🐱 Fandom Rules Against Deadnaming on Star Wars’ Wookieepedia

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
CatParty


Fandom, the host of the Star Wars wiki Wookieepedia and several other fan wikis, issued a policy against deadnaming transgender individuals across its sites.

Fandom's decision came after a debate emerged on Wookieepedia. Its policy previously stated, "Articles for real-world people, such as actors and authors, shall be titled according to their actual credited name in a Star Wars work, whether that be an abbreviation/stage name or pseudonym." However, its policy didn't address the harm it'd do to deadname transgender creatives who've come out and changed their names since their Star Warscredits.

The issue appears to have come to prominence with a back-and-forth editing war on the page of non-binary artist Robin Pronovost, with some editors trying to remove their deadname and others putting it back (trans Wookiepedia contributor Toqgers, who started the forum thread and put the issue up to a vote, tells CBR things were in motion long before this). Pronovost requested their deadname be removed, leading the policy change to ban deadnaming to be voted on in Wookiepedia's forums.

Before Fandom's deadnaming policy decision, 32 editors voted in support of changing the policy to prohibit deadnaming and 12 voted against the change. The Transformers Wiki also issued a statement in support of Pronovost and the site's policy change. Wookieepedia rules require a two-thirds majority vote to enact policy changes, with limitations on which editors are allowed to vote. Several editors were temporarily banned from the site for alleged "vote farming." The deadline for the vote was to be March 30.

However, Fandom decided to step in and make a call on behalf of its site, nullifying the vote and unbanning the banned editors. The official statement from Fandom Director of Community Safety Tim Quievryn reads, "Having reviewed the situation, and in keeping with the evolving understanding of these issues, Fandom has determined that, while it may not have been the intention, knowingly using a deadname in an article title is a violation of our Terms of Use." Quievryn added, "This is a global determination, meaning it applies to all wikis -- including Wookieepedia."

Quievryn concluded, "Our communities often spend much time debating the nuance of a canon or the particulars of a given content policy, but we must also be willing to engage in challenging conversations about the nuance of external factors surrounding these topics. To that end, when wiki content is talking about real human beings with real needs, they must be respected." Fandom's updated naming policy went into effect immediately across its sites.
 
Lucca "Programmer Socks" Skywalker. She always was a woman and just because she kissed her sister doesn't mean anything, bigot.
 
Does it count as incest if you don't know you're related?
If the force can pick up rocks and choke people out, I think it can tell you if some woman is your sister. Nigga can sense shit from time and space but can't sense that this woman when wet smells the same as his work-out sweats? I don't buy it.
 
If the force can pick up rocks and choke people out, I think it can tell you if some woman is your sister. Nigga can sense shit from time and space but can't sense that this woman when wet smells the same as his work-out sweats? I don't buy it.
On the oher hand, we never actually saw them get frisky, so...
 
Please don't deadname Anakin Skywalker, he identifies as Darth Vader now.
Oh wait, he detransitioned, delete all references to Darth Vader and refer to him only as Anakin Skywalker.
 
I was wondering how they got into a tranny slap-fight, and it's over some fucking artist that 99.9999% of the fans wouldn't know of.

Imagine my shock.
 
However, Fandom decided to step in and make a call on behalf of its site, nullifying the vote and unbanning the banned editors. The official statement from Fandom Director of Community Safety Tim Quievryn reads, "Having reviewed the situation, and in keeping with the evolving understanding of these issues, Fandom has determined that, while it may not have been the intention, knowingly using a deadname in an article title is a violation of our Terms of Use." Quievryn added, "This is a global determination, meaning it applies to all wikis -- including Wookieepedia."
I'm confused, they were voting against deadnaming, and Fandom walks on in, frees the ballot stuffers...And outlaws deadnaming, anyways.
 
the harm it'd do to deadname transgender creatives who've come out and changed their names since their Star Warscredits.
First of all, they don't create shit. Second, who are we talking about? Surely these MANY creators would result in at least one in article being cited as an example. I'm left to assume that there aren't any & that this is a change/debate on a hypothetical issue. Real people were banned from use thanks to a policy change catering to an extreme minority, so extreme that they can't be named/don't exist.

Oppressed people/class? It seems to me that if you belong to a group that cannot be referenced past a date you determine, by making up an entirely new name/identity for yourself, and if you are there are sweeping & severe penalties for those that dare reference your past life/identity/mistakes, then that group has private laws that apply to only them for their benefit. Privi lege, I believe it was called, in latin. 🤔🤔🤔

but we must also be willing to engage in challenging conversations about the nuance of external factors surrounding these topics.
>we must be willing to engage in challenging conversations
>you will be banned if you converse about someone's previous name even if it is publicly known, this is challenging for them
 
This makes me recall that plinkett review of episode 3, where he points out the credits for CG artwork was longer than the vietnam memorial.
Are they going to have people constantly checking in on the thousands and thousands of people who worked on star wars movies to see if any of them changed their name, thus requiring an update
 
First of all, they don't create shit
They create jobs for the morticians.

And congratulations on getting your own forum tag, cat party, which is something that @Arm Pit Cream is too obnoxious to earn.
download (1)~2.jpeg

This should be his icon.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom