You know, for a guy who loves tabletopping (as a fucking bard too nonetheless), Noah really seems to love playing murderhobos with no CHA.
I still think my favorite doublestandard from him is "I don't believe in a no win scenario" when referring to his non-Jedi Jedi Killer, basically saying that he wanted to be able to beat things he shouldn't, and then immediately demands as a DM enemies that you cannot kill, making a four part rambling bitchfest about that.
"Oh, that typo in the Tarrasque's THAC0? I love it, since it means you can only kill it by repeatedly botching."
"I love that they literally say you lose if you fight those whatsitzthingies in the Babylon 5 tabletop."
"Yeah, you can't kill the Lady of Pain. Deal with it."
"Fuck you, you can't beat Cthullu. He comes back radioactive now (even in the books you can. You just need to ram a boat into him and fuck his island signal/ritual)."
Then you get into his That Guy tendencies. For one thing, he perfectly is fine with playing the rules to the point he willingly does a conga-line of death to max out his potential despite the fact that any reasonably decent DM going "No Noah, you can't take advantage of the Blackguard's fight against Sir Stromming, because you're fighting a fucking lich or whatever already". Then he decides to use books the dm doesn't have to do his pigshit cheese and demands that the DM can't read his stuff (tough shit Noah, that would not fly if I DMed a game with you). Mix this in with his graybeard tendencies (in my day, I played a shitty complicated system that was improved significantly later on), and getting his graybeard stuff wrong (pretty sure AD&D did have negative health before you died), and you get a really shitty player and DM.