonic Advance 3
5. Sonic Adventure 2
4. Sonic Generations
3. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
2. Sonic CD
1. Sonic Mania

Sir, you're going to have to explain how CD rates above S3&K.

Also kinda funny how the OG didn't make the list, but that's to be expected. Sonic 1 was pretty rough on a replay some time back.

 

[Blitzsneed]

Sir, you're going to have to explain how CD rates above S3&K.

Also kinda funny how the OG didn't make the list, but that's to be expected. Sonic 1 was pretty rough on a replay some time back.

Personal preference. I'd rather say that they would share the same rank. Sonic 1 was indeed rough.

What the fuck is wrong with you?

lol calm down

 

[Celebrate Nite]

Personal preference. I'd rather say that they would share the same rank. Sonic 1 was indeed rough.

Sonic 1 was more of a traditional platformer than the GOTTA GO FAST type of games that followed starting with Sonic 2. You really have to give the game multiple playthroughs in order to have the levels memorized by heart (and to also discover the additional routes you can take that are quicker/have more items). It was probably Sega testing the waters of what worked and didn't work in a Sonic game.

Sonic CD is also a traditional platformer, but the problem is that it tries to have it's cake and eat it too with the GOTTA GO FAST schtick, specifically with the Super Peel-Out and the Time Travel mechanics that require speed to be activated when the majority of the levels aren't built for that kind of thing (only SPECIFIC parts of them). This becomes an issue when you are trying to get good futures on all the zones considering there aren't too many PAST sign-posts to begin with and one fuck-up on gaining speed will leave you with no choice but to commit suicide and start over. For me it's why I consider Sonic CD the black sheep of the family and rank it below titles like Sonic 3D Blast or even Sonic R.

 

[Liquid Marlon]

Always have been mixed about Sonic Runners Reloaded and this event looks pretty shitty ngl.

 

[Gru]

Always have been mixed about Sonic Runners Reloaded and this event looks pretty shitty ngl.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=KOuOdJzGQ4U

It genuinely looks like a shitty flash game, the sprites just feel like they're jerking around like an aforementioned shitty flash game, and they couldn't get sprites for the enemies or collectibles? I'm sure there's some autist out there who would've done it for them.

 

[BrunoMattei]

Sonic 1 was more of a traditional platformer than the GOTTA GO FAST type of games that followed starting with Sonic 2. You really have to give the game multiple playthroughs in order to have the levels memorized by heart (and to also discover the additional routes you can take that are quicker/have more items). It was probably Sega testing the waters of what worked and didn't work in a Sonic game.

Sonic CD is also a traditional platformer, but the problem is that it tries to have it's cake and eat it too with the GOTTA GO FAST schtick, specifically with the Super Peel-Out and the Time Travel mechanics that require speed to be activated when the majority of the levels aren't built for that kind of thing (only SPECIFIC parts of them). This becomes an issue when you are trying to get good futures on all the zones considering there aren't too many PAST sign-posts to begin with and one fuck-up on gaining speed will leave you with no choice but to commit suicide and start over. For me it's why I consider Sonic CD the black sheep of the family and rank it below titles like Sonic 3D Blast or even Sonic R.

I never liked Sanic 1 just because it had too many instant deaths and it was very stop and go. I played it back in the day, all excited because I played the shit out of 2 and 3 & Knuckles, got Super Sonic on all those games, thinking "Okay, the 1st one has to be as good." And it really isn't. It's not a terrible game. It's a fine platformer. But it never ascends the same way as the sequels. It's unfortunate that faggots always go back to the first game as an excuse to shit all over the Genesis titles.

CD is okay. It's better with the Jap soundtrack. It's better than 1 but not as good as the rest of the Genesis series (excluding 3D Blast of course).