I wish I could talk to someone whose legit first anime was Evangelion, and not because they were a kid or what-not. I'm super curious as to how they turned out from it.
It's not that difficult methinks, particularly in areas where you didn't get anime at all. Evangelion was my first anime, and I clearly remember:
- Being quite puzzled trying to reconcile the Christian/philosophical elements with my own personal knowledge, because it was far beyond me to understand that they were just gibberish there to look cool;
- Liking quite a lot the sci-fi beats and the concept of biological mecha with a limited operational time. Made for some decent action (and I liked a lot episodes that were merely monsters of the week or world-building like Jet Alone, from what I get they're not exactly well-liked).
- Finding Shinji was a loser and feeling particularly bad for the Asuka breakdown, because I saw kids burning themselves out in Real Life.
- Most of the cast was fine. Liked more the
humans (the command crew, the school mates) because Rei was clearly a monstrosity and the people in charge were clearly broken.
- I liked the original ending. I got they didn't have budget and that they went for some purposefully obtuse time-wasting episodes, but the last message was endearing enough even if the plotline wasn't resolved.
I hated
End of Evangelion. It made me almost sick, I perceived it as a try-harding, degenerate and bent on misery porn. I disliked even the
soundtrack, finding it inferior to the picks in the original series. Shinji went from a loser to a
retarded loser that the world finds important for unknown reasons. Most plot beats I found between the offensive and the stupid (Asuka's death, everyone being reduced to glop by teh Rei) and I found myself preferring the low-key but more endearing original ending.