- Joined
- Jan 3, 2017
Dan was a sex crazed maniac - can't have that because it would be white male patriarchy abusing their power structure. Once in a while you see a glimmer of what made the old show work in the new one. Unfortunately like his old sitcom, one of the characters has to be an alcoholic (in this case Harry's daughter, although it gave her one of the only good parts of the show, and that was dramatic, not even comedy).
John Larroquette has been in recovery since the early 80s -- if you watch his acceptance speeches for his Emmys, he thanks the friends of Bill W. So I suspect that angle is important to him. That being said, the scene between him and Rauch on the subject was far and away the best moment of the series so far. It really highlights how much wasted potential there was in getting Larroquette back and then just blowing the writing and characters on garbage, unfunny comedy.
But Dan Fielding isn't even close to the same character he was in the old show. They basically pulled a Picard on him.
I don't necessarily mind this. Part of the original show's finale involved Dan finally getting a comeuppance for his years of womanizing. Half of it was legitimately unsettling (he's confronted by the mother of his current conquest, who turns out to be someone he fucked-and-left back when he was 18 or 19); half of it was absurd (he has a nightmare about being put on trial by every woman he ever screwed ... amusingly, this was easily the biggest crowd scene in the entire series). His character having settled down does make sense. However, the fourth episode shows just how skittish they are about the old version of his character, and how it's probably going to be completely buried: Dan goes on a date, and there's not one allusion to his old ways, except for a throwaway line about how he can't remember ever having said no to having sex. It's pathetic. If they ever bring up what Dan used to be like, it'll be to make painful virtue signals about it.
You can't have the sassy black baliff be violent like Roz. She has to be cute and funny like Queen Latifah. The new guy in Mac's job? Can't have a male be competent or confident. He's a total cuck.
One really disappointing thing I realized from rewatching was seeing just how good Charles Robinson and Marsha Warfield were. Robinson was an amazing straight man (until they turned him goofy in the last season or two with his filmmaking silliness), and Warfield was one of the funniest people in the cast, both in the character's concept and her deadpan delivery. Also, you don't appreciate how comparatively slim and trim she was until you see the living planetoid that is "Gurds."