Arecibo telescope collapses - Goldeneye and Battlefield 4 (kind of) Icon

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/12/arecibo-telescope-collapses-ending-57-year-run

The Arecibo Observatory is gone. Its 900-ton instrument platform, suspended above a dish in the karst hills of Puerto Rico, collapsed this morning, at about 8 a.m. local time, says Ramon Lugo, director of the Florida Space Institute at the University of Central Florida, which manages the 57-year-old radio telescope for the National Science Foundation (NSF). On 19 November, NSF decided to decommission the observatory following two cable breaks that put the platform on the brink of collapse. But in the end, it couldn’t survive long enough for a controlled demolition.

“I feel sick in my stomach,” Lugo says, fighting back tears. “Truthfully, it was a lot of hard work by a lot of people trying to restore this facility. It’s disappointing we weren’t successful. It’s really a hard morning.”

Lugo says no one was near the dish when the platform fell. But he did not have all the details on how the structure came down. He believes it was because of a failure of one of the remaining cables connecting the platform to one of three support towers. These cables were carrying extra stress following the two previous failures. And since the Thanksgiving holiday, Lugo says, wires were breaking in these remaining cables at a rate of about one per day. He says he told NSF the structure only had a week or two remaining before it would collapse.

Engineers will inspect the condition of the three support towers today, says Lugo, and see whether they can piece together how it collapsed. He worries about the 130 observatory staff members and their future. “I can’t imagine how they feel,” he says.

Archive

Sad times, friends. It was realistically the only one of its kind and it will be years, perhaps decades before we build a viable substitute.
 
And of course this was due to budget restrictions that made maintenance and inspection too expensive to perform.
 
For England, James?
...no, for me.
DeathOfAlec.jpg
 
The telescope had suffered damage before from a cable that snapped and fucked some plates. Also, the latest seismic activity near Puerto Rico fucked it up more.

It was gonna be demolished anyways. What did it in was a tremor of 4.0 in the Dominican Republic.

Sad that it's gone, as even with better radio telescopes, it was still the only one that could receive shit. Like Amy Ramadan says : "It is what it is".

And since ratings are broken, I rate OP with :feels:
 
The telescope had suffered damage before from a cable that snapped and fucked some plates. Also, the latest seismic activity near Puerto Rico fucked it up more.

It was gonna be demolished anyways. What did it in was a tremor of 4.0 in the Dominican Republic.

Sad that it's gone, as even with better radio telescopes, it was still the only one that could receive shit. Like Amy Ramadan says : "It is what it is".

And since ratings are broken, I rate OP with :feels:
It also doesn't help that there seems to be a lot of negligence going on over there, on the part of workers and most especially government shenanigans. I recall reading that their famous zoo is also falling apart and treating their animals like shit.
Does anyone have the video of it happening though
I do enjoy the autistic beauty of mechanical failure
Ditto on this. I want some wreckage footage.
 
of course it doesnt it functions better because it bigger and china has 5000 years of history.
I still find it hilarious that despite it being 2x the scale of Arecibo they put this little tiny instrument platform in the middle.

1606881698100.png

That plus the towers don't even look like they'd be able to support the weight of a similar one (not that Arecibo was able to in the end).
 
I sneaked into an astronomy conference a few years ago. They're an interesting group, probably the only discipline I've seen the presenters regularly work a bit of humor into their presentations. They're also remarkably frank with you while still being fun to shoot the shit with. Would sneak again.

Anyway, there was a recurring theme of people scoffing at China's BFD. One of the biggest problems, nobody wanted to work there. The pay was dogshit, and the researchers knew they'd only be there long enough for the natives to copy learn everything they do. They'd get a fancy bullet point on their CV, and that's about it. Nobody cares about publishing under Chinese programs as most Chinese papers are garbage. Hence, the thing was idling for quite some time as they couldn't attract the needed talent to make the thing do science.

I haven't checked to see if the situation has improved, but that sounds like a typical attitude: copy, over-build, then worry about putting it to use later. Doesn't matter if it's an entire city or just a dish, it's make-work. I'm sure the quality of those support towers is 100% and they will never, ever be found to be subpar in construction.
 
Back
Top Bottom