https://youtube.com/watch?v=78BFFq_8XvM:1360
This might be the most memorable moment in the debate. Where Peterson wants to warn against bloody revolution and when he does, a couple of people start to cheer for bloody revolution.
Running circles around him is right.
I can only imagine what Peterson fans felt when they watched their hero struggle and finally just request Zizek to define Marxism when it was obvious Peterson had no idea what what going on.
When you have weeks to prepare and you end up just asking your 'opponent' to educate you... wellllp... it's not exactly an intellectual tour de force...
Blow-by-blow:
1:21 Welcome Slavoj Žižek and Jordan Peterson
3:46 Žižek's credentials
5:00 Peterson's credentials
7:36 Peterson's Opening Statement (about 30 minutes long)
- Tickets were higher priced than Leaf's game
- The Communist Manifesto
13:43 Hierarchical Structure is part of Biology and History.
16:36 A struggle for life in a cruel and complex world
19:30 The Demolition of The Kulaks
20:30 Binary Good/Evil, Proletariat/Bourgeois Identity Politics
24:37 1830's
26:21 What's wrong with profit?
27:14 How can you grow without prosperity?
28:35 Corruption, Proletarians rise up, overthrow. So, what now bucko?
31:08 Shallow Conception of A Person
31:57 Marx/Engels admit Capitalism is successful at quick production
34:42 You can't have an economic system without some inequality.
- Capitalism creates wealth and inequality, All others just produce inequality
Žižek's Opening Statement
38:55 Slavoj Žižek is tired of Left attacks on them
39:45 Happiness, Communism, Capitalism. Praise China. China combines (1) Strong State (2) Capitalist Merits (?)
41:10 Happiness from Psychoanalysis. Humans can and do sabotage their own happiness. Unreadiness to confront our true desire
43:00 Donald Trump Ego Trip. Profanity. "Trump is the ultimate Postmodern President"
44:12 Religion can make good people do bad things
46:23 Self Hatred/Degeneration is solved through multiculturalism/ "White multiculturalism Liberals embody the lie of Identity Politics." (?)
47:06 Pathological need for Jealousy to sustain Identity (The jealous husband. The Anti-Semitic Nazi. The Anti-Immigrant populists) The facts are true, the populist story is a lie
50:42 Daniel Bell Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism
53:15 "Evil is profoundly spiritual..."
55:00 Diminished arguments
55:45 Education and Equality.
57:00 Nature and Evolution. Like French Cuisine
59:19 T.S. Eliot. Art's effect on the past. "The past should be altered by the present as much as the present is directed by the past"
1:01:38 Soren Kierkegaard. God, Christ
1:03:40 The Commons, The Forests. World Interconnectedness
1:06:51 Marx Thesis 11 and Changing Human Nature (Man and Machine. Digitization of the brain.)
1:07:55 Foreign political messiness. (1) Enclosure (2) Globalization
1:10:34 Capitalist Market does great things, needs regulation/limitation
1:11:32 Pessimistic View
1:12:21 Confronting Serious Problems: China
Peterson's Response
1:13:43
1:15:54 Reduction to Economic Competition is not the best way forward
People value Absence of Misery > Happiness (In Peterson's experience with Psychology)
1:18:45 Catastrophes of the struggle of human experience (
1:19:47 Yang Gang?)
1:21:36 No good alternative for Capitalism
1:25:00 You have to clean your own room, bucko.
Žižek Response
1:25:40
1:26:45 Czechoslovakia. Happiness. Nostalgia/Fondness for the past
1:29:50 China scares Žižek
1:30:40 Fears dictator capitalism
1:31:30 Marx
1:32:24 Communism. Agrees with Peterson on many points. It's complex.
1:33:40 Oceans, International Action, Diminishing poverty, End of Apartheid, Race Card
1:34:58 Global Trade Corporation. Yemen
1:36:28 Disavow. Pessimism, no easy way out
Ending Questions/Audience Questions
1:39:15 "You're a strange Marxist to have a discussion with" you have an appeal to rebels
1:40:45 Why not promote Žižekism instead of old Marxism?
1:45:00 "We need Radical Openness"
1:46:58 Where are the Post-Modern Neo Marxists? Where is the Marxist factor in Post Modernism?
1:51:27,
1:52:35 1960's France Post-Modernism. Skepticism of Metanarratives.
1:54:13/
1:55:07 (Michel Foucault)
What is True Human Happiness. How do we obtain it? (
1:57:08)
1:58:23 J.P "You can't will yourself to be happy" The event happens, and in your reflection find happiness. Envision the ultimate good and live by those principles. "It's not happiness. It's meaning"
2:01:00 "Stand on the edge of what you know..."
2:02:23 S.Ž Falling in Love. Authentic Love.
2:05:30 Happiness is The Fall, The Struggle. (Movement. Not Stasis)
2:09:26 Confront your fears, Battle The Dragon. Save Your Father Pinocchio.
2:14:34 Carl Jung
2:17:34 The Fall in Christianity. Ideology. German Toilets
2:24:00 Man is so complex
2:27:00 Individual Responsibility. Be a good player in this game.
2:28:45 German Officers doing horrible things. Heinrich Himmler. Nazi Psyche
2:31:37 Zen Buddhist justification of Japanese Militarism in the 1930's
2:33:30 A Thought To Leave You With
J.P. The Power of Conversation and The Great Achievement of Free Speech
S.Ž Don't be Politically Correct. Trump is not a Fascist