Human penis size and sexual selection
Our study provides insights into the potential role of sexual selection in the evolution of penis size in humans. It is, however, important to recognize that human mate preferences are strongly influenced by cultural norms and the environmental setting [
72]. Ideals about masculinity and attractiveness vary widely across cultures and over time within different cultures. Some societies place great emphasis on height and body shape, while others prioritize facial features or social status [
73]. It is worth noting that while the data for the in-person female surveys was mostly from white females [
35], the other five surveys we ran involved participants from a wide range of ethnicities. It should further be noted that selection analysis at the population-level (i.e., using mean scores per figure) closely resembled those seen when calculating individual selection gradients for each participant. This is particularly apparent for linear selection. This suggests that any variation among participants due to ethnicity, cultural upbringing and so on, is minor. Most participants show the same pattern of evaluating taller, more V-shaped males with a larger penis as more attractive or better fighters. It is important to note that our computer-generated figures had flaccid penises. Flaccid penis length is known to be positively correlated with erect length [
60].
While a flaccid penis is a more common state in humans and probably a more relevant signal available to assess a rival’s fighting ability, male-male displays in other primates and female choice in humans can involve erect penises [1,2]. It is plausible, therefore, that using figures with an erect penis might reveal an even stronger effect of penis size on sexual attractiveness and assessment of fighting ability. Future studies using erect penises remain an avenue for future research to test this claim. Of course, the degree to which penis size is emphasized varies with media portrayals and societal narratives. Future studies could therefore include cross-cultural comparisons to disentangle the relative contribution of cultural norms to selection on male traits due to mate choice or fighting assessment.
In sum, we provide robust experimental evidence that sexual selection can act on multiple male traits that combine to determine male attractiveness and the perception of attractiveness and fighting ability. These traits include penis size, in association with height and body shape. Controlling for variation in other traits, both female mate choice and male assessments of rivals strongly favor larger penis size. The question remains open, however, as to whether this potential for selection affected the evolution of human penis size, as the opportunity for female choice is unresolved in our ancestral past. In patrilineal and agropastoral societies, marital decisions are usually determined by kin. In traditional foraging societies—commonly used as proxies for ancestral human social structures—parents generally exert significant control over their daughters’ mating decisions [
74]. In matrilineal and matrilocal systems, however, female autonomy is more pronounced [
75]. Likewise, across many contexts, women often exercised mate choice even under constraint—through selective compliance, extra-pair relationships, or re-partnering after marital dissolution [
76]. The existence of the strong female preference for greater penis size that we observed in our study suggests that these preferences are likely to have been present in our ancestors, and therefore will have had some role in sexual selection, causing the evolution of the enlarged human penis. It is also worth noting that penis size and shape may have been selected for because of their effects on sexual stimulation, specifically by increasing the likelihood of female orgasm, which has, in turn, been linked to improved sperm retention, facilitating sperm activation, and encouraging additional copulations [
6,
77,
78]. It therefore seems likely that both pre- and post-copulatory sexual selection have contributed to the evolution of human penis size. Given that little is known about the link between penis size and the outcome of male-male contests for mates, this link is worthy of further exploration as a potential driver of the evolution of penis size in our ancestors [
79].