Fanon Wikis

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
ThunderCavalier said:
I remember back when MLP was about a bunch of ponies learning about friendship and having fun, cheery little adventures.

Exactly where did "dark and edgy" come from in this fandom? This is like trying to introduce a serial killer in Dora the Explorer.
Click to expand...

It didn't take long to find this.

Chronicles of Dora the Explorer: Prolouge

Dora's world has become a dark and grim wasteland, and soon Dora will embark on a journey in order seek revenge on the forces at work.
Click to expand...

Umm, okay. Hope this is a trollfic.
 
ThunderCavalier said:
I remember back when MLP was about a bunch of ponies learning about friendship and having fun, cheery little adventures.

Exactly where did "dark and edgy" come from in this fandom? This is like trying to introduce a serial killer in Dora the Explorer.
Click to expand...

It probably starts the way it always does; somebody made a dark, edgy joke, it caught on, and then people start doing it seriously.

Dumb Frogposter said:
ayy
tumblr_maiyf6x3C31r0gvleo2_500.jpg
Click to expand...

This is some goddamned bullshit.

Nobody ever wants to make a hard copy book of my fanfictions. :heart-empty:
 
Dr. Meme said:
I found a really bad fanon wiki here
Click to expand...
What the fuck is a son-ic-chu?

Admiral Piett said:
http://falloutequestria.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout:_Equestria_Wiki

Does this count as fanon?
Click to expand...
In my spergier days (when I was 4 years younger) I actually read through this (The original Fallout Equestria) and let me tell you holy fuck the person who wrote this is fucked in the head. First off it's over 50 chapters and each chapter is 5-15 pages. It's actually longer than most novels, and tries really hard to scare you during it. At one point there was mention of rape and shit in it. Then it went a deeper level of fucked up when some brony wrote porn of it and the author made it canonical. This totally counts as fanon.
 
TM Ambrose said:
In my spergier days (when I was 4 years younger) I actually read through this (The original Fallout Equestria) and let me tell you holy fuck the person who wrote this is fucked in the head. First off it's over 50 chapters and each chapter is 5-15 pages. It's actually longer than most novels, and tries really hard to scare you during it. At one point there was mention of rape and shit in it. Then it went a deeper level of fucked up when some brony wrote porn of it and the author made it canonical. This totally counts as fanon.
Click to expand...

I guess friendship really is magic!
 
TM Ambrose said:
In my spergier days (when I was 4 years younger) I actually read through this (The original Fallout Equestria) and let me tell you holy fuck the person who wrote this is fucked in the head. First off it's over 50 chapters and each chapter is 5-15 pages. It's actually longer than most novels, and tries really hard to scare you during it. At one point there was mention of rape and shit in it. Then it went a deeper level of fucked up when some brony wrote porn of it and the author made it canonical. This totally counts as fanon.
Click to expand...

What is the plot, anyway? Is this just ponies roaming a wasteland and running errands for NPCs? And how many pages is it? I've seen this fic mentioned in several places but I don't care to read it.
 
Meowthkip said:
What is the plot, anyway? Is this just ponies roaming a wasteland and running errands for NPCs? And how many pages is it? I've seen this fic mentioned in several places but I don't care to read it.
Click to expand...
Over 500 or so pages, and no it's not running errands for NPC's weirdly enough. The person has put way too much time in establishing a canon for the story. It's about the main character coming to terms with mortality, death, love and their own sexuality.... Also did I mention the main character is a lesbian and leaves the vault to chase after some chick she wants to fuck? Don't think I mentioned that. Also there's implied child rape. The main character also gets addicted to drugs because really the person who wrote this shit is an edgelord. I never read anything outside the original (there is like 1000 other stories) so I don't know much about the side stories but the main story is autistic enough so i'm guessing any fan work is just as autistic.
 
TM Ambrose said:
Over 500 or so pages, and no it's not running errands for NPC's weirdly enough. The person has put way too much time in establishing a canon for the story.
Click to expand...

Jesus Christ.

500 pages for ponies.

You could have taken that crossover concept and made it a one-shot. It'd be way more accessible that way, just a fun little exercise that plays with dark and edgy themes applied to a cutesy cartoon. Tongue in cheek and all that.

I just... goddammit.
 
Last edited:
Meowthkip said:
Jesus Christ.

500 pages for ponies.

You could have taken that crossover concept and made it a one-shot. It'd be way more accessible that way, just a fun little exercise that plays with dark and edgy on a cutesy cartoon. Tongue in cheek and all that.

I just... goddammit.
Click to expand...
Wait no. It's 1000+ pages. The entire novel is 620,295 words. Compare that to the entire Harry Potter series which is 1084170 words. Currently the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series is 1770000 words.
 
TM Ambrose said:
Wait no. It's 1000+ pages. The entire novel is 620,295 words. Compare that to the entire Harry Potter series which is 1084170 words. Currently the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series is 1770000 words.
Click to expand...

... Fuck me. :sighduck:
 
TM Ambrose said:
Over 500 or so pages, and no it's not running errands for NPC's weirdly enough. The person has put way too much time in establishing a canon for the story. It's about the main character coming to terms with mortality, death, love and their own sexuality.... Also did I mention the main character is a lesbian and leaves the vault to chase after some chick she wants to fuck? Don't think I mentioned that. Also there's implied child rape. The main character also gets addicted to drugs because really the person who wrote this shit is an edgelord. I never read anything outside the original (there is like 1000 other stories) so I don't know much about the side stories but the main story is autistic enough so i'm guessing any fan work is just as autistic.
Click to expand...
The thing is... the premise isn't half-bad. If you refined it a bit, tried not to be too edgy, and put the focus squarely on one thing, you could get a compelling story out of that.

... Oh, and if you didn't make the whole thing about fucking ponies.
 
ThunderCavalier said:
The thing is... the premise isn't half-bad. If you refined it a bit, tried not to be too edgy, and put the focus squarely on one thing, you could get a compelling story out of that.

... Oh, and if you didn't make the whole thing about fucking ponies.
Click to expand...
Good story + ponies = bad
Good story - ponies + humans = good?
 
ThunderCavalier said:
The thing is... the premise isn't half-bad. If you refined it a bit, tried not to be too edgy, and put the focus squarely on one thing, you could get a compelling story out of that.

... Oh, and if you didn't make the whole thing about fucking ponies.
Click to expand...
Yeah I know, I heard a group of developers made a game based on this premise.... It was called Fallout.
 
TM Ambrose said:
Wait no. It's 1000+ pages. The entire novel is 620,295 words. Compare that to the entire Harry Potter series which is 1084170 words. Currently the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series is 1770000 words.
Click to expand...

That's just the original novel. There's a whole universe of this shit. Probably tens of millions of words.

(War and Peace, btw, has 650,000 words.)

It's on fimfic but these guys apparently have taken that down.


Original name, guys.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom