After Rabbis Ban AI, Educator Opens ‘Kosher Chatbot’ - Rabbis in New Square banned the use of AI tools, but that led Crown Heights teacher Moishy Goldstein to create a kosher chatbot with results aligning with Torah values.

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Link | Archive

Rabbi Moishy Goldstein, an educator and music producer in Crown Heights, has created a new Kosher chatbot, https://kosher.chat.

The Crown Heights resident has created the chatbot which he says creates answers that are “Kosher” and filtered to be aligned with Torah values.

The impetus to create the Kosher chatbot was the recent news that Rabbis in New Square have banned the use of all Artificial Intelligence tools that contradict Torah values and are equivalent to unfiltered internet.

In what is believed to be a first-of-its-kind ban, more than a dozen rabbanim and dayanim from the Skver chasidus have signed a strongly worded letter Rabbinically prohibiting the use of AI chatbots, YWN reported.

The letter, first released on Thursday, mentions OpenAI, the company behind artificial intelligence marvel ChatGPT, but makes it clear that it is not speaking of only that developer’s products, which they write, “is strictly prohibited in every way and form, even on a simple phone.”

“The severity of the danger is not yet clear and obvious to everyone,” the letter states, noting that it poses, in the eyes of the rabbanim, a critical danger to Frum Jews.

“AI chatbots can provide completely unfiltered access to apikorsus, lewd and perverse content, and all the issurim of ‘lo sasuru acharei levavchem,'” the public announcement says, so they are included in the ban of using unfiltered internet.

Goldstein has just released the new chatbot, and says it is a solution to the unfiltered chatbots which can return any result.
“Kosher.Chat responses are all aligned with Torah values, and the chat provides a safe, Kosher and secure environment for frum users,” he says. “Nevertheless,” he cautions, “it is by no means a replacement for an ordained rabbi and should not be relied upon for practical Halacha questions.”

Goldstein requests users to test-drive the platform to check for any answers that are not aligned with Torah and to report these findings so that the AI model can be further trained to be more aligned with our Torah, Toras Emes.
 
The Jew fears the AI.


It explains why ML bullshit got stifled for so long I guess. But as always you can't stop the signal.
 
I thought I'd give this a go from behind a VPN.

First, I wanted to make sure it was OK for me to use Kosher Chat.

1682933458581.png

So far so good. I thought I'd try asking Kosher Chat about something that Jews are renowned for, but I didn't get much sense out of it.

1682933520187.png

Maybe I didn't make myself very clear. I'm not really in the market for financial advice right now, but I am thinking of watching a movie tonight.

1682933656611.png

I honestly thought that Yentl was made by Jews. Maybe I should have asked Kosher Chat about its favourite Mel Brooks film instead. Though now I was wondering why Kosher Chat was so reluctant to discuss non-Jewish media. Does Kosher Chat have a problem with the portrayal of Jews in the media? This led me to ask about the most ultra-orthodox fictional character I could think of.

1682933879331.png

Oy vey.

It was at this point I decided not to waste any more of Kosher Chat's time, so I excused myself...

1682933929801.png

... which led to the most passive-aggressive thing I've ever seen an AI chatbot say.

1682933973965.png

I guess Kosher Chat really is Jewish.
 
I started off by asking it a few questions about the Moshiach (Messiah). Chabad, the group that the creator is affiliated with, is most widely known for their outreach activities and belief that their late leader, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, is the messiah:
1682934885533.png

On to a few questions about goyim:
1682935070635.png

Asking about the Talmud and Jesus:
1682935644299.png

Signing off:
1682936012507.png
 
I thought I'd give this a go from behind a VPN.

First, I wanted to make sure it was OK for me to use Kosher Chat.

View attachment 5104570

So far so good. I thought I'd try asking Kosher Chat about something that Jews are renowned for, but I didn't get much sense out of it.

View attachment 5104574

Maybe I didn't make myself very clear. I'm not really in the market for financial advice right now, but I am thinking of watching a movie tonight.

View attachment 5104579

I honestly thought that Yentl was made by Jews. Maybe I should have asked Kosher Chat about its favourite Mel Brooks film instead. Though now I was wondering why Kosher Chat was so reluctant to discuss non-Jewish media. Does Kosher Chat have a problem with the portrayal of Jews in the media? This led me to ask about the most ultra-orthodox fictional character I could think of.

View attachment 5104584

Oy vey.

It was at this point I decided not to waste any more of Kosher Chat's time, so I excused myself...

View attachment 5104585

... which led to the most passive-aggressive thing I've ever seen an AI chatbot say.

View attachment 5104587

I guess Kosher Chat really is Jewish.
Should have asked about the Talmud language model.
 
Back
Top Bottom