Holy shit. You hit that nail directly on the head. Nearly every single art community I've been a part of over the years has devolved into this bitchy, mean girl hierarchy and the closed species community I feel is one of the biggest exhibitors of this sort of attitude. What makes me moti about it is that these bitches expect you to pay hundreds or thousands for shitty autistic doodles and be grateful that you were able to even afford their ridiculous prices like the peons you are.
When I discovered DeviantArt at the age of nine I was mesmerized by the very concept of art trades and commissions. Before that, art was something lofty and distant, like the Catholic Church commissioning Michaelangelo to paint them something.
DeviantArt sounded like something I, a talentless fanboy with an excitable imagination, could feel at home among other excitable stickman-loving fanboys.
It was
small scale commerce. A friendly little village where you could pay five dollars for a doodle, or an MS paint doodle in exchange for another.
Nobody, and I say nobody I knew IRL liked drawing.
I remember getting fanart of my OCs when I was nine on Scratch. Holy shit, I was jumping up and down in pure ecstasy. Little did I know that that cocaine rush of online validation was the very same thing that would drive artists a decade hence to emotional ruin and great narcissism.
The secret club mentality is a tantalizing thing when you're a child. There is nothing better than online prestige, to be honoured for your creations. But as this thread would indicate - this mentality has disastrous consequences on those who don't outgrow it. And there's the realization that I could have ended up like this if I had tried to relive my old experiences, albeit with more social status. It's like being God and watching one third of your angels become demons.
I have a gut feeling that all the ills of the internet link back to the secret club mentality. Once it brought light and creativity to the old web communities, and now it is the banal driver of the culture wars.