Mechanical Keyboard Autism Thread - Because Cherry MX switches get you laid.

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
That's certainly an issue I've never had with my repro kishsaver.
That would fix it but by having the wider border it sort of loses the point of having the 60% to move your mouse hand in a bit as it's nearer 80%/TKL size. Thankfully my shoulders are wide enough I don't need to give a shit about that ever for it to be ergonomic for me.
 
The most expensive Raspberry Pi product yet: a mechanical keyboard.

 
Linear switches are genuinely so retarded. When I want to use a keyboard, I want to click my keys, not give each key a weird half-click that is supposedly faster.
>But muh vidya. Muh response time.
If you are spending hundreds of dollars on a controller in order to make yourself 0.0001% better at video games, you would be better off with an actual controller or the box thing that fighting game people use. No video game requires as many keys as keyboards have. Keyboards are made for typing, and not for video games. The only reason I use them for such is because keyboards are good enough and I can't be bothered to spend a whole bunch for something better.
 
Linear switches are genuinely so retarded. When I want to use a keyboard, I want to click my keys, not give each key a weird half-click that is supposedly faster.
>But muh vidya. Muh response time.
If you are spending hundreds of dollars on a controller in order to make yourself 0.0001% better at video games, you would be better off with an actual controller or the box thing that fighting game people use. No video game requires as many keys as keyboards have. Keyboards are made for typing, and not for video games. The only reason I use them for such is because keyboards are good enough and I can't be bothered to spend a whole bunch for something better.
Agreed. There is an argument to be made for the modern HE linears that can do analog sensing, ie lightly resting your finger on a key has one effect, and fully pressing it has another. Like ”preview on a partial click, actually perform on a full click” for some softwares or games. But for typing, give me the loudest most clickiest keyboard you can find (hello Model F Reproduction project) because clicky=tactile (keyboards actually sold as ”tactile” are really just linears with some sandpaper in the switch).
 
Thoughts on split ortho keyboards? Been using ye olde 30$ 60% aliexpress board for a minute so I wanna get one of these as a replacement. I'm currently split between Lily58 and Cantor Remix given the price range I've got (no more than 150$ ideally).
 
Have any of you tried the "Gateron Milky Yellow Pro" linear switch?

It's absolutely amazing. It feels like writing on glorious butter. Like firm but soft butter that goes thock.

I've been using the Cherry MX Browns for a long time, or some variant of this kind of tactile switch, but man am I glad I found the Milky Yellow Pro.

If you're interested in trying out a linear switch, I highly recommend these switches.
 
okay I haven't been able to financially justify this purchase in the 2+ years I've wanted to, but my Logitech G413 SE is now broken. The left key keeps firing for no reason and I am pretty confident it is because the cable is worn and the wires are exposed.

So I have never built a mechanical keyboard and tbh I am quite overwhelmed with the options. I want to build one because I have ceramic keycaps. I like how they look. They 're just neat. They've been siting in my box of neat things. It is time to build a keyboard.

For the ceramic keycaps to work, they need plungers with 40gf and a minimum of 55gf for the spacebar. I don't know what kind of switches I want. My keyboard has brown switches and they feel right, The Internet says they're Long Hua Tactiles with 45gf actuation 50-75 bottom out. I realize while being aware of this that I never press the key all the way down and when I do it feels uncomfortably hard. So I feel like I need something that, with the ceramic keycaps, will have an obvious actuation because that's what I feel for.

I don't like the cheap plastic sound of the keyboard but I don't want some noisy fucking racket either.
 
The left key keeps firing for no reason and I am pretty confident it is because the cable is worn and the wires are exposed.
That sounds like the switch is fucked in some way and might be repairable, but it would require soldering to change the switch. I'm sure you have more important things to deal with than engage in DIY keyboard repair.

I've been using a custom WASD Keyboards V2 keyboard for over a decade, but sadly they went out of business this year, so I can't recommend them anymore. One of the things I like about it is that the cable uses a USB-C connector so you can easily swap the cable if it gets fucked.

Other than swappable cables, nowadays there are fancy keyboards with hot-swappable switches. If a switch breaks, you just easily swap it out without having to do any soldering and move on with your day. If you're going for a "buy it for life" approach it should be something to keep in mind.
 
So I have never built a mechanical keyboard and tbh I am quite overwhelmed with the options. I want to build one because I have ceramic keycaps. I like how they look. They 're just neat. They've been siting in my box of neat things. It is time to build a keyboard.
Sounds like an epic project. If you actually spend a lot of time on a keyboard you get a feel for your specific keyboard and doing things like replacing the keycaps with ones more to your preference will make you enjoy it more. Personally I don't give a shit about the noise. In fact, I prefer crunchy keyboards that make a lot of noise, although I could do without artificial added noises.

The old IBM 3270 keyboards with two rows of function keys, adding up to 24 function keys, were awesome, and they would put out a racket. Ceramic tends to make a bit of noise. I'm not sure how to do that even if you can silence the beamspring noise that puts out a lot of sound.
48751736838_9f64ee70f2_o.jpg
Never built a keyboard personally (other than replacing the keycaps and installing a foot pedal and stuff like that), but I've customized them to be more to my liking.

The tactile feel (the kind of shit haptics seek to emulate these days) of these keyboards was very satisfying and something you rarely see these days, and being able to remap two dozen function keys to do whatever the fuck you feel like was also great.

I'd suggest trying to find something with the feel you like but without the sound you apparently don't.
I used the kinesis for about 3 weeks, right up to when I would be able to return it. I think the concave form just didn't work for my hands/wrists, and honestly a surprising side effect was that when I would travel on site without it, typing on my laptop's keyboard became difficult.
It's sort of weird. When I first switched to the Advantage, it was because "normal" keyboards were starting to cause me carpal tunnel/tendonitis and other bad shit and it was becoming outright painful. Not only did normal keyboards cause me pain, they were actually also causing me obvious mechanical damage to my hands and wrists and the tendons between my wrists and elbows.

Totally went away with the switch although it took a couple months to get used to it. Also it stops people in the workplace from asking to use your computer because of the weird alien device you brought in.
 
Last edited:
I need something that, with the ceramic keycaps, will have an obvious actuation because that's what I feel for.
I was kind of in the same boat, I was looking for something with that nice tactile bump you had to overcome when you pressed a key. I ended up with Kailh Box Navy switches and I absolutely adore them but they can be a bit much. They do make ones that are less intense like the Box Jade, Those are 50g switches and a lot closer to what you wanted.

The only down side is they do make noise but they don’t sound cheap and shitty. My old Cherry MX blue keyboard sounds like a tub of legos sloshing around after upgrading. Modern keyboards are filled with foam and gaskets to keep the sound down.
 
So I have never built a mechanical keyboard and tbh I am quite overwhelmed with the options. I want to build one because I have ceramic keycaps. I like how they look. They 're just neat. They've been siting in my box of neat things. It is time to build a keyboard.
Mechanical keyboards are kind of overhyped imho. Don't get me wrong, i'm using one right now and it feels good, but i was using a membrane one and it was EXCELENT. Mechanical keyboards have it's advantages, but the main issue with them is that the fucking keys just stop working sometimes, and with one keyboard i had an entire column of keys stop working for no reason and i had to buy another one. With another mechanical keyboard the thing had some one faulty key out of the box, i had to press it hard as fuck at an angle for the input to register.
I don't even know why i insist on buying mechanical keyboards when i don't even game with M&K.
 
So I have never built a mechanical keyboard and tbh I am quite overwhelmed with the options. I want to build one because I have ceramic keycaps. I like how they look. They 're just neat. They've been siting in my box of neat things. It is time to build a keyboard.
You don't actually need to build a keyboard, and if you want the best experience you probably shouldn't. There are plenty of prebuilt keyboards with easily swappable switches and key caps. For example this one, which I think is pretty cool, it has a nice layout and a built-in calculator. By default it comes with linear switches with foam and gaskets prefitted, so it will be very silent, but have next to no tactility. But if you're pulling the key caps anyway, you might as well pull the switches also, it won't add much time, and install something like Kailh Deep Sea Silent Pro Whale Tactile switches. The name is a mouthful, but basically it's a silenced, slightly heavy box switch, which seems like exactly what you're looking for (ceramic switches are heavy, so with a heavy key cap the result will be somewhere in the middle).
 
I was kind of in the same boat, I was looking for something with that nice tactile bump you had to overcome when you pressed a key. I ended up with Kailh Box Navy switches and I absolutely adore them but they can be a bit much. They do make ones that are less intense like the Box Jade, Those are 50g switches and a lot closer to what you wanted.

The only down side is they do make noise but they don’t sound cheap and shitty. My old Cherry MX blue keyboard sounds like a tub of legos sloshing around after upgrading. Modern keyboards are filled with foam and gaskets to keep the sound down.
I've been using a keyboard with MX Browns for five years now. I've lubed the switches and put silicone dampening rings under the keycaps.

That did improve the overall experience massively, but what made it prefect for me (as far as this kind of technology goes, anyway) was a change in spring hardness for exactly two keys: W and the spacebar.

I have put a lighter spring (from an MX Speed Silver, Cherry's lightest switch, ~40g) under the W key and a harder one (from an MX Green switch, Cherry's hardest, ~80g) under the spacebar. (I took the springs out of a Cherry keyswitch tester I had bought before buying the keyboard.)

Due to this change, my left-hand middle finger wouldn't hurt anymore when gaming for hours, and the harder spacebar spring would also prevent the accidental presses that happen all too easily with the default MX Brown spring.
 
Mechanical keyboards have it's advantages, but the main issue with them is that the fucking keys just stop working sometimes, and with one keyboard i had an entire column of keys stop working for no reason and i had to buy another one. With another mechanical keyboard the thing had some one faulty key out of the box, i had to press it hard as fuck at an angle for the input to register.
I just checked when exactly I got my WASD V2, it was just over 9 years. I got it with Cherry MX Black switches and in all this time I have never had any issues with a switch malfunctioning. I also have an old Razer Black Widow (I think first gen?) with blue switches that I took to the office after getting the WASD at home. I've used that for coding at the office but I've had switches fail on me (they'd sometimes activate twice when pressed) and I ended up replacing them a few times.
 
I just checked when exactly I got my WASD V2, it was just over 9 years.
For how much? Because, i mean, you can get very high quality keyboards that won't give you as many issues as some shit from AliExpress, but at same time i'm thinking "shit, i'm not gonna spend $150 on a keyboard, i can find one that does the job for $10 at Walmart".
 
For how much? Because, i mean, you can get very high quality keyboards that won't give you as many issues as some shit from AliExpress, but at same time i'm thinking "shit, i'm not gonna spend $150 on a keyboard, i can find one that does the job for $10 at Walmart".
It was exactly $150... Although shipping was an extra +$75. The europoor tax. True enough, that's a lot to spend on a keyboard, but after all this time I think it was worth it.
 
Though currently sold out at the time of posting this, I have a MK Night Typist with Cherry Brown switches that's been good to me for about 4.5 years now. I plan on getting another one when this one finally dies from the near-daily heavy usage. Though with how well it's holding up that could easily be another 4.5 years.
 
Either I don't take care of my electronics, or I have had bad luck.... my mechanical keyboards I've had always double type within a year or two.
 
Either I don't take care of my electronics, or I have had bad luck.... my mechanical keyboards I've had always double type within a year or two.
Wash your hands before you sit down to one and clean them periodically.

I just replaced my Corsair K70 Lux after 9 years. Incidentally, the first key to start double-firing was N. Thanks, Kiwi Farms.
 
Back
Top Bottom