Hey, Handsome Tard here, back after the Doxxing Scare. Turns out my flextape-Hyperion fortress kept me safe (also a VPN didnt hurt). Aaaaanyway...
MGS4 certainly has it's moments, but I just hate shit like retconning Vamp as not supernatural and the over reliance on "nano machines" as a plot device.
The more time goes on the more I respect Kojima's original decision to end the storyline with Sons of Liberty, which sure, was a bold idea, but leaving stuff to our imagination is better than what we got in 4.
I respectfully disagree. I still think him just stopping in Sons of Liberty would have been worse in the long term. I did really like what we got on 4, sure, everyone can say that this and that could have been done better but I do think the last acts are one of the best in MG history (the microwave hall sequence, the fight between Old Snake and Liquid Ocelot and the ending redeem most flaws to me).
About Vamp, well, the series keeps using supernatural elements but it does feel like it started to almost because ashamed of it by the time 4 happened (1 had Psycho Mantis, 2 had Fortune actually stopping bullets with no magnetic device and 3 had the sorrow). I think its suppose to add to the somewhat cynical/nihilistic tone that 4 was going for at first (like that codec call between Otacon pretty much saying to Snake that him beating Raven on that tank was "unrealistic/impossible"...forgetting that he is Snake and the impossible is kind of what he makes possible on a constant basis). I always liked Vamp in 4 but I do admit that the whole nano-machines giving him Wolverine type healing was a bit forced (but be honest, going the other extreme and saying he is an actual vampire would be going too far, wouldnt it?), I really think Kojima wrote himself into a corner there so he embraced how insane nano-machines are and just went for it. Kind of always made me wonder why the fuck couldnt they give some of those OP nano-machines to Old Snake to stop or reduce his accelerated aging, or hell, I even imagined a HISHE styled scene of sorts.
Old Snake: Wait wait wait wait....you created nano-machines that can actually give you a super healing factor?!
Naomi: Yes but-
Old Snake: So aw, tell me, can you make Nano-machines that....
*later*
Snake: *back to his MGS2 self*Hey guys, Im back to my "old" self, hehehe.
Otacon: Good thing nano-machines can kind of do anything now.
Naomi: But wouldnt it be better to accept your mortality for one final mission?
Snake:....yeah but you know, kind of can do said mission better being young again and I want to, like, live after this. Why do I die while everyone else lives? Anyway...
Later...
Liquid Ocelot: FIGHT ME SN-
Snake: *CQC him easily to the ground* There.
Liquid Ocelot: RAH!.....you know, this went better in my head....you are pretty good tho...Rahaa *dies*
Snake: Man, things are so much easier now. Imagine if I was still old.
Liquid Ocelot: oh FYI, I was faking. Im not Liquid, just really crazy for your dad...no homo...kind of. *dies for real*
Snake:......
Otacon: man, its great how things worked out. Usually there is always some sort of terrible event centered around me.
Naomi: .......I have cancer
Otacon: YOU HAVE WHA-
THE END
....
Big Boss: its been a while, Snake-
Snake: *literally CQC him to the ground*
Big Boss: GRAH!....This could have gone better....This is...quite anti-climatic, isnt it? *dies*
Snake:.....well, that happened....who is the guy in the wheel chair?
He probably also did the same thing with Ocelot's possession by Liquid. I always assumed that by revealing his father was The Sorrow, Kojima's original idea was that Ocelot had similar powers.
Im absolutely sure that this is where Kojima was heading because the whole "nah, he was faking it" felt so out of left field as if to try to force a twist. But it does show how almost insanely loyal Ocelot was to go through all of this just for his ambiguiously gay bro Big Boss.
MGS4 is a game that constantly alternates between being the best game in the series and the worst
I think thats the best way to describe 4. You either love it or hate it (I happen to lean towards the former but I do recognize why some people see it as the latter).