Fanfiction Horrors

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
I find it difficult to believe that these fics are all that good, though.
Oh no, they are generally awful in their own unique way. I mostly find them interesting by trying to work out where they got their info from. Was it just by reading the "important" fics of the fandom, or did they at least attempt to read a wiki? Something I find fascinating with fandom is the creation and spread of fanon, and a lot of these fics are mostly built on fanon.
 
Oh no, they are generally awful in their own unique way. I mostly find them interesting by trying to work out where they got their info from. Was it just by reading the "important" fics of the fandom, or did they at least attempt to read a wiki? Something I find fascinating with fandom is the creation and spread of fanon, and a lot of these fics are mostly built on fanon.
To be honest, this is how is how I feel about the newer (non-cartoon) Star Trek shows. /semi off topic
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty convinced that most of the people in this locust crowd never actually get around to watching/reading/playing the source material and churn out fanwork based entirely off of other fanworks. Then, after a few months, their interest dries up just as suddenly as it appeared, and they move on to something else.
That's a good name for the phenomenon; a traveling group that boosts and then deflates a fandom, leaving it eternally changed. Like a book club but horny; the cliterati.
but I've heard rumors that quite a few famous fan fictions were written by people who hadn't engaged with the standard recommended subset of the source material of their fandom
I see authors preface their work with that, or in the case of something with a lot of canon, explain that they've watched the first season only, played two video games and watched a Let's Play of the third. Or something like that. I'm sure there are more authors who are keeping it quiet.
(ETA: This is also a Star Trek fic, and the author has watched some of the other series all the way through, so she does have firsthand knowledge of a lot of the worldbuilding + the general vibe.)
I maintain it's now possible to be a cultural Star Wars fan or Trekkie, the same way as an atheist raised in North Dakota is unavoidably a cultural Christian. These are our new mythos, maaaan. (And they've been taken from true believers and turned into/bought out by giant profit-driven corporations... if I were more pretentious there'd be a whole hour-long video here.)
did they at least attempt to read a wiki?
Fan wikis have been a godsend for fanfic writers, even as the decentralized Internet dies.
 
From the same author that wrote that God-awful Mpreg Viktor fic comes a true Gay Love fic where Trans Man Viktor gets into a relationship with prison bitch Jayce. It's only two chapters so far, but like the other fic, I want to see how it goes before I go all in or tap out. Link to fic.
The author thought it'd be amazing to make Jayce fully Latino, not knowing the stereotype of Latinos being criminals. "They're rapists, they're murderers, and some, I assume, are good people" - zbz
prison jayce.PNG
Already this is better written than the other Mpreg fic the author wrote, because that shit is godawful. However, in this fic, Viktor is a pooner instead of the pseudo-pooner he is in the other fic, but you really won't notice a difference.
prison jayce 2.PNG
Ahh there's that white picket fence clichéinteresting how all pooners dream of being a tradwife while saying they're a Real Dood.

If you didn't read my lampooning of the other fic, Atreus was one of the baristas at the coffee shop Viktor worked at. He's a nod to the God of War games, because there is nothing more humbling than having the Ghost of Sparta's son serving Frappuccinos to a bunch of screaming Oregonites.
prison jayce 3.PNG
I will allow that the description of the food is nice. Way better than the other fic.
prison jayce 4.PNG
We later find out that Viktor did indeed send Jayce letters, but that they were never delivered to him. Jayce thinks Viktor abandoned him. He did not; but it is curious why the pooner never visited the male prison - oh wait, nevermind.

Compared to 'Coming Home', where Jayce's feelings were open to Viktor and Viktor is too dumb to interpret them as gay romantic feelings, these two are very open about their feelings for each other. It's a nice change, and I am so used to the jarring dialogue of Coming Home I must admit it's something else seeing it written competently.

BTW, Jayce got 4 years for murder, and is recently paroled. Broke as fuck despite someone pulling strings to get him out early. My bets are he was jailed for killing someone who 'misgendered' and tried to hate crime pooner Viktor.
prison jayce 5.PNG
Before I read ahead, I thought it strange that Jayce knew about Cait speaking to Vi via a pen pal program when Viktor never did the same for him. Now that the letters were simply intercepted it makes sense. But Viktor never bothered to call Jayce, which you are allowed to do. Was he allowed phone calls, or no?
prison jayce 6.PNG
Yes, the author wants to make Jayce an authentic Hispanic by having him say random Spanish phrases. No, he won't be sporting MS-13 tattoos or yelling racial slurs at black people (at least not yet). He'll just be in a halfway house until he hears the call of Viva La Raza.
prison jayce 7.PNG
We know Jayce is a big boy, and that he got jumped in prison, but what's interesting is that he didn't make friends in prison. He's a big fucking Hispanic guy; the other Hispanics are going to rally around him. If he ain't punching back he's getting shanked - and he did, with toothbrushes. 4 years for murder is a walk in the park. People get longer prison sentences for pissing off the HOA.
prison jayce 8.PNG
It would be American cheese because it keeps its shape - try watching The Menu for once.
prison jayce 9.PNG
Ahhh there's that binary talk. Gotta have that in a fic where a woman pretends to be a True and Honest Man and had a Hispanic man take the fall for *his white privileged ass. Damn, can an ese get a break?
prison jayce 10.PNG
Here's what's binary: you, a Man of Colour, went to jail for a White (Wo)man. Top and bottom, literally and figuratively. Race war for troons. Amazin'
bad boy blues.PNG
> Says he's the one
> Somehow remains in denial
Ehhh I can kinda forgive Jayce's ignorance, but only so much. It's been four years, not forty. And you were allowed phone calls, friendo.
bad boy blues 2.PNG
You are NOT gonna believe what they do in the hallway.
bad boy blues 3.PNG
> Slender waist
> Full hips that are a delight to hold
> Ruins his face with ugly ass earrings
> dresses like a grandfather
Yep, that's a pooner. I cannot believe they want to tarnish such a Czech beauty with such filth. Be gone! My boy has style, you skin walking, stinky T bitch.
bad boy blues 4.PNG
That's right: he rubs him up in the hallway, where people can see. Luckily the 40 second blowjob occurs inside Viktor's apartment - can you imagine coming home from work and witnessing that? World star!

40 seconds is incredible. Must be that pooner pussy magic. I will say that the smut, vague as it is, is still better than in 'he discovers flowers'. Holy fuck were those scenes bad.
bad boy blues 5.PNG
I'm still betting on Jayce murdering a guy for an anti-trans hate crime. You wanna pitch in?
bad boy blues 6.PNG
Damn, boy is horny AF. Must be that T acting up.
bad boy blues 7.PNG
Still betting on that hate crime!

40 second climax.PNG
That's right: Viktor has a copy of Stephen Jay Gould's magnum opus in bullshit. Of course he wouldn't be reading the Bell Curve; that's just too offensive for a pooner.

Jayce acting shocked that Viktor waited for him for four years does make me roll my eyes a bit. 4 years for murder is nothing. Plus, it appears Jayce never got his phone call(s), so this is just one of those Just So stories to ramp up the drama. The dialogue and interactions are still better than 'Coming Home', though.
40 second climax 2.PNG
Amazing how Jayce got erect again after that 40 second climax. Man must have stamina for days. He didn't even wait for his refractory period!
40 second climax 3.PNG
Also amazing how Jayce gets literally soft for just a two minute conversation. He must be like an automaton you can just turn on and off: erect one minute, soft the next. I love this anatomy!
40 second climax 4.PNG
Yep, there has to be a mention of mastectomy scars. I am thankful there is no use of 'front hole' (yet) and you can re-program yourself to think Viktor is a man if you want, especially with that comment of giving him a hand job in a movie theatre. Imagine having stale popcorn butter on your dick. And fucking in a pub bathroom! That must've been so validating for Viktor, having that man pussy be fucked over piss stains and stale beer.
40 second climax 5.PNG
Funny thing about that 'not knowing almost killed him' line...a reviewer said that this fic wasn't cheesy like most romance plots. I'd like to point to that first highlighted sentence.

> Asks Jayce if he came
> Pretty obvious he would've felt it

Damn, first we got 100% Authentic Gay Sex and now phantom cum. Amazin'!
40 second climax 6.PNG
Murderers go to jail. Shocker. It clearly wasn't first-degree or that big of a deal because Hispanic Jayce probably got the ACLU and Saul Goodman to defend him. Can't keep an ese down, y'know?

Also, LMAO at the fact that Viktor being nice and sentimental was only due to him wanting to get fucked. What a nice, empathetic person. Or as we say in the business: a typical fucking pooner.
40 second climax 7.PNG
Pooners have terrible fashion sense and it leaks into whatever character they're projecting on. Viktor has always dressed nicely, even when dirt poor. He'd find oversized sweaters like that ironic; he wouldn't actually wear them. An actual gay man would never be caught dead wearing something like that. Other gays would hate crime him for bad fashion.
40 second climax 8.PNG
> be a pooner
> Have an 'accidentally woman brained' moment by capsizing a boat
> nearly drowned, laughs anyway
> You weren't in New Zealand
> Wew, lad
40 second climax 9.PNG
40 second climax 10.PNG
> Be Viktor
> Be described as healthier and fuller than what you once were
> Your fridge is fucking empty and filled with processed food shit
AKA, the token pooner diet.
spaghetti memories.PNG
You're never gonna believe what the reaction to this cooking disaster was
spaghetti memories 2.PNG
A commenter - you'll find out who soon enough - mentioned that Jayce's gaydar works perfectly. The funny thing is, he's a 'gay man' fucking pussy, but that's OK because we're told genitalia has no ties to gender and it's a man's pussy if the pussy owner identifies as one. Also, nice way of sexualizing minors, you MS-13 reject.
spaghetti memories 3.PNG
> No girlfriends
> Is still having penis-in-vagina sex but it's gay because Viktor is totally a male
> Insists he's a Gold star gay
About as believable as that spaghetti being good, especially if it's stale spaghetti sauce.
spaghetti memories 4.PNG
Hope they got Listerine in the cupboard, because you're gonna be tasting that oregano all day, ese. But it's only a twinge better than your 'boyfriend' chugging chocolate milk and garlic, because pooners suck at cooking. Eugh. I want to brush my teeth now.

Now, for some comments. Did you know prison is a blight?
prison is a blight.PNG
Gosh golly, that's so deep. Where are we going to put all those rapists and murderers, then?

(and no, you don't need to re-read anything. The writing is straightforward and simple and there are no hidden meanings to be found.)

This was the person who inspired the update:
successfully enthralled.PNG
Don't read 'he produces flowers', you might have an aneurysm.

Look at all these details:
haphazard details.PNG
> Distracted and unperceptive
Get that media literacy, chud.

> Didn't see the saucy twist coming
I mean, it was pretty obvious they were going to some Frankenstein shit with the food.

> Jayce's gaydar is working flawlessly
He's fucking vagina and pretending it's gay.

> Soo curious whether you'll explore this
Probably not, in the author's larger story she 'solves' plots by conveniently writing them out/solving them with a Just So solution. It got enraging pretty quick. I bet it'll happen here.

> Says it doesn't read cheesy
> Jayce was having literal panic attacks because he thought Viktor abandoned him
OOOF learn media literacy CHUD
haphazard details 2.PNG
> Nothing is OOC
> Viktor, a male, is made a pooner 'just cause' and we're to believe it's a gay pairing

And yes, it's unjustly mediocre. Sure, the dialogue isn't as bad as Coming Home, but the internal logic is still iffy. It's still early; there's a lot to ground to cover before this gets as wacky as 'he produces flowers'. I'm still betting Jayce went to jail because of a trans hate crime, lmao.

What could the mystery crime be? From the same commenter who said 'Coming Home' had an 'enchanting AU':
mystery crime.PNG
Always about safety with these pooners. It was four years for murder. You're not the Alaskan Avenger; calm the fuck down.

Your honourable mentions:
Screenshot_20241010-193056_(1).png
Screenshot_20241010-193235_(1).png
Ever want to see someone fuck Spongebob? You're in luck.
Screenshot_20241010-193535_(1).png
 
Last edited:
Semi off-topic, but I've heard rumors that quite a few famous fan fictions were written by people who hadn't engaged with the standard recommended subset of the source material of their fandom. A fiction writer's job is to make things up, but in many cases readers would be surprised by how much guesswork and secret Q&A sessions went into the final result.
This is a NOTORIOUS problem in anything involving tbe Robins from Batman/extended Batfam stuff. It's bad enough to the poibt wgerecwhole servers for Batman fanfiction haven't even read a single issue of ANYTHING Batman.

(I also dealt with this personally when the first Venom movie came out and I assume it's a lot worse now. Ended up leaving fan communitues I was previousky in due to movie tourists and being harrassed for "gatekeeping" for not really liking movies/offering people free comic links of they wanted to understand what I was referencing.)
 
If anything, fandoms needs to be gatekept more.
I'm not worried about a fanbase dying. Especially if it's for an IP that isn't actively producing anything anymore, so the creators have basically made all the money they're gonna make anyway. I'm more concerned about otherwise interesting communities being taken over by screeching, lazy, woke, clout-chasing dimwits who lack the attention span to read the goddamn book/watch the goddamn show/play the goddamn game. (:_(
 
If anything, fandoms needs to be gatekept more.
I'm not worried about a fanbase dying. Especially if it's for an IP that isn't actively producing anything anymore, so the creators have basically made all the money they're gonna make anyway. I'm more concerned about otherwise interesting communities being taken over by screeching, lazy, woke, clout-chasing dimwits who lack the attention span to read the goddamn book/watch the goddamn show/play the goddamn game. (:_(

I've said it before and I'll say it again: social media abd removing barriers ruined the internet. Takes no skill whatsoever to be online and post, you don't even do the bare minimum of finding a dedicated forum/LJ anymore.

Normie attention whores need to go back to their shit and let us actually autistic speds make our fanfiction in peace
 
This M guy might be the most degenerate person I’ve seen in one of these threads and that’s saying something. His entire profile is thousands of fanfictions just about some poor anime girl or genshin/Pokemon/fire emblem character being violently raped and killed, always in excruciatingly high detail with overly sexual and cutsey writing.

I’m all for laughing at people with weird fetishes (that’s the main reason I post in this thread honestly) but there is something very wrong with this guy.

The only silver lining is he hasn’t done this to an actual woman (at least not that anybody knows of).
 
This M guy might be the most degenerate person I’ve seen in one of these threads and that’s saying something.
Okay, I did some digging because I'm in one of those moods and was curious about this person.
I'll just post my findings here.

This guy has a fanbox account (something like japanese patreon, I guess?).
I'm not sure if there's a way to see how many people are subscribed to his stuff.

He also has a discord, I did not join it; I doubt I'll have enough bleach stashed in my apartment to cleanse my brain from whatever's hiding in there.
Screenshot 2024-10-17 at 18.16.29.png

I also found the "depravity repository" where he seems to be active as well (his posts).
According to his posts, he's active on guro websites as well, especially gurochan (not that it's a big surprise).

If anyone wants to check out his discord and tell me what's going on there - be my guest.

Btw, someone on xitter wrote a tutorial on how to filter out M's fanfics, I'll just post this here because some people might want to know.
1729182104551.png
 
Speaking of snuff, in addition to Inktober (one drawing everyday during the month of October) and Kinktober (the same, except for smut fanfics/fanart) being things, apparently Snufftober (the same, except it's all snuff fics) is also a thing:

1729218295190.png

Link / Archive

And since most snuff fics involve male writers writing about female characters being brutally raped and killed, are there any female writers that do the same for male characters? I don't remember seeing a snuff fic where a male character gets the same treatment.
 

Attachments

Chapter 7 of Coming Home arrives. I eagerly await for the smut scene so I can see how badly it's going to be mangled due to the dialogue.
professor picks.PNG
Ekko? Being Piltie friendly? That's like asking if black people like cops - a big fat fucking no.

Once again, the author cannot decide whether she wants Viktor to reconcile with Jayce or be a cruel, catty faggot. We're sticking with the latter, Just Cause. We need that drama for the eventual reconciliation fuck.
professor picks 2.PNG
If this woman has a beta, they need to get a brick to the head. There is no fucking way this made it past the editing stage - and it's happened in every fucking chapter. I get anal if a period is missing or if I confuse 'lighting' with 'lightning'. What is their excuse?
professor picks 3.PNG
You're not great with being, you know, an accomplished genius either. The author waits until THIS fucking chapter to mention he works in augmentations and robotics, btw.

And according to the end notes, this author decided to be accurate with grad school bitching, but not with these. I'm doing more research than this bitch, LMAO
professor picks 4.PNG
Can. You stop. Writing dialogue. Like you're a fucking. Millennial? How come a dumb bitch who wrote an Mpreg fic where the child was named tar baby manages to get dialogue right, but not this one where Viktor is an actual man? FOH
professor picks 5.PNG
> Hex scholars exist
> This is a modern AU
> Author has not even considered how modern tech and magic would co-exist
> It's retarded

Viktor telling the other guy he's a loser because he never filed a patent when Viktor willingly sold his half of a patent because he didn't want to give speeches is pretty fucking dumb. Aside from him being ill, there was never a solid reason given as to why he signed away his intellectual property rights. Then again, the author is retarded and should be shamed for thinking this makes a lick of sense.

Also, if this man's invention is an electric toaster...he'd be pretty fucking rich. Something something ebil capitalism, something something
professor picks 6.PNG
> Viktor gets turned on when Jayce gets angry
Oh, that's going to be a theme in the porn scene, isn't it? Place your bets now.

> Also gets humiliated at Jayce standing up for him, despite not even bothering to stand up for himself

This motherfucker cannot decide whether he's flattered or offended. Just stick with 'flattered and turned on', it'd make a lot more sense. Or as we say in the business, pick a fucking struggle.
professor picks 7.PNG
> Thinks they've gotten too comfortable with each other
> Haven't spoken outside of professional settings and the literal fever dream
> Guys, it's drama guys
> Admits he's always wanted Jayce, but was written in earlier chapters to be oblivious to Jayce's VERY OPEN feelings for him
> PICK A FUCKING STRUGGLE

"That was. That was very childish" - SO IS THIS WRITING AND I'M GONNA COMPLAIN ABOUT IT ALL DAY

Ten hours for a wastewater tank test? The fuck you doing, making it military ready?
professor picks 8.PNG
Oh yes, you want a fire NEXT TO A WASTEWATER TANK, FILLED WITH METHANE GAS THAT IS HIGHLY FLAMMABLE. Interesting how we went from industrial pollution - which is what static scrubbers are for - to wastewater management, which involves different processes and different tech. There was no mention or explanation that it would be used for both.

> Becides
GET A FUCKING BETA OR FIRE THE ONE YOU HAVE, GODDAMIT

And please use commas. These random sentences are killing me.
professor picks 9.PNG
Can you please. Write normally. For once? Use complete sentences? It's not that hard.
professor picks 10.PNG
> Makes robot to teach kids how to draw
> AI and video tutorials already exist for that
> Could've opted for robots to help kids who have lost their hands or motor function how to regain them
> I am already a better storyteller
screw loose.PNG
> Few, when she meant Phew
WEW, LAD
screw loose 2.PNG
Please. Just write. Normally. For fucking once.

Also, LMAO at Viktor being concerned that the COPS are going to be interested in using the butterflies when we all know Uncle Sam would be eating up that shit. For a 'worldly leftist', Viktor isn't all that worldly. It's also a lot of work for tech that wouldn't be functional to begin with (how would it stop a gas powered gun? It's going to explode right in your face, something Viktor straight up says. It's not feasible, either). I also had a cackle at the school bombing thing. Girl is creating mini McVeighs.
screw loose 3.PNG
So, this is the conclusion to the Jinx/Powder plot...as if Caitlyn wouldn't notice a blue-haired girl with a peculiar personality hanging out at a prestigious university her mother funds. Yeah yeah, a bunch of libtards with blue hair and whatnot...but Jinx stands out. The fact Caitlyn didn't think to ask Jayce about it or Jayce mentioning it to her is a plot hole.

> I've done a lot of shitty things
But you can get that record expunged and go to university, when most people with a record can't. White girl privilege.
screw loose 4.PNG
> Emotion flies in the face of logic
> Has been emotional this entire time, even being catty when there is no reason to be
> Fluctuates between what he feels and what he wants to do, despite Jayce being very open about wanting to dick him down
> Be Viktor

I'd kick myself too if I were Caitlyn. She probably should've tried 4chan.
screw loose 5.PNG
We had to wait until CHAPTER SEVEN to hear about what Viktor was doing back in Zaun. Chapter fucking seven. He's never shown to actually DO any of the things he's canonically known for, and you'd never know he was a genius unless you were explicitly told so. What a fucking hack.

Now, can you please. Write things in a single, solid sentence. I am fucking begging you. I am about to become John Doe from SE7EN. Please.
screw loose 6.PNG
JUST WRITE FUCKING NORMALLY SO THEY CAN HAVE NORMAL FUCKING DIALOGUE GOD

> Did I do something wrong?
Nigga, you seriously asking that? You fucking threw Viktor under the bus by getting him to sign away his rights to his half of the patent. He's infinitely more forgiving than I'd ever be. But it's OK because Viktor read his journal and read how much Jayce missed him and oh my God he's just so sad and miserable and he can't live without him...bitch, fuck off.
screw loose 7.PNG
> Says he's loved Jayce all this time
> has acted ignorant of Jayce's extremely open affections, to the point their own students gossip about them
> Jayce complains Viktor doesn't want to trust him when he actively betrayed him and got him to sell his patent to a company he somehow didn't know what that fucking evil
And we are STILL using that dialogue, Jesus Christ. I am about to go Gary Plauche on them.

> Jayce says he regrets the things he says
He sure didn't regret them in the first few chapters, and still has not apologized once
screw loose 8.PNG
Jayce is right here. Viktor brings these things up as a gotcha when he doesn't let Jayce explain his side of the story. problem is, he's already done that...and he's still a shitty person. Reminder: Caitlyn AND Jayce's mom had to gaslight Viktor into accepting an apology because 'Jayce felt bad'. None of this is genuine.

> Viktor says he never hated Jayce
Far cry from him enjoying seeing Jayce be humiliated. Oh right, that change came because he read how much Jayce missed him in his journal. Peak character development.

Now, can you like. Stop speaking like you're in the Suicide Squad? Thank you.
screw loose 9.PNG
> Viktor says it's humiliating
> Keeps putting himself in those situations to be humiliated
> Now confesses he has feelings for Jayce despite not reciprocating Jayce's obvious affections (seriously, a fucking 60 IQ autist could tell)

This author cannot write dialogue. I've said it a million times already, but it's fucking terrible. Good God, imagine this in the smut.
screw loose 10.PNG
WAS THIS PROOFREAD? THIS WASN'T PROOFREAD. WHY DO YOU KEEP CAPITALIZING SHIT?

Hope the turkey fucking sucks, bro.
Comments are still coming in, but look at this cope.
disgustingly in love.PNG
> Over protective
> Didn't know what the largest company in their area was despite being a worldly leftist
> Is a literal retard

She's got the 'dissipates into nothingness' part right. None of this shit has meaning.
done somehting to me.PNG
That dialogue sure does haunt me. I want to huff some gasoline after reading it.
 
And since most snuff fics involve male writers writing about female characters being brutally raped and killed, are there any female writers that do the same for male characters? I don't remember seeing a snuff fic where a male character gets the same treatment.
Search "whump" and related terms, or the hurt/comfort tags. Or just the archive tag for rape/non-con. Female writers absolutely churn out fics where male characters get raped and beaten, lol. I will grant that it does seem less likely that female writers actually kill off the characters, but it totally does happen too. What you're seeing is probably just male writers using the term "snuff" while female writers use other terms.
 
I wanted to take a brief break from reading bad troon fics to focus on one that was not too bad. I mentioned HexHomo's 'Catafalque' earlier ITT, and posted a few screenshots, but didn't get around to reading it in its entirety. I finished it a few weeks ago on my e-reader, made a few notes, and decided to post what I liked and didn't like here.

For starters, in terms of Trans Viktor fics, it's one of the better ones. It's not in your face, it's not eye-rolling, and the writing is remarkably good in certain places. What I did notice, though, was tonal changes in the POV, going from serious and witty to Millennial-speak. You'll see what I mean in the spoiler.

Second, this is supposed to be a JayVik fic, but there is no romantic tension until the very last paragraph. You see a lot of pining on Viktor's part on how much he desires Jayce, but you don't see or feel this in reality. This was in stark contrast to 'Divine Alchemy of the Self', where the pining between the two characters was obvious, heartfelt, and tragic (and yes, Viktor was trans in that one too, but it was by far the least egregious one I've found. You can pretend he's male for a large part of the fic). I'm going to post screenshots of what I liked and didn't like for further discussion. Some of these screenshots you'll have seen before, others you won't. Later, I'll be looking at her T4T Jayvik fic to compare to this one.

Reminder that this author actually hated Arcane, talked about how terrible she found it that Viktor was made disabled (she wrote that it undermined his entire LoL arc and his reason for augmentations), hated how Vi was made into an Enforcer and Ekko was working with Piltover people, and oh, kept rancid butter outside of her fridge and forgot to throw it out.
summary.PNG


catafalque.PNG
When I first read this, I had to do a double take before reading it again, before discovering that she meant 'neck tie' rather than 'neck'; otherwise, it seems as if Jayce is twisting his neck around Viktor's like a snake. You'll notice a few out of place words and wordings like this, especially with the 'ugh' comment there. It gets very jarring.
catafalque 2.PNG
Viktor goes from being very introspective and having guilt to being a snarky, smarmy motherfucker. This is also jarring to read. Viktor can be sassy, sure, but this kind of snark is uncalled for, especially when you're doing a Kardashian duckface. Get with the times, boyo.
catafalque 3.PNG
I actually like this, and highlighted it as an example of good worldbuilding/character exploration.
catafalque 4.PNG
This is where you first hear hints that Viktor is trans, with the dolls and skirts. I screenshotted the bits where the author talks about him missing his period before, so that will be discussed further here.
catafalque 5.PNG
> Irregardless
Bruh. Irregardless is normally viewed as redundant as the former word works just fine. And I have to wonder if she meant 'production flaw' vs 'projection flaw' because the former describes what she's writing in that sentence vs the latter.
out of place.PNG
See what I mean? We got from a very serious tone and consistent sentences to descriptions like these, that completely throw you off balance. 'A cumbersome guest with a vile personality' would've worked instead, because the author is talking about catastrophe here. 'High of your balls' makes me think of Jackass. Not a good look.
out of place 2.PNG
I brought up this screenshot before, and here it is with additional commentary. This is the part that confirms Viktor's transness and how he feels in relation with other men: he didn't grow as big as them (even though he's 5'8, which is above average female height, and average male height), his voice didn't drop (until he took T shots, which managed to be synthesized and not, say, ammonium nitrate), and for being a voracious reader, he doesn't know anything about female anatomy. You'd think he'd know what menstruation is just by watching other girls, or reading books on human anatomy.

(One also has to wonder how Piltover managed to synthesize testosterone, but not anything that could fix his chronic condition. One also has to wonder why he sought treatment for his 'wrong sex', but not that. Fatal character and story flaw.)
out of place 3.PNG
It is true malnutrition can delay the onset of menarche. But in this case, Viktor straight up doesn't know what it is. Again, that's a character flaw on the author's part, because Viktor is written as a polymath of sorts. He'd know just for the sake of knowing.
out of place 4.PNG
I also brought up this screenshot before: Viktor, the pooner, nearly gets his hand broken by the token black woman. You have to laugh. And oh, just like Mel, he doesn't really like Sky either. What is it with the subtle racism, man?
out of place 5.PNG
Maybe a more enlightened Kiwi can help me here, but I tried finding the definition for 'becquer' and found nothing. All I get is the Spanish poet.

I also love the fact that the author also makes Jayce to be a bit of a retard, making his math ineligible and unscientific. His math was good enough for him to be one of the top inventors and Big Men of Piltover, so while it may read like a kindergartener's scrawl, it's not dumb. Of course, this is from Viktor's POV which gives him a bit of preening space, but I'd expect a more amused sarcasm rather than the jackass sarcasm I'm reading here.
out of place 6.PNG
> Manchild ambition
At first I did not like this description of Jayce, but then I examined Jayce in this fic and he really is a manchild. I get this is entirely from Viktor's POV, but holy shit. It gets really bad later on.
> Too much of a chickenshit to say it out loud
Huh, Arcane Viktor didn't have that problem. He was a sassy motherfucker when he wanted to be. He'd happily trade barbs with you. The fact it's a pooner saying this makes it funnier in hindsight.
out of place 7.PNG
> Half assed interruption
He meant that interruption because he knew what Jayce was going to do.

> Relieved enough for having be given an excuse to turn to ever really have wanted it
What? I had to re-read this several times. This was definitely a mistake on the beta's and the author's part. It doesn't make a lick of sense. I think she meant: "...relieved enough to have been given an excuse; to doubt if he ever really wanted it." There. Now it makes sense.
out of place 8.5.PNG
I found this scene to be pointless. Jayce is trying to visit his mother with a burnt roast because he was an absolute jackass to her (the reason is never explicitly stated) and Viktor has to be the Yes man while trying to be incognito while 'stage whispering' across a nearly empty street.
out of place 8.PNG
It's common for fanficcers to make Jayce 6'7 when canonically he's 6'2, in order to make Viktor a full foot shorter and highlight the height differences between them (which only makes clocking Viktor far easier, as he's shorter than the actual male).
out of place 10.PNG
"Oh wow" indeed. This dialogue, man.
out of place 9.PNG
This is an intimate act, and one of the few times Jayce seems to reciprocate Viktor's want, but other than that, you never actually see Jayce do anything to earn Viktor's affection. There are no hugs, no smiles, not even friendly banter between them to make it seem as if they're actually a pairing. All the want is on Viktor's side, and it's incredibly one-sided.
romantic troubles.PNG
I've noted quite extensively how bad the dialogue is in 'Coming Home', so it's not surprising to me that this cutesy, manchild dialogue is used here. It's supposed to show Jayce in a cute, lovable light, but it only comes off as annoying.

Also, LMAO at 'the actual street'. I immediately got 'the actual eggs', a line from Life is Strange.
romantic troubles 2.PNG
Why so shy? A real gay man would've not walked back that hug, especially how Viktor was into that hug just a few minutes ago. Him 'squeaking out from pressure' also clocked him. He's far more mature than that. This is a guy whose first lie was about sneaking a guy into his bedroom.
romantic troubles 3.PNG
I did like this scene. It shows Viktor's pain, his struggles, and his inner turmoil.
romantic troubles 4.PNG
So, Jayce shares a bed with Viktor, even while fully clothed, and there isn't any genuine affection here. It's trying to come off as warm and fluffy, but it's oddly sterile. Jayce doesn't show him that affection or need or want or whatever, he's just...there. I've read one-sided pairings but this isn't even that. Yes, it's from Viktor's POV, but if you're writing JayVik, how hard is it to make Jayce feel like a whole person?
romantic troubles 5.PNG
Yes, because the workaholic focused on science and sticking to himself is an alcoholic.
romantic troubles 6.PNG
All this dialogue and soft talk and it still comes off as cold. Jayce just exists; he's not an active force in Viktor's life despite the author's insistence that he is. He doesn't even appear to be a friend, let alone a lover.
romantic troubles 7.PNG
> Doesn't have the will to be repulsed
Come on, man. Say it. She's a dirty fucking nigger taking your man and you don't have the balls (literally, in this case)

BTW, this author uses 'sickly-sweet jasmine' twice:
sickly sweet jasmine.PNG
Niggers and their jasmine. How dare the man that doesn't even have a proper romantic plot be taken away by another woman. If you want me to feel Viktor's hate, make Jayce a proper love interest, not some bland cardboard cutout. Do better.
romantic troubles 8.PNG
I would've liked this to be an entire scene; it would have established a sweet tension these characters needed. As it is, Viktor's affections for Jayce are stated, but not felt. As for Jayce, we don't even know if he likes Viktor or not.
melting gold.PNG
Don't trigger my autism, don't trigger my autism -

For an author who focuses a lot on JayVik and compiles every single interaction between them (and hates the show, mind you), she sure doesn't know that the melting point of gold is 1064 C. Your skin is NOT going to turn it to goo. Is it malleable? Yes. Will it warp? Yes. That's why they add the alloys. But your skin WILL NOT melt it. Fucking retard.
drunken problems.PNG
People were saying in the comments they were glad Sky was made into a person. She really isn't. Viktor still mistreats her even when she gets drunk and vomits everywhere, viewing it as an indignity to HIS person. What an asshole.
drunken problems 2.PNG
More Mel hate. Viktor hates her with a passion. It's just that Central European racism, my doods. He can't stand her fucking Jayce when HIS LOVE IS PURER AND MORE PASSIONATE, DAMMIT (even though said passion and love isn't even fucking there). Yes, you're losing to the pretty black woman because the author hasn't even bothered to introduce pining. That would help your case a lot.
drunken problems 3.PNG
And here we have the T shot reference. Have to have that. Have to have testosterone but nothing else that would actually alleviate your condition, because transition comes before all else.
drunken problems 4.PNG
> As if your goodness could ever be eclipse
Get your fucking beta, I should not be reading such broken sentences.
drunken problems 5.PNG
> bloodpumper
What, was 'heart' too much of a peon word?

Here comes the Hexcore dream sequence:
dream sequence.PNG
dream sequence 2.PNG
> Overdoing it fucks the appeal
I'll say.

Funny how the dream sequence actually has more romantic tension than at any other point in the fic.
dream sequence 3.PNG
Funny, I never saw this want at any other point in the fic. That's what pining is for. It's simply not there.
dream sequence 4.PNG
> Says he wants him so badly
> All we got is a 6'7 manchild who is a cardboard cutout with a barely there personality, and a sardonic, asshole pooner who doesn't do a damn thing about it
> Says he'll die without his love
> We never actually SEE these two in love
Ho hum.

But hey, robo-cock and robo-sex! Subtle, of course.
face like a smore.PNG
Yeah, but we never actually SEE Viktor be affection with Jayce. Ever. The previous fic, Divine Alchemy of the Self, that I mentioned? Oh yeah, the pining was there from the get-go.

How are 'spurs of hysterics' covetous? Should be the opposite.
dream sequence 5.PNG
It was still an accident, because Viktor didn't know Sky was going to be there. And despite his attempts (and by extension, the author's) to humanize her, she still comes off as a one-and-done character. Why does he feel guilt he led her on? He didn't know she existed; in this case, he wasn't aware she had feelings for him because she never expressed them. so much for doing her justice; like Jayce, she's a cardboard cutout, an empty shell for the audience to fill with what they think she should be, rather than being her own person.
face like a smore 2.PNG
I don't know - if there were scenes of Jayce and Viktor talking, building up their repertoire and making me feel as if they were actually doomed lover I'd buy this line of thinking. But 32k words in and there's nothing.
face like a smore 3.PNG
Yes, the author actually used that description. 'His face looked like a s'more'. What a way to set the tone, eh?

> Says he wants Jayce so much it frightens him
> There is literally no scene, line of dialogue, or interaction with Jayce that would actually cement this belief
> It's all one-sided and in Viktor's head
> Comes off as obsessive
Okay, I guess? But a few scenes where they're interacting and Jayce having an actual personality rather than being a manchild would help immensely.

Ironically, it's the end scene where there's actual sexual tension.
face like a smore 4.PNG
face like a smore 5.PNG
Yep. It had to take a fight-or-fuck scene for them to realize they had feelings for each other. Like I said, there were multiple scenes I liked - including Viktor's childhood - and things I did not, such as the jarring Millennial speak and lack of Jayce scenes. Otherwise, it's better than most trans Viktor fics, but only because so many of them are utter trash or basic porn.

The 'your skin melts gold' bit was pretty funny, though. There's no way that wasn't fact-checked.
Now, time for the comments. You'll never guess who showed up.
all I could think about.PNG
Sky is barely there and her 'moment' was her vomiting into a toilet. Viktor tells himself he feels guilt, but he really doesn't.

"I would have genuinely been devastated by her death"
dignity.PNG
Still no characterization and she dies, lmao. She barely makes a skidmark on Viktor's life.
so well done.PNG
Viktor's feelings towards Mel can be summed up as: "This fucking nigger stole my man, a man I barely interact with and only tolerate, but we're meant to be together and I can't live without him WHY THE FUCK DID HE PICK BANTU PUSSY OVER ME?!"

Obligatory TRANS RIGHTS! comment:
hear no different.PNG
Of course not. You're a pooner; you're always going to headcanon that man as the man you wish you could be. You will never have his cheekbones or masculine beauty. Cope, you rancid butter eating hippo.

You'll also NEVER BELIEVE who showed up:
look who it is.PNG
Goes to show you pretty writing cannot always save bad or inconsistent plot or characterization. 'Flawless' is not the word I'd use; 'sorely lacking' is my final judgement.

This next one wouldn't be so bad were it not for the tags. The best parts of it comes from the author's notes, though. She wrote this fic while in high school, and while it's not as bad as most teenage fanfics go, the troon cocksucking gets very tiresome.
holy tags.PNG
Yes, Viktor is trans in this one - and totally gay! Who also happens to be aromantic while having sexual and romantic feelings towards a 'biromantic' Jayce. And yes, they're all autistic and it comes off very clearly in the fic. The author was clearly projecting. The funny thing is, half the time I couldn't even tell the characters had the 'tism, were it not for the author casually reminding me.

So, how did this all start, and end?
how it really started.PNG
> Computer breaks for two months
> Is heading into college
Bruh. You're gonna need one for college. Was she working with a tablet?
how it started.PNG
You'll never guess what happened.
college failure.PNG
That's right. She failed college, which means she now has to pay off that debt, works three jobs like an American does to provide for their family/keep a roof over their head, and was in an abusive sex cult relationship. Wild, eh? I wonder what she was studying that caused her to fail school. That shit costs money.

So what happens when you bring up inconsistencies with her fic and how Viktor is totally gay when he, as a woman, has the hots for a man? You get this:
you are transphobic.PNG
I didn't fail out of college, for one. And I don't know how much money you make, but three jobs and a college dropout is what you expect from some backwater hick - and those people actually have a reason for that. What's yours?
 
Last edited:
I'm gonna interrupt the regularly scheduled rubbernecking at pooner mental illness literature to talk about just how much of a fucking condescending faggot farm the community can act sometimes.
Recently on the AO3 subreddit (yes, I know, reddit, shut up) there was a post where a reader posted five simple words in an author's comment section: "mmm good fic next chapter". Doesn't sound like anything bad or even worth talking about, right? Just an average message of support from some tumblrite who likes their fic, yeah?

Wrong. So, so very wrong.

ffcond.jpeg


The first time I saw this I wanted to throw my phone out the window. What a fucking piece of shit to reply to someone like that with the most attack-dog fuck-you-aura response that I think could possibly be drawn up. At least, that's what a reasonable person would probably think, but this is the fanfiction community, so of course everyone who types a comment that isn't the most obvious toxic positivity happy fuel should get their hands cut off a la the Congolese. Since Redditors are Redditors though, instead of reason prevailing we get a whole host of womenchildren bending over backwards on just how exactly you are supposed to type a positive comment to not get the wrath of an author looking to skewer someone. And I mean really bending over.

"if you don't wanna get flamed, give the author a whole paragraph of praise fluff before you dare type anything else"
fluff.png

"you deserve to be put on a stake, you comment like a toddler" (but positive comments of course could be written like this just fine)
toddler.png

"I'm gonna hold your hand and tell you how to comment properly" (this gives me 'bless your heart' vibes)
lewd.png

this comment is so, so close to getting reasonable views on it all but fails harder than the antiwork interview
soclose.png

and the last one, here's a raisin cookie that'll go on strike and abandon their fic if you trip their angy switch (surprised this one went in the negatives)
abandon.png



Yep, these are the people that are writing your average fanfic in the sitcom/drama show fandoms that they all gravitate to for some reason. Thank god I stick to the occasional generic animu and male smut trash when I wanna read the written word. A lot of times I truly wonder if many authors in the fanfic community actually talk to people face-to-face. Most of them probably do have jobs, they're not useless pooners or NEETs, they're 20-something women that really should know enough to give even just the tiniest morsel of charitable interpretations, but nope. Gotta rant and rave to your fellow thin-skins. It's a shame, really, because they really should be at least tolerable given how much they are supposed to be working on stories rather than bitch on the internet (a good story that's fun to read, usually not but that's a whole other tangent). But this is how the online world works, apparently. Can't wait for next week when the same thing happens again and I gotta try to avoid the same motherfuckers coming out of the woodwork to police the way you are supposed to comment... yippee...
 
I hadn't realized Coming Home had a double update on the 17th, so here is Chapter 8. We are close to the finish line and inevitable smut, so buckle up, homies.

christmas horror.PNG
We're still. Typing sentences. Like this. Because using commas. Is too fucking hard.

> Blubbering mess he sort of blacked out during
During what? Blacking out during what? An anxiety spell?

This Jayce has a fuckton of panic attacks. This is a 180 from the second chapter, where it was Viktor who had the panic attacks. Weird how that got conveniently forgotten.
christmas horror 2.PNG
Jayce is still in denial over his obvious feelings for Viktor - remember, he was the one who made his affections so obvious and clear that his own students gossiped about it - that he has to have gaslighter faghag Caitlyn tell him the facts. So when Jayce is acting le shocked at Viktor 'looking at him differently' it makes me roll my eyes. There's Idiots in Love and there's Retards in Denial. Jayce is the latter.

> Peaks
Lmao this bitch doesn't know the difference between peek and peak.
christmas horror 3.PNG
Oh, he did the meme! "I can take him." "In a fight right?" No, you fucking dumbass, you KNOW what she's referring to. It's pretty obvious Viktor is being somewhat affection towards Jayce at this point, but we have to remember that this 'reconciliation' only started because Caitlyn and Ximena forced Viktor to accept Jayce's groveling as an apology. This wasn't genuine from the get-go.

Jayce getting snippy at Caitlyn telling him the obvious even when it's been made clear that his internal monologues have all been about Viktor is a moot point. We, the audience, know Jayce feels something for him. Stop it with this pseudo-denial; it doesn't make him look cute. It makes him look retarded.
christmas horror 4.PNG
> Jayce wonders if he's worth a relationship with Viktor
> Has to ask Caitlyn what she means about her sexual innuendos
> Thinks about putting his hands on Viktor several paragraphs later
Ho hum. Loving the consistency here.
christmas horror 5.PNG
What did I say. About writing sentences. Like this. When commas. Are there. To bridge different subjects together.

Oh, and look at that. "I'm not gay. I have relationships with women, and sex with men" Jayce is being very touchy-feely with someone he doesn't think is affectionate towards him. Idiots in Love, amirite?
christmas horror 6.PNG
Yes, we know Viktor has beautiful eyes. Thank God he doesn't have a septum piercing and a forked tongue like he did in that one pooner fic. I'm still mad the served COORS LITE AT A RICH PERSON'S WEDDING

Yeah, it's a little weird that you're sharing a bed with your 60-something year old mother. There aren't any more spare rooms? Can't share a room with Viktor? You missed a perfectly good 'there was only one bed' scene.
christmas horror 7.PNG
> Jayce says he doesn't know what he's worth to Viktor and denies his feelings
> Makes his feelings pretty damn open paragraphs later
> Other people notice and mock him for it
Agreed, I also hate these people. They know it and you don't, and they're laughing at you.

Ah, we have the Ugly Christmas Sweater trope. This is how I feel about this fic: the author tried her damnedest to make a work of art, only to have it come out frayed, ugly, and a useless piece of shit. Viktor should not be wearing such a monstrosity, 'tis true. It definitely isn't fair, my dood.
christmas horror 8.PNG
> Jayce says how much he hates these people
> It's OK because it's ironic and he actually loves them
> Never forget that he sold them all out for Noxus because he ran out of money and has never faced consequences for his actions

But hey, Cait is there being a supportive fag hag, playing matchmaker for him and Viktor. We love a good faghag, don't we folks?
christmas horror 9.PNG
Agreed, it's fucking creepy to take pictures of people drunk on a couch without their consent. What, you gonna blackmail him or something? I bet if Jayce took pictures of Cait and Vi having a moment without their consent, it wouldn't be funny. Dial back that creep factor, bud. You're giving us the Ick.
christmas horror 10.PNG
I'm going to start using slurs when it eventually comes to the final review of this fic. This author absolutely deserves it for the shit she put me through.

Ah, so Jayce wants to top this time. We know he has a praise kink and Viktor loves imagining tugging Jayce's hair, so we'll see who really tops and bottoms when the smut comes around. Place your bets.
snowstorm sexual tension.PNG
If you were a genius, you would've already graduated college at 15. Just saying. You wouldn't be begging Noxus for money; they'd be begging YOU.
snowstorm sexual tension 2.PNG
Yeah uhhhh can't I get two number nines, a number nine large, a number six with extra dip...

Still weird to sleep in a bed with your mother when you're a grown man, and HALF NAKED to boot. You're not a Targaryen, stop that.
snowstorm sexual tension 3.PNG
Reminder that Ximena has no idea what Jayce did to fuck Viktor over and assumed her son Dindu Nuffin. She basically told Viktor Jayce was oh-so-sorry and that he was guilt-ridden and whatever and Viktor just laid down and took it, because muh guilt. Reading his journal didn't help. How to fix betrayal? Listen to someone's mom and read their journal on how they feel bad. That'll fix it.

Also: Jayce never actually apologized to Viktor. He actually gets mad when he's forced to admit he was the guilty party. Of course it has to be his own mother to tell him this.
snowstorm sexual tension 4.PNG
> Why are you depriving yourself
BECAUSE HE SOLD OUT THEIR PATENT TO A WARLORD AND FORCED VIKTOR TO SIGN AWAY HIS INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS. Guess we're forgetting that tidbit because the author downplays the gravity of that situation.
> Do you think he'd be so cruel to cut you out of his life
He had a whale of time seeing Jayce be humiliated in the first few chapters, so yeah. Funny how fast he turned on a dime once he read Jayce's pity party.
> His mom is making sense
She doesn't even know the extent of what he did, and why Viktor hated him. Literally a 'My Son Dindu Nuffin' mom, Hispanic style.
snowstorm sexual tension 5.PNG
You would have quiet days if you actually fucking apologized for what you did. But you're too stubborn to even do that.

> Something's changing, because he feels like he's about to burst
Ah, there's that sexual tension that the author wants Jayce to both deny and indulge him. 'He just doesn't know what he wants'. Bitch, please.
snowstorm sexual tension 6.PNG
> Be Caitlyn
> You're rich as fuck
> Viktor, the leftist, magically doesn't hate you
> She gives you a shitty sweater that's probably fast fashion
> Viktor accepts it anyways
Wow, such a good leftist. That better be real wool.

> Jayce hates goodbyes, despises endings
Huh, maybe you shouldn't have sold your bacterial engine to Ambessa Medarda. Maybe Viktor should've done his research. Maybe this should have never made it past the publish stage, yet here we are.
snowstorm sexual tension 7.PNG
Interesting. Viktor 'pours' over the date twice - in the same paragraph - and the anticipation kills Jayce twice in the same paragraph. Great job, beta!

> He wants. He wants. He wants this work
T-T-T-T-TODAY, JUNIOR
> What. What. Spit it out.
Is this a Ja Rule track?
snowstorm sexual tension 8.PNG
Stop. Writing sentences. Like this. I am. Fucking begging you.

> I just. I just
T-T--T-T-TODAY, JUNIOR

> It fucking works. It works. it works
Yeah, because you're working off an existing technology. We only just find out here, in this chapter, it's a mobile robot. Nice little detail the author conveniently put in at the last minute.

> Oh wow. Oh wow
OH MAN OH GOD. OH MAN OH GOD

Four years, eh? Better get to work then, boys! More inventing, less fucking!
snowstorm sexual tension 9.PNG
He's there because you wanted him to be there. Why are you acting shocked?

Ah, here's the twist. Jayce wants Viktor to have their mobile static scrubber, as atonement for fucking up their battery tech. Wanna see how Viktor takes it?
snowstorm sexual tension 10.PNG
Funny, that. The tech Jayce 'invented' has already been in place for 40 years. His mobile tech would be the only 'new' thing about it, and he'd have to reference other inventors for it. Need I also mention Viktor willingly sold away his half of the battery patent, allowing it to go into the hands of corporate thugs? He has no room to complain about fraud.
babbling apologies.PNG
It took until Chapter 8 for Jayce to finally swallow some humble juice (and later cum) and admit he was wrong. It would have been a more heartfelt confession had the issues been addressed earlier, because what he did was no simple thing. He threw Viktor under the bus, humiliated him and shamed him, and Viktor signed away his rights while ill because Jayce told him to. He ruined Viktor's life, but that's OK because they're crying and upset and they need to fuck now.

And. The confession. Sure doesn't sound. As genuine. When the sentences. Are structured. Like this.
babbling apologies 2.PNG
> Too naive to see how horrible Noxus was
To be fair, so was Viktor. The worldly leftist had no idea what they were, who they were or what they were doing, and still signed away his rights. What a fucking retard. The Internet presumably exists, and yet I've never seen a single person using it. You can text message but you can't Google? Miss me with that shit.

> I felt like, I felt like
STOP WRITING LIKE THIS, GOD

Well, least Jayce admitted he was a hypocrite. But we have to admit, Viktor has been one too, especially with all the 'noble Leftist' shit.
babbling apologies 3.PNG
> And he and he and he and he
Are you having an asthma attack?

>He rips gaze away astares
Fucking hell, this was not edited. "He rips his gaze away and stares."

> Because Viktor has no idea
Well, he's gotten all the hints that've hit him in the face, and he's still blind, so we'll call this Retards in Denial.

Finally, in Chapter 8, we have the much vaunted kiss scene. Next up, the smut.
first kiss.PNG
> Oh god oh god oh god
Stop with this fucking writing already. Jesus Fucking Christ. First kiss scene and you're already pissing it away.

Viktor moves his hands away from Jayce's face twice, and puts them on his face twice. He does lots of things twice.

Here we go with the segmented sentences. "They stare at each other for a moment, in the intimate silence of their spot in the lab, Viktor's lips are split slick, cheeks a furious red and he's buzzing like a live wire." There. See how easier that is to read?

> As they take a moment to process. A quiet moment before the splitting of atoms. WHAT DID I JUST SAY?!
first kiss 2.PNG
Viktor grabs Jayce's face twice - this makes it the fourth time he's done that. Get another beta reader.

> He's so overcome. He never thought.
Never thought what? Don't leave us hanging.
first kiss 3.PNG
Yes, because the man who fucked you over and made you move away and made you enjoy his humiliation is retconned to being someone who would never leave him like he was a louse or some shit. Pathetic. What a way to downplay such betrayal.

> And he wants he wants he wants
I want want want want this to be over so I can skewer the smut, but whatever. We get there when we get there.
first kiss 4.PNG
And here we are led to the eventual smut. Can't wait to read that.

For the record, I found the kissing scene to be not that bad. It could have been written in a better context, had the drama actually been drawn out and plotted better. For example, if Jayce had more doubts and misgivings over what he did in internal monologues, the audience would feel that tension and wish for them to make up. He didn't do it until his mother (and Caitlyn) told him to, remember. He didn't do anything until two fag hags laid down the law. Pathetic.

Now, we wait for the smut. Let's see what it brings us.
What a fucking piece of shit to reply to someone like that with the most attack-dog fuck-you-aura response that I think could possibly be drawn up. At least, that's what a reasonable person would probably think, but this is the fanfiction community, so of course everyone who types a comment that isn't the most obvious toxic positivity happy fuel should get their hands cut off a la the Congolese. Since Redditors are Redditors though, instead of reason prevailing we get a whole host of womenchildren bending over backwards on just how exactly you are supposed to type a positive comment to not get the wrath of an author looking to skewer someone. And I mean really bending over.
Once, I got nothing but a single heart on the comments of my fic. I didn't write an essay on how I thought they needed to do better. I just ignored them and let them have their fun. Those comments are a dime a dozen and are 95% of any given fic, because fanfic readers, despite all the shit about them being 'media literate' really aren't. You'll have a few dedicated fans and that's it - and that's OK.

When you DO give these authors what they want - and I have, many times, especially in the realm of criticism - they will take back all that hand holding and proceed to chimp out. it's all, 'Wow. Literally, wow." And I've seen dozens, if not HUNDREDS, of comments EXACTLY like that caveman comment on smut fics, especially in CoD. All the time, in fact. And the author doesn't write tangents on how much she hates it. They recognize it's just a horny smut fic and move on.

Sure, I don't like those caveman comments either. But you shrug your shoulders and move on - and cater to those who are willing to engage. These bitches better be lucky their fics don't end up here where they'll be laughed at.

Speaking of, here are some comments I grabbed from the Fanfiction reddit back in the day. I posted these before, but here's a reminder. But first, here's an example of a 'teehee uwu' comment that didn't get such a snarky reply.
gleeful little slut.PNG
For the record, I do not remember what Assassin's Creed fic this was, but yes, what the author is squeeing about is exactly what the Bleeding Effect is: you are receiving the memories of your ancestors in real time, outside of the Animus, and it fucks with your psyche. This is apparently novel to this user.

And what does this author write? Transformers smut, and this:
t4t pirates.PNG
Speaking of AO3/fanfiction reddit, you can try to give users there actual criticism, but don't you dare call them out for their gender bullshit. You might get a classic like this:
I hate you mom and dad.PNG
I hate you mom and dad 2.PNG
She didn't like to be told she was getting upset over...*checks notes* 26 dead transwomen.
I hate you mom and dad 3.PNG
I hate you mom and dad 4.PNG
That's r/fanfiction in a nutshell. It's overrun with these fucks, and this was taken four years ago.
BTW, she's not white. To no one's surprise, she's actually Jewish, and has written things for Purim. White people generally don't know what Purim is.

And this is what she writes:
trans male smut.PNG
In case you didn't notice, the Jewish woman crying over dead black transwomen doesn't write about niggers but white men fucking each other and white women pretending to be white men who fuck each other. Imagine that.
 
Last edited:
Caveman comments are annoying, people are gonna get annoyed by them. lol calm down
Nobody's reading those essays on how to "properly" comment on a fic any more than fic authors are actually reading the comments that just say "Extra kudos!" or some shit. Anybody who's flipping out on either end of the spectrum is being retarded.
 
Taking a brief break from Coming Home to go a little bit out of my element: the huge CaitVi fandom. Both of them are canonically female, but this is one of the rare instances where Caitlyn is made trans. What would otherwise be a normal F/F fic is made redundant as one of them has a cock. The comments are all moderated; this seems to be enjoyed by the author's personal entourage. Link to fic. Archive.

jewish love.PNG
That's right: we've got a Jewish Vi falling in love with a Jew of the East who happens to have a schlong. Amazing what the goyim think of!
representation.PNG
The Chinese are one of the most numerous peoples on the planet. If you want representation, try Cantonese and throw in a big of a Hong Kong struggle. She's also using a dialect of Chinese that is mostly used by the Taiwanese, which is funny in hindsight. So, without further adieu, let's read about the rich 'bitch' who has a cock.
goyim love.PNG
Let me start off with the fact that the writing, it of itself, is pretty good. But like all things, once you add that 'trans' tag, the beauty of it goes out the window and all you've got is autism; you cannot help but start noticing things. In this case, Caitlyn the True and Honest woman has dainty screams and thin shoulders. You totally couldn't clock her.
goyim love 2.PNG
Cait is canonically 6'0, very tall for a woman. Since she's a transwoman this is even funnier in hindsight; they are rarely small uwu girls. I'm so used to reading about trans Viktor who IS made a teeny tiny pooner that it shocks me when it happens to an actual female character.
goyim love 3.PNG
goyim love 4.PNG
Turns out the Chinese dialect they're speaking is supposed to be Ionian, a language in LoL that's completely separate to ours. I guess the author thought that because most of the champions from there look Asian, they must be an Asian nation?
goyim love 5.PNG
One thing you might have noticed that I certainly did: despite the attack on the Council, there's absolutely no mention of Caitlyn's dead mother. None. Nada. Maybe it'll appear later but that's a helluva thing to miss on the get-go.
goyim love 6.PNG
> Be a transwoman
> Have thin shoulders
Honey, not even F1NN5TER has thin shoulders. Who are you fooling?
goyim love 7.PNG
Eh, you can still get someone with a paring knife, especially since they're sharp. John Wick got somebody with a pencil.
goyim love 8.PNG
She's gonna be blinking once she finds out what Caitlyn is packing beneath the sheets.
goyim love 9.PNG
"Hey Caitlyn, you wouldn't happen to have an inverted dick that you masquerade as a vagina, would you?"
goyim love 10.PNG
That's right: Ionian is actually Chinese. Better tell the non-Chinese looking Ionians they're racist skin walkers.
kosher romance.PNG
Interesting how they've got French dogs in a world where the French do not exist (imagine that; no piss-stinking cities!).
kosher romance 2.PNG
kosher romance 3.PNG
Ha, there's something else knit into her very physiology - just wait until you find out what it is.
kosher romance 4.PNG
So, we do have a minor smut scene, and it gets pretty mind-bending once you start asking questions. Kiwis here are aware of the SRS thread (if not, I suggest getting acquainted) so you know what these results look like in real life. Transwomen have tube tits for a reason - gynecomastia on a male chest - and those weird ass areolas around their nipples. They will never get breasts larger than an A-cup, while Caitlyn in the show has pretty big boobs. Something to note.
kosher romance 5.PNG
That's right, readers: Caitlyn magically has a fully functioning neo-vagina that drips and stretches just like the real thing vs the ballsack pussylips they're infamous for. No scrotal scars or entrances that look like a raw chicken about to go into the oven. In this universe, they've perfected SRS to make it look like the real thing! You'd never tell that Cait was a biological male unless you forced her to admit it! Just Lesbian Things.
kosher romance 6.PNG
Yes, that inverted penile skin and peeking dorsal head of the penis is totally a clit. It's totally swollen and not the remains of the cock that got turned inside out.

> "It looks like architecture when she comes" - It's not the Hagia Sophia up in here, it's straight up 9/11.

> Lapping at flushed folds
Her readership has no idea what those stinkditches look like, do they? It ain't a labia. Deflated chicken skin is what it actually looks like.
kosher romance 7.PNG
Haha get it? The actual woman is smol compared to the big and tall tranny. Laugh it up, lads!
kosher romance 8.PNG
Wait until you read how bad this injury is.
kosher romance 9.PNG
That's right: a small blade buried beneath your ribs is something you can casually leave in there and just pluck out. I assume it's not near her heart and probably near her stomach, which is an even more dangerous location. Someone was aiming for a killshot and plot armour protected her.
kosher romance 10.PNG
Honey, you're gonna need more than your fingers if it's buried that deep. Try a fridge magnet.
painkiller passion.PNG
That's right: she pulled that out without the use of painkillers while also having a crying fit. Need I mention she was sobbing before she even got the supplies to begin with? Poor Vi. But it's OK as she's a Jew and that IDF blood will pull her through.
painkiller passion 2.PNG
Yes, you should. Because that's how you get an infection. Spoilers: she did none of those things and let Vi fester in those dirty clothes - oh, and I forgot, SHE NEVER CLEANED THE WOUND AT ALL - and in those bloody bedsheets. Ergo, she was staying in a filthy troon's room because Caitlyn is too lazy to clean.

Figures Caitlyn would go gray in her 30's. That estrogen surely isn't helping.
painkiller passion 3.PNG
She's 30 and aging terribly like most troons do. Funny how Vi doesn't have gray hairs and she does.
painkiller passion 4.PNG
painkiller passion 5.PNG
That's right: the Demacians speak FRENCH. The people who engage in holy wars against all magic speak French because hey we're referencing the Crusaders! They all totally spoke French! That must be why Garen is such a stuck up zealot swinging his sword everywhere; he needs to sate that French bisexuality and need to be better than everyone else.

LMAO at the troon being bad with kids. Oh, honey. You never should've used that tag.
painkiller passion 6.PNG
Yes, it devolves into your white picket fence story with 'lesbians' - except one of them is actually a dude. So basically your spicy straight Hallmark story.
painkiller passion 7.PNG
That's nice, but one of you has a ballsack pussylips vagina and the other one a natal vagina, and you can't have kids unless you A) adopt and B) find a sperm donor. You gonna ask Jayce or Viktor this time around?
painkiller passion 8.PNG
> Talks about the erasure of Vi's heritage
> She's Jewish (like her VA is)
> Hints that Zaun is a multicultural centre
> The Jewish language and people get wiped out in a Steampunk Shoah
Damn, where's the Piltovan ADL? And neither of you can pass on your DNA, because, you know, you're deliberately sterile.
painkiller passion 9.PNG
OY VEY IT'S ANUDDAH SHOAH
Man it's really something when the Jewish people and language get targeted first in a multicultural hub...almost like you're warning us of something there...
painkiller passion 10.PNG
So you used sign language to help someone during mental distress? Mm, interesting. Also funny that that would mean Powder/Jinx is Jewish too, leaning into the whole 'neurotic Jew' thing. Man I love it when progressives confirm 'racist' stereotypes!

> Vi has a heart murmur
Damn, maybe she should get that fixed. I mean Caitlyn got a ballsack pussylip vagina, so anything goes!
not me though.PNG
Very nice. You'd never know Vi was Jewish unless the author explicitly told you so; it's something that was never brought up aside from one or two Hebrew terms. She's indistinguishable everywhere else. As for Caitlyn being Chinese, yeah, we can tell she's a Hapa from the way she looks in the show, but having the Ionians speak Chinese is kind of a copout. It takes away the allure of Runeterra being a reality like our own, but also completely unique. I get the author wanted to be authentically Chinese here, but it didn't give me that impression. Her being Chinese did not affect the story at all, and the plot is virtually nonexistent. You wouldn't know Cait was trans were it not for the tags, either.

And oh, to make matters worse...the author also headcanons Vi as 'transmasc' and her fans call her 'he' because she used the Chinese word for 'lady killer' and 'handsome man'. For a plot involving bridging relationships and reconciliation, there's none of it here. They just hang around talking, and there is no mention of Caitlyn's dead mother. You'd think that would be a major event, but no. Enjoy the stinkditch sex instead.

Here were some comments. As said, these were all moderated, so only besties can comment.
Here was one of the people who got this fic going.
going gray.PNG
"You really showed the richness of their culture! Connections with blood and soil matter the most to people - oh wait, this isn't Stormfromt"
rich culture.PNG
You sure did love sharing it with Taiwan and Tibet.
learn every culture.PNG
Better not learn about the Bantu languages and how they came into being.
literally crying.PNG
My eyes were completely dry. Anyone else's?

In which a commenter had to bring up those 6 million tears:
six million tears.PNG
These hoes are going to CRY once the first act gets released. I can't wait to see their pain.

And oh, I've seen the fanart for this. It's as terrible as you can expect. Will post in SJW art thread later.

It's white, brown, and tan?
It melts under fire? You have to wipe it off with soap? It's all melty and gets everywhere and you hate it when it gets on your clothes? That if you aren't careful you might think it's shit? That you can't let pets eat it? That it burns the inside of your mouth?

What a weird fucking description. That and the 'your skin will literally turn gold into goo' thing.

Obligatory fascinating titles tax.
Screenshot_20241019-051805_(1).png
Screenshot_20241021-184551_(1).png
Imagine being an EMS and STILL getting your field wrong.
Screenshot_20241021-185640_(1).png
Screenshot_20241021-184921_(1).png
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom