Sorry for not responding, took me a minute to gather my thoughts and consult my roommate on her thoughts about some of what we're shaky on.
>not finished Hellsing Ultimate (plans to drop)
>queued Hellsing the Series
Why. How. That's not normal.
IDK, we haven't really watched something that runs as long as an episode of Hellsing Ultimate and we've been watching it subbed with a really shitty font (don't ask why, we've been staying away from dubs for some reason and I'm not sure why.) The fat nazi dude talks way too much from what she says.
That aside, I recommend Trigun, Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann and Higurashi No Naku Koro Ni.
Lol, I forgot Gurren Lagann, we were into it for awhile but we lost interest after the timeskip. Neither of us could really stand Nia and given we kinda hated the way Samurai Jack ended, I doubt either of us would have enjoyed the ending.
I was 99% sure I wasn't going to like Konosuba before I watched it. Got hooked immediately. I'd give it a shot.
Oh, I personally love it, it's made me laugh like nothing else has in recent years. I listed it as a maybe because some of the humor really isn't her kind of thing, but I'll give it a shot.
If you like hip-hop (not sure since you said Afro Sam was "meh") you could give Samurai Champloo a go.
Well, it depends. Afro Samurai was beautiful and it's soundtrack is great, but the story is kinda weak (great concept imo) and the much advertised Samuel L. Jackson was kind of misused. We expected a Pulp Fiction-esque type thing but a quiet role where he speaks maybe three words an episode isn't really his strong suit, and his weird delusion honestly could have been played by any hyperactive black dude.
If you want more horror after Ghost stories, there's Another, which is really good. I also enjoyed the episodes of Chrono Crusade that I saw. A nun with a demon familiar hunt down and exorcise demons.
Oh, she loves horror and slasher type shit. Any more recommendations would be welcome.
Since you guys seem to be men of culture as well and enjoy mecha, I'd get into Patlabor. The ova series is good if you like 80's anime with quirky humor but the film is kino. It was directed by Mamoru Oshii, the same guy that directed GitS. He also made another film in the 80's called Angel's Egg. It's one of my favorites but it's weird, just to give you a heads-up.
Based, that's going in the cue.
Oh, and just for the sake of brevity cause this post is getting kinda long, I'll give ROD a shot,
@Dom Cruise, it sounds interesting.