Final Fantasy XIV - Kiwi Free Company

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Not to mention Calyx throwing a primal at us despite the wol being a famous primal slayer was dumb enough.
I can imagine the Ascians giggling as they give Calyx the knowledge to summon a Primal
"Yeah dude, this primal is sure to kill the PrimalFucker9000, go ahead"

Though I am more annoyed at Speeeen breaking the neo regulator citizens out of their tempering/trance, I know it is some anime/fantasy trope but how does that work? I thought the whole deal with tempering is that your aether becomes unbalanced and you become obsessed with the primal, did Dynamis come into play since the citizens love for their queen is that strong?

Changing subject: I have reached rank 7 with the Yok Huy and I have to say: The tone is definetively different from the other two DT beast tribes and also a step up, not perfect but good enough.
 
Changing subject: I have reached rank 7 with the Yok Huy and I have to say: The tone is definetively different from the other two DT beast tribes and also a step up, not perfect but good enough.
Yeah, I thought the Yok Huy tribal quest was fine as well. A little too saccharine in the motivation of the ice spirits, but it was cool that they thought about how different immortal beings would see mortal lives.

Also, I finished my first solo deep dungeon with PT. A lot of fun and a very unique experience in XIV, having to household well with your poms and incenses, really think about your pulls and such. Actually looking into doing HoH next but that one is much, much harder it seems.
 
Breaking News: Kate's out of the lead localizer chair.

1762399079597.png
 
Breaking News: Kate's out of the lead localizer chair.

View attachment 8132301
Damn I might deign to end my boycott of Squeenix games.

Just kidding every single one of their games I've bought in the last 5 years has been boring dogshit and they're trying to sell a Dragon Quest I remaster for $60. Fuck those troon enablers.
 
I’m perfectly fine dumpstering that plot point and leaving it dead and buried.
I never said the plot points are good, more so that they just get instantly brushed under a rug and vanish with zero conclusion or real explanation why, nor that they should come back. The ship sailed and it was all more of a point that they just can't write to satisfactory levels outside of a few core flash in the pan moments that only make sense in a vacuum.

And while the plotpoint itself is garbage, Fordola got done dirty and was also basically dumpstered until Endwalker and only then as a minor side mention out of game despite her being a perfect avenue for approaching a fresh character growth with a different perspective which is what they tried to force with Wuk.
 
Last edited:
Breaking News: Kate's out of the lead localizer chair.
One of two things happened here - either Kate wanted to quit because she hated the attention and notoriety, and they made a deal to have her be the fall guy so they could save face, orrr....

Much, much more likely in my eyes is that Kate really was behind Wuk's EN VA and the second studio the whole time. If we stop and think about the localizer issues, they really were not that big of a deal. Some flat dialogue, some erroneous translations, some typos and mistakes. Par for the course these days, particularly for Square Enix. And social media posts are not enough to get you fired from a position that important - you'd get a warning for it. Sure, that the community was baying for her is one thing... but this isn't their first rodeo.

By contrast though, if it was at her direction and insistence that the local studio was brought on to be "authentic," and that was all a smokescreen to get Sena a gig... that would explain why we would see someone in such a position get straight-up fired in Japan of all places. It's not like the nepo-hire of Sena fully explains the troubles with the game - the real rot is from the core design - but it's such an obvious figurehead. And given they already had Sena re-do several lines, plus the downright insulting things that made it to release (I'd bet my bottom dollar the UK studio complained about what their work was being put up alongside), it's just hard for me to think they didn't see that as a huge problem.
 
Last edited:
One of two things happened here - either Kate wanted to quit because she hated the attention and notoriety, and they made a deal to have her be the fall guy so they could save face, orrr....

Much, much more likely in my eyes is that Kate really was behind Wuk's EN VA and the second studio the whole time. If we stop and think about the localizer issues, they really were not that big of a deal. Some flat dialogue, some erroneous translations, some typos and mistakes. Par for the course these days, particularly for Square Enix. And social media posts are not enough to get you fired from a position that important - you'd get a warning for it. Sure, that the community was baying for her is one thing... but this isn't their first rodeo.

By contrast though, if it was at her direction and insistence that the local studio was brought on to be "authentic," and that was all a smokescreen to get Sena a gig... that would explain why we would see someone in such a position get straight-up fired in Japan of all places. It's not like the nepo-hire of Sena fully explains the troubles with the game - the real rot is from the core design - but it's such an obvious figurehead. And given they already had Sena re-do several lines, plus the downright insulting things that made it to release (I'd bet my bottom dollar the UK studio complained about what their work was being put up alongside), it's just hard for me to think they didn't see that as a huge problem.
Another thing worth considering is that Koji was lead from ARR all the way to Endwalker, then Kate taking the helm in Dawntrail and now leaving the role in 8.0. Having a 1 expac tenure in a "10 year story" seems like a very poor showing.
 
Another thing worth considering is that Koji was lead from ARR all the way to Endwalker, then Kate taking the helm in Dawntrail and now leaving the role in 8.0. Having a 1 expac tenure in a "10 year story" seems like a very poor showing.
I believe Kate got that at some point in Shadowbringers, after the game's release (which explains why I find SHB's postgame to be so stiff and generally middling). She's listed as the lead for EW, but wasn't even seemingly top-billing in ShB's MSQ.

I don't really think this move reflects her performance in the role: Japan notoriously just shoves around people who fuck up in their job, which is what's gonna happen with Hiroi. It's part of the country's productivity crisis.
 
Last edited:
If it makes you happy, 4chan is celebrating that Kate Cwynar is gone. It was on a livestream with Trash Taste.
(Archive)
https://youtube.com/watch?v=D8Gi1PArtsw
Of course there are Kate simps like that FFXIV lolcow & Airbagged dickrider Roegamaniac.
View attachment 8132325View attachment 8132328

Reminder.
View attachment 8132330View attachment 8132335

EDIT: Archduke Grummz won.
View attachment 8132357View attachment 8132472View attachment 8132471View attachment 8132477
What?

Localization always dogshit for niponese games and I accepted that.

They just fucked with the story too much, made everything lame and gay.
WoW is a tad recovering from this shit, getting a bit outside of the "Villain of the expansion" format.

The thing is where WoW recovers from Bobby's retarded vision, FFXIV has become more arrogant.
They have been the big MMO for half a decade and think everyone will gobble it up like blizzard did before.

Unless ffxiv does something big again, they will die down.
Unironicly, banning the ERP mods was their biggest mistake, as coomers always bring a string of continious revenue.
 
EDIT: Archduke Grummz won.
I sincerely doubt Grummz had fuck all to do with any decision related to Kate. He's a useless tit just like Kate.

One of two things happened here - either Kate wanted to quit because she hated the attention and notoriety, and they made a deal to have her be the fall guy so they could save face, orrr....
I've been saying that heads needed to roll with the EN localization side of things and I think that my feelings would be stronger if I had any sort of command of Japanese. There are a lot of instances where, having gotten a sense for things like Japanese pacing, manners, etc. things just sounded off in DT.

The bigger issue is shit like the overall audio quality being trash, hiring borderline amateurs to be the fucking lead in your Triple A Studio game, flat, joyless writing, and other inane creative decisions. If Kate's role follows the responsibilities and such as similar positions do, she absolutely would be overseeing and even potentially having final say. That we're seeing so many corrections to these issues indicates that the higher ups realized after the fact that she was fucking the dog.

Coupled with the sheer number of minor errors it paints a dire picture of someone not doing their job. I imagine we'll hear that she was 'homesick' or just wanted to be 'closer to home' or some shit, but I can't imagine getting promoted rather recently and then willfully choosing to eject (IIRC she was promoted sometime leading up to the launch of EW as it was discussed in a LL or some other thing.) And the fact that she wasn't side shuffled to another role/department is also pretty telling, as is no 'it's been a fun strange trip, but moving onto bigger things' or whatever. (Good, I hope she's seething.)

I don't think that she is being made into a sacrificial lamb -- JP audiences also hated DT by and large, although not as rabidly as EN ones did -- and that this might be an indicator that they're serious about cleaning shit up.

Whether they actually fucking get there is another story entirely.
 
Kate is almost certainly not out due to performance. Japan doesn't really do that, and even if they did, the game is floundering in all languages and regions.

It could just be that they started giving her directives from above about stuff and she refused. Or it could just be a matter of pay. Or it could just be her not wanting to be the community punching bag every time there's a story misstep.

There's so many other fundamental problems with the game that I don't see this changing much.

Kate is gone. Great!
Do Ozma next.
The Ozmafication of content coupled with the complete gutting of everything else is a major issue that none of the big content creators for this game want to talk about because they're also all Arthars-tier raidtrannies.
 
Last edited:
The thing is where WoW recovers from Bobby's retarded vision, FFXIV has become more arrogant.
WoW during Shadowlands was in the same slump Squeenix has been in since 2020 in that everything from the storytelling to the environments to the characters was SSRI depression dampened dogshit. Depressing grey and brown environments, grimdark story arcs with shitty unsatisfying conclusions, a complete lack of depth in the way characters interacted. Then in DF they started making beautiful environments again, featuring bikini bitches like Alexstrasza and Xalatath, and hiring actual fans to write their wokeshit characters so they at least had a little sovl and identity beyond being cardboard tropes.

Every character in FFXVI, FF7R, and DT is flat, one-dimensional, played out, and autistic. The stories to all of them, especially the endings, are depressing unsatisfying horseshit. The gameplay is just beating up unthreatening punching bags with bloated health pools for 10 minutes each with no actual difficulty. It's a company-wide rot. Their shit sucks and all of their sales underperform their bloated graphics budgets that still end up looking ugly and dated.

Unless ffxiv does something big again, they will die down.
Unironicly, banning the ERP mods was their biggest mistake, as coomers always bring a string of continious revenue.
Look at the Chinese industry where individual games like Genshin Impact make more profit than all of Playstation. Vibrant colors and great art design, bouncing booba and high heels on all the girls, badass dudes with cool outfits, satisfying stories with epic anime climaxes, that's what people want to play. Squeenix just keeps fucking sucking after getting it right with DQXI and they probably won't fix it until they're about to go bankrupt again.
 
The thing is where WoW recovers from Bobby's retarded vision,
Bobby never decided what the story or gameplay for WoW was going to be about. He would only be focusing on the business aspect like store and WoW Tokens.
Maybe he told them to axe the warlords of draenor story early because player retention was shit, but that would be the limit to his involvement.
The problem for WoW is hiring too many faggots at Blizzard and turning warcraft into some saccharine sappy bullshit for Disney adults
1762432843963.jpeg
With housing tokens on top of paying a subscription on the way I see no way to redeem WoW
 
Bobby never decided what the story or gameplay for WoW was going to be about. He would only be focusing on the business aspect like store and WoW Tokens.
Maybe he told them to axe the warlords of draenor story early because player retention was shit, but that would be the limit to his involvement.
The problem for WoW is hiring too many faggots at Blizzard and turning warcraft into some saccharine sappy bullshit for Disney adults
View attachment 8133476
With housing tokens on top of paying a subscription on the way I see no way to redeem WoW
Mealz on Wheelz was the rage during that time though. Even XIV had it.
1762440521544.png
 
Kate is almost certainly not out due to performance. Japan doesn't really do that, and even if they did, the game is floundering in all languages and regions.
I dunno. It's really weird that, as far as we can tell, she's not with the company and there's no explanation on her next move.

Knowing of some game dev folks on Twitter, they generally don't miss the opportunity to share promotions/new gigs/being laid off/etc. if the opportunity presents itself. Kate very much fits the mold of those types and it's strange that we basically find out through a promo video featuring another dude.

If she was promoted, I guarantee she'd be screaming it from the rooftops. If she found a position at another studio, she'd also likely be sharing that.

Just the way that this information came out makes me think she was let go, and based on what I've seen from her efforts and public statements I imagine part of the reason was she was let go.

(Now watch as it comes out that she was promoted or some shit after having said all this.)
It could just be that they started giving her directives from above about stuff and she refused. Or it could just be a matter of pay. Or it could just be her not wanting to be the community punching bag every time there's a story misstep.
I'm incredibly skeptical on all of that. Lore and narrative discussions seem to be collaborative, remember her anecdote about 'fighting' to get 'they/them' pronouns for the ShB fey, and her just going rogue and inserting shit that makes no sense would have been caught by the fans who play in EN and JP. She's a turbo weeb so working for peanuts (if she was) for a company she likely adores would be a non-issue, especially given that dirty gaijins have a chance for upward mobility (a la Koji Fox), and the punching bag thing seems to be something she relished.

I'm actually hoping now that she doesn't have to worry about proper conduct we may see the beginning of a lolcow arc with her.
The Ozmafication of content coupled with the complete gutting of everything else is a major issue that none of the big content creators for this game want to talk about because they're also all Arthars-tier raidtrannies.
I'm curious what sort of content you'd want to be seeing and/or what sort of content has been stripped from the game that is missing?
Mealz on Wheelz was the rage during that time though. Even XIV had it.
The whole thing with Arenvald makes sense (although I still think they did him dirty) -- he's a B-Tier guy who got knocked the fuck out, and him being on the sidelines and in a wheelchair makes sense given everyone was dealing with the potential end of existence.

The shit with Khadghar is contrived and insulting. You have one of the most powerful archmages in existence, whose magical abilities (IIRC) weren't hampered, opting to use a wheelchair because it was a 'gift from a friend', rather than something that'd be far more practical, imaginative, etc.

The whole 'wheelchairs in Dungeons and Dragons/fantasy' was all the rage at the time, like you said, and basically just came from retards trying to be contrarian.
 
Back
Top Bottom