Yeah - my point was more that HOAs are more an example of American petty authoritarianism, not that they're all that common in most places. It's only something that you would really pick up on if you've lived in both countries for a while. In America, if you go to a swimming pool, or a parking lot, or even a restaurant, there are just so many more angry rules and regulations than the equivalent in the UK. Here, people will literally cut off wheel clamps/boots with angle grinders if they're issued by private companies, but if it's the Council they'll just pay the fine and apologise for being an inconvenience.
Agreed that leasehold is a fucking scam. Note to Britbongs who may be looking at getting on the housing ladder - it's literally better to rent in the UK than lease, and that's not an exaggeration in any way. Renters have all sorts of legal protections, leasehold can leave you in a massive financial black hole (the freeholder can not only charge you basically unlimited numbers for repairs, but also make you pay for expansion and building works that don't benefit you) and there's nothing you can do except pucker up your asshole and ask for more. At least when you rent you know how much it's going to cost. Leasehold is basically signing blank cheques. The biggest freeholder of leasehold properties in the UK by far is, of course, the state. How British.
In Germany, of course, you get both - both the state and private companies/individuals will give you long lists of rules to obey and the Germans will obey them enthusiastically. They love taking orders, do the Germans. Whereas the French don't give a fuck about either and if you try they will riot and smash your shit up. That's what I like about the French (and the Italians), the rest of the world could really learn from their attitudes to authority.
Sorry if this has gone a bit off-topic. I just thought it was an interesting cultural difference compared to how the Tranch situation would have unfolded elsewhere.