Science Hypochondriasis Linked to Earlier Death - isn't it ironic

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

Hypochondriasis Linked to Earlier Death​

TERRI D’ARRIGO
Published Online: 27 Feb 2024

People who have hypochondriasis (health anxiety disorder) may have an increased risk of dying by either natural or unnatural causes, including death by suicide, compared with people who do not have the disorder, a study in JAMA Psychiatry has found. According to the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, Tenth Revision (ICD-10), people who have hypochondriasis are preoccupied with thoughts that they have one or more serious and progressive physical disorders and repeatedly check for symptoms and seek reassurance from health professionals.

“This is a wakeup call. We need to work toward developing better models of shared care for these patients, focusing on tighter collaboration between primary care, medical specialists, and mental health professionals,” lead author David Mataix-Cols, Ph.D., told Psychiatric News. He is a professor of child and adolescent psychiatric science at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm.

The researchers examined data from 4,129 people in the Swedish National Patient Register who received a diagnosis of hypochondriasis between January 1, 1997, and December 31, 2020. (The median age of diagnosis was approximately 34 years.) The researchers matched those individuals with 41,290 demographically similar people without hypochondriasis. All individuals were followed from the date of diagnosis until the date of death; emigration from Sweden; or the end of the study on December 31, 2020, whichever occurred first.

A total of 268 individuals with hypochondriasis and 1,761 individuals without hypochondriasis died during the follow-up. Those with hypochondriasis died at a mean age of 70 years, compared with a mean age of 75.1 years for those without the disorder.

After strict adjustment of sociodemographic confounders (for example, highest level of education and family income), those with hypochondriasis had a 69% increased risk of dying of any cause, a 60% increased risk of dying of natural causes (for example, diseases of the circulatory, nervous, or respiratory systems), and a 143% increased risk of dying of unnatural causes compared with people without hypochondriasis.

Those with hypochondriasis also had a 314% increased risk of dying by suicide, which was the most common cause of unnatural death. However, after the researchers adjusted for a history of depressive or anxiety disorders, suicide risk was no longer statistically significant. According to the researchers, comorbid depression and anxiety are the norm in individuals with hypochondriasis.

Mataix-Cols noted that the absolute risks of death were small. For example 0.7% of the people with hypochondriasis died by suicide, compared with 0.1% in the general population during the same period.

“Of course, we should still consider the risks unacceptably high, particularly because effective treatments do exist and at least some deaths could have been prevented,” he said.

Mataix-Cols said that hypochondriasis was underdiagnosed.

“We ‘only’ found a little over 4,000 cases in the whole of Sweden during a period of more than 20 years. This is far fewer than we would expect given the known prevalence of the disorder being somewhere around 3-5% [and] the population of Sweden is around 10 million people,” he explained.

“We need to get better at diagnosing the disorder in a variety of medical settings and persuading sufferers to see mental health professionals,” Mataix-Cols added. “Good treatments exist, particularly cognitive-behavioral therapy. SSRIs are also an option, though many patients prefer talking therapies due to the fact that the medication side effects, such as bodily sensations, can trigger health anxiety.”

This study was supported by the Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare; Region Stockholm; the Swedish Society of Medicine; and the Karolinska Institutet.
 
This is anecdotal but from what I've seen there's a decent number of hypochondriacs who are only hypochondriacs when they have a depressive episode. They get a permanent label of hypochondriac but in between depressive episodes they see the doctor for the same reasons and the same frequency as normal people. As soon as they are depressed again they see their doctor all the time for minor aches worried that its cancer. So it's not surprising they are at an increased risk of suicide.

There's still people who are hypochondriacs all the time but most of the ones I've known are only hypochondriacs when their mental health has taken a nose dive
 
I have to admit - since I've been in medicine, I've started fearing morbidity and mortality increasingly with every passing year to the extent that a day doesn't pass where I don't get anxious and depressed about getting old and sick and inevitably dying. Hypochondriasis in health care workers really is a thing. It would be more comforting to be ignorant and not constantly aware of all the thousands of things that could be wrong with you.
 
I wonder how much of the increase in mortality with hypochondriasis is due to iatrogenetic adverse effects (harm specifically caused by medical care itself).

Hypochondriacs are going to access medical care more often. They will also present with vague and atypical presentations that will inevitably lead to "throw spaghetti at the wall" approaches to diagnostic tests and treatments. Which have no for benefit but permutations and aggregate risks for harm.

The other "hidden curriculum" part of medicine (at least in the West) is that clinicians aren't culturally permitted to ever acknowledge or formally document that the symptoms are "in the patient's head".

The amount of health dollars, time and resources spent on not directly addressing psychosomatic symptoms with curtness and honesty is immeasurable.

The first time I ever documented in a patient's chart that I believed that a physical complaint was psychosomatic in origin (a young woman kept coming to the clinic wanted something done about the lump on her shin that I couldn't palpate or perceive), my "Nice Guy" preceptor burst into the exam room after reading it when I was with a second separate patient, chewing me out and warning me "NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THAT AGAIN".

There's also a pattern where specialist consultants will never formally document psychosomatic symptoms as a conclusion in their reports.

They will write consultation reports back with boilerplate phrasing such as "Mrs. Smith is a pleasant 63 y/o woman presenting with "X"" and then concluding their reports with non-committal wordsmithing such as "from my perspective, the organ system of my concern gets a clean bill of health. I'm discharging her back to your care. Good luck."
 
They became so obsessed with not losing their health that the only thing they had to fear was not losing their health. Which they eventually did. Ironic. They could lock down the entire world from COVID, but not themselves.
 
Too much cortisol can cause the same shit that obesity does over time, like diabetes and heart problems, just to a lesser extent. It makes sense.
 
The first time I ever documented in a patient's chart that I believed that a physical complaint was psychosomatic in origin (a young woman kept coming to the clinic wanted something done about the lump on her shin that I couldn't palpate or perceive), my "Nice Guy" preceptor burst into the exam room after reading it when I was with a second separate patient, chewing me out and warning me "NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THAT AGAIN".
Writing your speculation down in the patient record can have legal consequences. You can discuss with your colleagues, but all you should have written down is "palpation at the patient's specified location was negative for lump."
 
Writing your speculation down in the patient record can have legal consequences. You can discuss with your colleagues, but all you should have written down is "palpation at the patient's specified location was negative for lump."

Clinicians have to speculate constantly in the patient record.

Every patient admitted to hospital requires a diagnosis at the time of admission at the top of their chart even when there's still tons of uncertainty what's actually going on. I don't know how many "Reason For Admission: Pneumonia" I've come across with clear X-rays and no evidence or mention of a respiratory infection anywhere else to that point.

Physicians are forced to speculate officially on the record for billing purposes constantly.

Why is Hypochondriasis/Somatoform Disorder/Medically Unexplained Symptoms so verboten to document and the Voldemort of the industry?
 
I wonder how much of the increase in mortality with hypochondriasis is due to iatrogenetic adverse effects (harm specifically caused by medical care itself).
This was my first thought as well. I wonder if they even looked for that? You go in scared about a lump somewhere and have a million tests done and one of them picks up something tiny and they operate and treat just in case, which causes damage..
Hear the one about the hypochondriac's tombstone?

It said "Told You I Was Sick"
Didn’t spike Milligan have similar written on his grave?
Hypochondria is an interesting one. I think for some people it’s a manifestation of acute or chronic stress.
Stress can make you sick - from things like altered cortisol, poor sleep and all sorts of stuff. The times in my life I’ve been uder intense stress and unhappiness I have definitely gotten sick more, it’s very noticeable and I think it’s a vicious circle.
Imagine you’re under intense stress. You aren’t sleeping so you put weight on. Obesity also depresses rhe immune system. Now you’ve got a nasty cold. So you’re sleeping worse. And putting weight on. Maybe now you’re not as keen on excercise, which would help with the stress, so you aren’t exercising as much. Worse sleep. More immune depression, more weight gain. Metabolic syndrome follows and maybe diabetes, which also depresses your immune system. It’s very very easy to get into that pit in today’s pressured world. I wonder if a proportion of these people were previously well and are just experiencing constant but unusual to them milder illnesses.
The rest are expressing stress, but are seeking help for physical ailments because physical sickness is more acceptable than mental.
 
As someone who’s been in the weeds with hypochondria my entire adult life, the thing that concerns me now is that 10 years ago, people could accept a doctor telling them “we’ve done all tests, you are healthy, this is a mental health issue”. Now there are millions of tiktoks telling people that no, ackshually your doctor is gaslighting you and you have x hard-to-diagnose chronic illness. This has started to show up in mainstream media now. And people latch onto that until they find a doctor who will diagnose them with something physical rather than getting help for their anxiety. Plenty of examples of this in the munchie thread.
 
Back
Top Bottom