It still makes me laugh that these morons' criticism about the Star Wars Prequels boiled down to "this isn't like the OT!"
Mike's general criticism was that the fun space fantasy movies based off of the old Buck Rogers serials and WW2 footage were supplanted by people sitting around talking about taxation on trade routes or CGI schlockfests that ruined key parts of the original films (eg, the Force as this mystical, spiritual thing rather than just a tool to lob rocks or have Yoda flip around like the baby from Ally McBeal or having James Earl Jones say the word 'Padme.')
Then when Disney turns the franchise into endless OT memberberries,
The OT memberberries you're talking about is more CGI schlock, so this is consistent with their criticisms of the prequels.
they get pissed, especially with their Rogue One review which was them mocking it for being like the OT. They really don't understand that this is the fruits of their labor.
It is, if you take only a surface level understanding of the criticisms levied against the prequels.
You can deride Mike's own personal tastes, his understanding of cinema, his functional alcoholism, or his inability to articulate things very well, but he's generally been pretty consistent about what he wants:
1) A good story
2) that is in-line with the themes, tones, vibe, etc. of the world it exists in.
Whether this is from a series of films (Star Trek, Indiana Jones, Star Wars) or just a singular film, that generally is what he wants. I don't think Rogue One is a particularly good story. The idea of a ragtag group going through and succeeding vs. the Empire is very much 'Star Wars' but the execution felt more like a rough draft. And honestly? Vader going in and murdering everyone en masse might be 'so kewl how it seamlessly blends into Episode 1' but it comes off as a downer even though the good guys 'won' (which, yes, we know what happens here and the whole movie is pointless as a result because the one thing it could've done -- create new characters to use in future projects -- didn't happen and, oops, they realized that as Andor is a prequel to the prequel.)
I'd argue that the closest Disney got to that was with the first 2 seasons of the Mandalorian.