Magic The Gathering

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Didn't Dominaria Remastered ultimately hard flop and is still available at under launch prices? I'm surprised they didn't abandon the format yet, but maybe this time around it will be the last nail in the coffin as I can't imagine Ravnica Remastered going over well. What reprint value can they even stuff into it at this point? Dark Confidant?
They're just going to repackage all that dragon's maze that they couldn't move back in 2013! they found pallets of the stuff in a warehouse and are going to insert them into collector boosters! just think, you might open a mint maze's end, or even a plasma capture, or *gasp* a Vorel of the hull clade???? In all seriousness, I actually think this remastered set is the strongest one they've announced, since Ravnica is very internally cohesive. since all the colors are paired off in the thing they do, and you have plenty of fixing with the gates, I wouldn't be surprised if this is one of the best limited environments in years. I also think the plan is to use this to bring a bunch of rtr era cards to arena smoothly. I do also think they'll put shock lands in the thing, dropping them back down to 4-6$ each.
 
They're just going to repackage all that dragon's maze that they couldn't move back in 2013! they found pallets of the stuff in a warehouse and are going to insert them into collector boosters! just think, you might open a mint maze's end, or even a plasma capture, or *gasp* a Vorel of the hull clade???? In all seriousness, I actually think this remastered set is the strongest one they've announced, since Ravnica is very internally cohesive. since all the colors are paired off in the thing they do, and you have plenty of fixing with the gates, I wouldn't be surprised if this is one of the best limited environments in years. I also think the plan is to use this to bring a bunch of rtr era cards to arena smoothly. I do also think they'll put shock lands in the thing, dropping them back down to 4-6$ each.
Ravnica Remastered isn't coming to Arena is the problem.
 
Didn't Dominaria Remastered ultimately hard flop and is still available at under launch prices? I'm surprised they didn't abandon the format yet, but maybe this time around it will be the last nail in the coffin as I can't imagine Ravnica Remastered going over well. What reprint value can they even stuff into it at this point? Dark Confidant?
Time Spiral Remastered was a good idea, executed well. Take an old block that hasn't been available in awhile and turn it into a single draft set. Love it because there's a unified theme and art style to everything.

Dominaria Remastered was a bad idea, executed poorly. Dominaria covers too many sets, so there's no unifying theme or art style. Hell, they even produced a ton of new (mostly shitty) art for cards.

Ravnica is already Magic's most generic plane. The last Ravnica set came out four years ago. What even is the fucking point of this set? I'd sooner have an Ice Age or an Alara Remastered than more Ravnica.
 
What even is the fucking point of this set?
It's the first time you'll have all ten guilds (and all of the mana fixing) in all three packs?

I dunno.

A lot of the older sets are hard to remaster because modern Limited design sensibilities are so different, or because they've basically done an updated version already (like Dominaria United being kind of like Invasion block remastered). How would you go about remastering Masques block? Or OG Kamigawa? Even if you could make functional Limited environments out of those sets, there's no guarantee it would be fun to play.
 
WotC basically changed there banning policy to pretty much only ban cards once a year (although they leave themselves an unlimited amount of wiggle room on this) to instill confidence in their children's card game to pack crackers. So it's summer banning season? I wonder what they ban for this year!


Modern:
Preordain is unbanned.

Legacy:
Mind's Desire is unbanned.

Oh OK see you next year WotC.

Funny part is that most of the ban announcement is trying to make excuses for Orcish Bowmaster and The One Ring seeing very, very high play rates in every format and very little is trying to justify the unbans (preordain seems fine, mind's desire seems dangerous since Storm decks already played a worse storm card that let them touch cards next turn instead of casting them for free now)

Personally I would have banned either Karn or Nykthos and some rakdos midrange card like Shelly in pioneer. Probably would have banned Wedding Announcement and Shelly in standard too.
 
WotC basically changed there banning policy to pretty much only ban cards once a year (although they leave themselves an unlimited amount of wiggle room on this) to instill confidence in their children's card game to pack crackers. So it's summer banning season? I wonder what they ban for this year!




Oh OK see you next year WotC.

Funny part is that most of the ban announcement is trying to make excuses for Orcish Bowmaster and The One Ring seeing very, very high play rates in every format and very little is trying to justify the unbans (preordain seems fine, mind's desire seems dangerous since Storm decks already played a worse storm card that let them touch cards next turn instead of casting them for free now)

Personally I would have banned either Karn or Nykthos and some rakdos midrange card like Shelly in pioneer. Probably would have banned Wedding Announcement and Shelly in standard too.
Can't Ban Shit when the packs are still in print, gotta grift those consoomers.
 
Commander Masters seems to be all the talk with countless stores talking about how it's financially crippled them worse than that one tiger did to Joe Exotic.

It's the first time you'll have all ten guilds (and all of the mana fixing) in all three packs?
Dragon's Maze but three packs in a row, let's goooo!

A lot of the older sets are hard to remaster because modern Limited design sensibilities are so different, or because they've basically done an updated version already (like Dominaria United being kind of like Invasion block remastered). How would you go about remastering Masques block? Or OG Kamigawa? Even if you could make functional Limited environments out of those sets, there's no guarantee it would be fun to play.
I'd play the shit out of a remastered Invasion or even Masques block. Masques isn't as bad as people make it out and there's some interesting design space out there, not to mention the art in Masques was great. Now I want to make a Masques cube or something.

Oh OK see you next year WotC.
Nothing can possibly go wrong unbanning Mind's Desires in Legacy, can't wait for the combo lunacy that enables with Mind's into Mind's and Mind's duplicator chains.

Can't Ban Shit when the packs are still in print, gotta grift those consoomers.
Wasn't half of Standard banned before Ikoria rotated?
 
WotC basically changed there banning policy to pretty much only ban cards once a year (although they leave themselves an unlimited amount of wiggle room on this) to instill confidence in their children's card game to pack crackers. So it's summer banning season? I wonder what they ban for this year!




Oh OK see you next year WotC.

Funny part is that most of the ban announcement is trying to make excuses for Orcish Bowmaster and The One Ring seeing very, very high play rates in every format and very little is trying to justify the unbans (preordain seems fine, mind's desire seems dangerous since Storm decks already played a worse storm card that let them touch cards next turn instead of casting them for free now)

Personally I would have banned either Karn or Nykthos and some rakdos midrange card like Shelly in pioneer. Probably would have banned Wedding Announcement and Shelly in standard too.
Unban Mana Geyser in Oathbreaker, cowards.
 
I'd play the shit out of a remastered Invasion or even Masques block. Masques isn't as bad as people make it out and there's some interesting design space out there, not to mention the art in Masques was great. Now I want to make a Masques cube or something
I have an Invasion Remastered cube and it's fun but definitely has glaring issues from a modern set design perspective.

And there's no way the Ravnica remaster can be as bad as Dragon's Maze. DM wasn't just overly crowded, the power level was also total shit. At least this remaster can pull from the best the three blocks had to offer.
 
I have an Invasion Remastered cube and it's fun but definitely has glaring issues from a modern set design perspective.

And there's no way the Ravnica remaster can be as bad as Dragon's Maze. DM wasn't just overly crowded, the power level was also total shit. At least this remaster can pull from the best the three blocks had to offer.
Invasion and Masques had glaring issues by any design standard, but that's the fun of making a cube you can actually adjust with cards from Urza's and more. The other issue with cube is the one of thing that hurts the format, but you can make multi section cubes that introduce extra copies of cards which makes it a lot more fun, but that takes work so Magic players are terrified of the idea.

I'd hope Ravnica could manage to make a good format with what 9 sets to draw from across all of their blocks? The problem is they'll probably go for zany fun legendries that turn the format into Dragon Maze instead of making a good draft format. The price will also be retarded.
 

Hidetsugu 2024.​

When god lets you down you know what you do? You eat god! Hence this ogre is running on a platform of literally eating the rich, violence to all who oppose him and oaths of loyalty that any who break will result in a dire and likely bloody end for them.

Essentially one good idea Democrats refuse to follow through on and two that are their unspoken official ones. Not the worst option on the table
 
Is it the end of the world to track all this small binary shit?
So I had a guy pick up a commander deck who had played the game maybe a good ten years ago or so, understood the mechanics, didn't really know a lot of more modern stuff. He was I think a Modern guy, so Conspiracy wasn't up his alley.

Took us five seconds to get him up to speed on Monarch. Sure, we missed some triggers here and there, but it's all good.
He had bought the RG Baldur's Gate precon. He played Tome of Sarevok. It took us around seven minutes to fully explain Initiative and Dungeons, and we had to scramble around to find enough tokens to represent it the first time someone else got hit. That's more what I mean.
Commander Masters seems to be all the talk with countless stores talking about how it's financially crippled them worse than that one tiger did to Joe Exotic.
The reason it dumped a lot of stores hard is that they placed positions way ahead of anything in the set being spoiled, and the stores couldn't predict the community would shit their diaps about it this hard.

It has a lot of dud rares - true (...monetarily. Sidisi is an awesome card, just worth nothing.. But it also has a lot of bomb commons and uncommons, with a price point that isn't that much above sets like M25. M25 was a shit set at a stupidly inflated price-point that, along with Iconic Masters, helped to sink the 'Masters' brand. This is a good set being sold at an inflated price... much like Baldur's Gate. But you wouldn't really know that unless you drafted it, same as Baldur's Gate. You know, the set that, even less than a year after its release, had an EV higher than its original, high price-point because people stopped shitting on it and realized that it actually had lots of good stuff (alongside truly stellar common/uncommon designs and an overall perfect power-level for the format).

The way all the youtube channels tell it, Commander Masters is the worst set ever / total shit / blah blah blah because it isn't Commander Legends 2. Commander Legends printed so many problem cards into the format that turned it into even more of a wallet-warrior arms-race, and because those people didn't get another set full of designs like Jeweled Lotus or Hullbreacher, they're throwing a hissy-fit.

As a result of all the negativity, even people who don't mind the price point and would otherwise be into the product are staying away, which is forcing stores to crack packs or race to the bottom. Small stores that use preorders to gauge their allocation are gonna do alright; the medium-size ones that buy a bunch at bulk pricing are stuck with some heavy bags.
 
Last edited:
The way all the youtube channels tell it, Commander Masters is the worst set ever / total shit / blah blah blah because it isn't Commander Legends 2. Commander Legends printed so many problem cards into the format that turned it into even more of a wallet-warrior arms-race, and because those people didn't get another set full of designs like Jeweled Lotus or Hullbreacher, they're throwing a hissy-fit.
I get where you're coming from, but at $300 a box for draft or set, that's retarded unless the set is absurd in power and even then it shouldn't be that high. Baldur's Gate was what $150-200 a box so at least not that inflated compared to a normal box, and it sunk into the $70's for liquidation. I can't imagine stores having a way to easily move three hundred dollar boxes, because even if the format is ok there's no way I'd pay that much for a draft.
 
I get where you're coming from, but at $300 a box for draft or set
Commander Masters draft boosters are currently sitting around $250. Set is closer to around $300. The MSRP of a box of Ultimate Masters was $335. (Oh, those days before set boosters...) UM also had a lot of dud rares with zero application (whereas at least, in theory, the dud rares in CM are good commanders). I forget the Double Masters prices, but those are also up there with plenty of bulk.

It's hard to find exacts, but between MM2-3, Eternal Masters Iconic Masters, and Masters 25 the MSRPs were around $240, with the original Modern Masters (what a good set that was) MSRPing at around $168, which is what Commander Legends / Modern Horizons tended to be around. Eternal Masters also has some of the... most absurd dud rares you'll ever see, and iconic masters has channel at mythic.

There have been a lot of bad products in this price range. I'd never buy them, but I benefit from whales buying them and shifting the bulk for cheap - Generous Gift at common is fucking excellent. The community freaking out, despite this being not that much different than a normal Masters release from their end, is hilarious. Now, yes, for stores, the $250 is selling at a loss and the pricing on this product via distribution is retarded. But that's not what most people complaining about it are saying, lol
 
Back
Top Bottom