I still cannot get over the fact people still discuss Anders and the Mage-templar conflict. Gaider hit gold with that-intentionally or not, given the topic's staying power.
To clarify, while Anders is an immensely disreputable person-the way he is written in DA2 is absolutely BioWare at its best.
There's a pathos to the man I do admire-the literal "wrestling with a demon", the merging of this self sacrificial devotion and a petty man's ego, the clear queer/sexual allegories(Anders is up against the christian coded chantry and templars), the fact he is such a nasty and ultimately cowardly bastard(the way he speaks to Fenris and Merrill are just not forgivable), the glib humor, the VA sells it all.
Which is why the character resonates so much on Tumblr in particular, again I dislike Anders the person-but as he is written in DA2, he is memorable for a damned good reason.
One of DA2's themes is people stay the course on their paths-even if it leads to destruction.
Anders-cannot back away, (if really pressured Justice will take over and force the matter),
The Arishok-has to recover the tome, and deal with Kirkwall's dysfunction
Meredith-she was always going to react with the harshness, paranoia and severity that defines her,
Elthina-doing nothing is still doing something
Merrill-she has to make her deal with Audacity even if her clan falls
While DA2 has very limited environmental variety, and Act 3 is undercooked, and the lack of the Exalted March DLC really shows-I stand by my contention upon replay that is is the best written DA game.
(There's a codex entry you find in Act 1-where some nobles remark the Amell family is cursed to misfortune, after Leandra runs off with Malcolm, and in the end that's the same with Hawke).
Few BioWare games really sell the idea of Tragedy-the idea that disaster and calamity follows inevitably from the inherent flaws, motivations and contexts of a story's protagonists, but DA2 does.
Anders in particular stands out at every point he could have stopped. But his nature(and that of his spirit) could lead him no other way.
Again I don't particularly like Anders but he really is well written.