🐱 How Star Trek Succeeds At Diversity When Other Sci-Fi Fails

  • 🔎 If you see an alert for analytics.usips.org, this is a self-hosted system I am running as a test. It is GDPR compliant and collects no invasive information.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
CatParty

The Star Trek franchise has a long history of diversity, and this history has helped newer Trekshows succeed in their representation while other modern sci-fi franchises have largely failed. Star Trek: The Original Series first aired in 1966, and spawned a franchise that has grown to encompass nine shows, thirteen movies, and plenty of other media like books and video games. Most of Star Trek's core shows aired between the late 1980s to early 2000s, but as of 2017 a host of newer shows including Star Trek: Discovery and Star Trek: Picard has brought a resurgence to the franchise.

From the very beginning, Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry sought to use TOS as a way to showcase a variety of social and political topics that were in the consciousness of the 1960s American public. These included discussions of race, gender, sexual orientation, and other things pertaining to the rights of minority groups that were only just becoming part of the mainstream awareness. As a result, TOS's main cast included a Black woman and Asian man shown in positions of power and respect, and many episodes of the show feature allegories to important social movements of the day, such as the Civil Rights Movement.

TOS established a tradition of representation that has continued throughout the rest of the Star Trekfranchise, with subsequent shows steadily incorporated more and more diverse characters and topics over the years. Because of this, Star Trek has paved the way for its newer shows to be on the cutting edge of diversity. The best example of this is Star Trek: Discovery, which premiered in 2017. Discovery's main cast features many actors of color, including a Black woman as the series lead, and the series was the first Star Trek show to feature explicitly LGBTQ+ characters. Two male characters in the main cast, Paul Stamets and Hugh Culber, have been in a romantic relationship since season 1, and season 3 of Discoveryintroduced Gray, a trans character, and Adira, who identifies as nonbinary.

The amount of positive representation Discovery and Star Trek's other new shows have included has put the franchise far out in front of any other modern sci-fi in terms of diversity. When compared to movie franchises like Star Wars or the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Star Trek shows them both up time and again. The recent Star Wars films were criticized by some audiences for their refusal to depict the characters of Finn and Poe Dameron in a romantic relationship, and the MCU has yet to feature an openly LGBTQ+ main character. By contrast, Star Trek: Discoveryseason 3 had an episode that beautifully handled Adira coming out as nonbinary, and also included some well-written and believable relationship moments between Stamets and Culber, including the two of them discussing Adira's gender identity and later sharing a kiss.

While Star Trek is certainly not a perfect franchise in terms of diversity, nearly every show in the franchise has done something to further the cause for inclusion over the years. Star Trek: Discovery'slevel of representation would likely not have been possible had this not been the case, and the way Discovery utilizes its characters of color, female characters, and LGBTQ+ characters highlights just how far other sci-fi franchises have to go before they will be able to catch up. Ultimately, Star Trekremains the franchise that most often succeeds in its diversity, while other franchises continue to struggle with getting it right.
 
The best example of this is Star Trek: Discovery, which premiered in 2017. Discovery's main cast features many actors of color, including a Black woman as the series lead, and the series was the first Star Trek show to feature explicitly LGBTQ+ characters.
Oh, you mean by including Black Female Jesus, who is the REAL reason everything is the way it is?

Get fucked.
 
Nobody watches Discovery. There may be a reason for that.

Old Star Trek actually did do diversity right, by not forcing overrepresentation. Each crew on each show actually reflected America: mostly white with a smattering of non-whites. And nobody minded. Nobody was mad that Geordie or Tuvok or Sisko were black, because they appropriately made up about 10% of the main cast. Representation, not overrepresentation.
 
Oh, you mean by including Black Female Jesus, who is the REAL reason everything is the way it is?

Get fucked.
she really does every-fucking-thing in that series, doesn't she?
I thought they'd at least let Tilly have the "shy, officer lacks confidence in own abilities, gets trusted with respnsibility->fucks up imediately->redeems self" but no muh black god emperor had to swoop in and do it by herself. The only other crewmembers that get anything to do ever are the fag boys, and later the elderly lesbo and the zoomer girl.
 
Nobody watches Discovery. There may be a reason for that.

Old Star Trek actually did do diversity right, by not forcing overrepresentation. Each crew on each show actually reflected America: mostly white with a smattering of non-whites. And nobody minded. Nobody was mad that Geordie or Tuvok or Sisko were black, because they appropriately made up about 10% of the main cast. Representation, not overrepresentation.
No, they did get a bit of hatemail from the usual suspects for a few of the more controversial episodes. The Kirk/Uhura kiss, the TNG troon planet episode, the lesbo trill kiss in DS9. Probably more I'm forgetting.

Also, I believe a couple of bible belt stations either censored or skipped playing one or both of the mentioned kiss scenes, but I may be misremembering and I don't really care to look it up. If you care, I'm sure Memory Alpha has the deets.
 
The amount of positive representation Discovery and Star Trek's other new shows have included has put the franchise far out in front of any other modern sci-fi in terms of diversity. When compared to movie franchises like Star Wars or the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Star Trek shows them both up time and again. The recent Star Wars films were criticized by some audiences for their refusal to depict the characters of Finn and Poe Dameron in a romantic relationship, and the MCU has yet to feature an openly LGBTQ+ main character.
This is retarded. TV and movies are a completely different ball game. As long as China has a no open faggotry rule in movies the most you'll see are easily removable scenes between minor characters, (I think one of the Deadpool movies did this?) so they can be cut out in China, Singapore and maybe the Middle East. And that includes any and all Star Trek movies.

Mystifies me that everybody with even a passing acquaintance to how movie box office works knows this, but it gets zero media coverage.

Given how much the Chinese market hates Star Wars at this point, open faggotry might be on the table there if LucasFilm decides to throw in the towel on ever getting a toehold in the Chinese market. Not sure how well Star Trek does there, but I can't see how the same rule does not apply.
 
No, they did get a bit of hatemail from the usual suspects for a few of the more controversial episodes. The Kirk/Uhura kiss, the TNG troon planet episode, the lesbo trill kiss in DS9. Probably more I'm forgetting.

Also, I believe a couple of bible belt stations either censored or skipped playing one or both of the mentioned kiss scenes, but I may be misremembering and I don't really care to look it up. If you care, I'm sure Memory Alpha has the deets.
I consider a couple hundred people in a nation of 300 million to be nobody.
 
It used to succeed by having diverse characters play roles. It now fails because it makes the show about the traits that make one dimensional characters different than everyone else.
 
I consider a couple hundred people in a nation of 300 million to be nobody.
I hear ya, and tend to agree. And in the few markets that didn't air it, its just petty tyrants at a local station making up the minds of and entire region. Just felt like having an "ackshually...." moment, as we all tend to, from time to time.
 
Nobody besides tumblerinas watch that show and every time I see one talking about it, they talk about the Black Woman™. I sure remember when I used to watch TNG and we all talked about the White Man™.

I mean, sure, if you ask Tumblerettes about this shit show, they'll tell you it features a black woman and that's sjw code for "best show ever!", plot and storytelling aside. Maybe try asking people who aren't permanently online and they'll tell you how this show either sucks or they have never heard of it.
 
Back
Top Bottom