Culture Flying Colors Foundation scandal - Why you shouldn't trust anime youtubers

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
So there's something happening now called the Flying Colors Foundation scandal .
http://goboiano.com/the-short-life-of-flying-colors-foundation/

Their (archived) website: http://web.archive.org/web/20180318183234/https://flyingcolorsfoundation.org/#contactus


TL;DR/DW:
>Flying Colors Foundation is a supposedly non-profit foundation that claims it's going to help "Western anime fans to be heard"
>The future founder of FCF meets up with Gigguk in the summer of 2017
>One month later The Anime Man releases his "Top 100 anime survey", the group behind the foundation (still not officially launched) contacts him because they see a business opportunity
>They collaborate with him and help him analyze and publish the data
>It did well *dollar signs in their eyes*
>The company officially registers sometime in November
>One day they put out a survey called the The 2018 Anime Census
>Big anime youtubers shill for it (all for free, they claim, later on it turns out they were all paid):
Flying-Colors-Foundation-Youtubers-Influencers-768x240.png

>One week later a woman called Alicia Haddick/socialanigirl posts an article on Medium (sadly it appears to have been removed), pointing out that one of the staff members of the foundation used to work for Loot Crate and Disney as Consumer Insight and Data Analyst
>Some people start suspecting it's a scam and that it was made for the sole purpose of data harvesting and selling analytics to companies
>Connections between Gigguk and one of the founders are also found
>Concerns are also raised about the lack of team transparency, intrusive census questions about mental health and income, and questionable donated profits
>FCF also promise to donate their profits to other non-profits but also claim that they will donate to a for-profit company, it's illegal for a non-profit to give revenue they earned through donations or other non-taxable income to a for-profit company so this is clearly suspicious
>FCF damage control and deny it's a scam, same goes for people like Gigguk and The Anime Man
>Alicia Haddick/socialanigirl releases another article exposing more of their lies (http://web.archive.org/web/20180328...s-foundation-further-revelations-dc43b9e8a8b9 , such as:
– Having more employed individuals than publicly known (including a potentially illegal unpaid intern)
– The staff claiming to have no more connections with Otaku Pin Club while some still have admin privileges on the OPC Discord server
– They considered the possibility of charging Japanese clients for a more in-depth analysis of the gathered data. They also did not represent themselves as a non-profit with these clients
– The survey management tool they used collected IP addresses despite FCF themselves stating that no personal data will be gathered
– Despite claiming to have not paid influencers, they paid Digibro $100 for their first consultation
>BURN BABY BURN https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/87kja1/flying_colors_foundation_lied_about_the_people/
>Gigyuk starts distancing himself from the company, The Scammer Man goes even further by sweeping it all under the rug, he deletes the video and the tweets where he promoted the survey etc (they were the anime youtubers who were the most involved in the project)
>FCF admit defeat and close down on March 31 https://flyingcolorsfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Farewell-Letter-FCF.pdf

Big tl;dr: Private Info of weeboos got leaked to one, two, or maybe thousands of scam companies.
 
Last edited:
For those who took the survey, I highly doubt anything will come of this. Having browsed through the reddit thread, it sounds like the only sensitive information that was given over was the email address. Everything else would really just appeal to marketers for consumer research data. So yeah, the only people who lost anything in this scam were those that used their primary or work email address. Furthermore, unless I'm mistaken, i.p. collecting isn't really a concern for the most part and you'd have to put real effort into trying to get anything useful out of that info. Maybe they could backtrace the ip to residential addresses and send spam mail but I'm not sure if there's much they could do beyond that.
 
as long as my dear eye-patch wolf wasn't a part of it it's cool.
I do worry he'll turn scummy soon though.
 
Flying Colors Foundation is a supposedly non-profit foundation that claims it's going to help "Western anime fans to be heard"
Good that it was a scam. Nobody wants to hear weeaboos who torrent anime bitch about Aniplex Blu-ray prices, or source material purists who don't understand anime production constraints.
 
If youre a youtuber commits a crime and then ask people to remove the video of anything related to that, is that destroying evidence? Im genuinely curious. If a youtuber admits something or hints at something criminal in a video then deletes it or tries to get it removed from the internet, and stop others from uploading it, including using DMCA to try and silence them, especially after a scandal--is that considered trying to destroy evidence? Could be a pretty big deal in internet cases, couldnt it?
Im not a lawyer at all, a little buzzed, and I dont know anything about law outside of maybe being drunk during Law and Order, but is tampering with evidence a crime? It is, isnt it?
 
Digibro is the only one who puts out halfway decent content and he's a cow to the extreme. Not surprising that I didn't know about this whole mess.

Are you shitting me? How could no one figure out this was a scam just from this stupid mission statement? What does that even mean?

It sounds like an awful mission. The industry catering to the west will inevitably mean the industry giving up its soul to appease moral busybodies in other countries.
 
As if it wasn't clear enough that animu YouTubers are a bunch of spergs. Also, so much for Gigguk quitting his job so he can be a full time YouTuber. Apart from EvAbridged, his content gets boring fast.

BobSamurai is pretty cool doe. He's basically the animu Reviewbrah.
 
I knew Mother's Basement was a corporate shill. "Don't pirate anime" so we can have our corporate sponsors sell it to you instead!
 
Hmmm, Glass Reflection is part of it? Interesting, but not completely unexpected. One should never trust anyone who dresses up like a low-rent Char Aznable.
 
For those who took the survey, I highly doubt anything will come of this. Having browsed through the reddit thread, it sounds like the only sensitive information that was given over was the email address. Everything else would really just appeal to marketers for consumer research data. So yeah, the only people who lost anything in this scam were those that used their primary or work email address. Furthermore, unless I'm mistaken, i.p. collecting isn't really a concern for the most part and you'd have to put real effort into trying to get anything useful out of that info. Maybe they could backtrace the ip to residential addresses and send spam mail but I'm not sure if there's much they could do beyond that.

So the worst case scenario is a bunch of spam mails from Nigerian princes and penis enlargement pill shills?

The main problem is that people spend money on anime to begin with.

I used to buy it but it get too expensive. I'm much more likely to buy licensed merchandise. You'd think they'd actually make more money from anime doodads than DVDs and Blu Rays anyway.
 
I used to buy it but it get too expensive. I'm much more likely to buy licensed merchandise. You'd think they'd actually make more money from anime doodads than DVDs and Blu Rays anyway.
Japanese companies don't really care about Western consumers one way or another because it's far too niche of a market outside of Japan. If you're buying merchandise, it's coming from an importer or trading company, not the manufacturer. Even in Japan, the whole industry is pretty niche, and is kept afloat by a small number of autistic nerds with way too much money. (That same consumer type exists in the west too, but they go on /tg/ and not /a/) The money there is generated pretty evenly between discs and merchandise- the merchandise is expensive like in outside countries, but so are the discs. Whereas $50 would get you the whole season on Bluray in the US from a licensing company like Funimation (which is still overpriced), the same amount in Japan would get you a disk with 2 episodes on it. You being a basement-dwelling otaku with fat stacks of yen would buy the whole 24 episode disc set for $600, of course. Then you'd spend another few hundred for your plastic shit. Those are the consumers that matter in the industry, and it's why the Western market hardly matters at all.
 
Back
Top Bottom