Disaster Condo collapse in Miami-Dade kills at least one; search and rescue combing through rubble

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

Condo collapse in Surfside kills at least one; search and rescue combing through rubble​

https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/miami-beach/article252324218.html (archive)

A 12-story oceanfront condo tower partially collapsed early Thursday morning in the town of Surfside, spurring a massive search-and-rescue effort with dozens of rescue crews from across Miami-Dade and Broward counties.

The ocean-facing portion of Champlain Towers South Condo, completed in 1981 with more than 100 units at 8777 Collins Ave., collapsed around 2 a.m., leaving a heap of rubble.

Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett confirmed that 10 people were treated for injuries on-site, two transported to the hospital, and at least one person has died. Authorities anticipate more fatalities.

A little after 8 a.m., Frank Rollason, director of Miami-Dade Emergency Management, said emergency workers believe they have cleared all survivors from inside the tower, which has more than 130 apartments. He said more than 70 of them have been destroyed or damaged.

“Everyone who is alive is out of the building,” he told the Miami Herald.

Several people have gathered at the town’s community center, where the Red Cross is assisting those who are waiting to hear about missing loved ones. Burkett said the building manager does not keep a log of residents, but logs visitors. First responders are using the list to try and account for the missing.

“They brought dogs who can sniff for survivors in the rubble,” said Surfside Commissioner Eliana Salzhauer. “They aren’t turning up very much. No one is celebrating anyone being pulled out.”

Salzhauer said the building was beginning its 40-year recertification, and the building’s roof was being redone, but it is unknown if any construction activity contributed to the disaster.
E45DB30E-2284-4988-9A1A-3056401DD9E8.jpeg

Rescuers were desperately trying to get a trapped child out of the garage at the Champlain Towers shortly after 8 a.m. Thursday, who was discovered by a Miami-Dade Fire Rescue dog.

The searchers believe the child was with his or her parents, who are deceased, Rollason said.

“It’s bad,” he said.

In another case, Rollason said, rescuers saved a mother and her child, but the mother’s leg had to be amputated to get her out.

“We got some people out. They had to cut away railings,” he said.

Because workers haven’t determined the stability yet of the collapsed structure, they haven’t yet started to remove the pile of rubble that remains attached to the building.

Rollason said the building to the south, which is newer, is far enough away that it appears to be fine for now. The building on the south, he said, is older and has been evacuated. The Solara Surfside hotel, which is next to the tower, has also been evacuated.

Santo Mejil, 50, was roused out of bed when his wife called from a unit on the ninth floor of the south condo, one of three buildings that make up the Champlain Towers complex. She is an overnight caretaker for an elderly disabled woman.

“She said she heard a big explosion. It felt like an earthquake,” Mejil told the Miami Herald.

As he recounted rushing over to the beach from their home near Miami International Airport, his phone rang. It was his wife.

“They’re bringing you down?” he said. Tears welled in his eyes. “Thank God.”

Adriana Chi waited outside Jackson’s Ryder Trauma Center shortly before 7 on Thursday morning, worried about two relatives inside and another she can’t locate.

She said her brother, sister-and-law and teenage niece live in a ninth-floor unit there. She was able to speak to her niece ahead of her emergency surgery at Ryder. She said the 16-year-old recalled being awoken by her mother to a shaking building, then had the sensation of the floor giving way.

“She felt the building shake,” said Chi, a nurse practitioner. “Then everything collapsed.”
99C5A520-561B-49AF-B00D-D94E45ABF3D6.jpeg

Chi said her sister-in-law, a psychologist, was brought to Ryder as well but she doesn’t know the whereabouts of her brother, a lawyer.

Chi said her father has owned the unit for about 30 years. She said leaks were a chronic problem, leading to a nagging worry for her.

“The last time I was there, I looked at him and I said: ‘I am serious,’” she recalled between tearful cellphone calls by hospital’s driveway and hugs with other family members gathered outside. “‘This building is going to collapse.’”

Burkett, the mayor, noted that the building is not as old as many in the surrounding area, and that “there is no reason for a building to come down like that.” There are one-foot gaps between stories where there used to be 10, he said.

“This doesn’t happen,” he said. “I’ve been here my whole life, and I haven’t seen anything like this happen.”

When asked if he believed the collapse was an accident, Burkett wouldn’t say.

“What I can say is that a building has fallen down .... I expect that this building is not salvageable at this point.”

He said there had been construction work on the building’s roof over the last 30 days, and that “we’re certainly going to look at that.”
6AF9A7C4-224E-4676-81C9-20942821729F.jpeg


A South Florida-based home insurance inspector who asked not to be named said she had visited Champlain Towers in February 2020 to verify impact windows and doors for a client.

She said the building is reinforced concrete and should not have collapsed the way it did.

“As someone who has been in this business for years, it defies logic,” she said. “It defies everything that we know.”

The area around 88th Street and Collins and Harding avenues have been shut down for several blocks. Dozens of fire engines and rescue vehicles are lining the streets. According to the county’s fire rescue call list, 113 Fire-Rescue units are on scene.

The building is a block north of Miami Beach city limits. The town of Surfside runs along Collins Avenue, south of Bal Harbour. Condos and motels line Collins Avenue.

Miami-Dade Fire Rescue has set up a family reunification center. Anyone looking to connect with loved ones from Champlain Towers can call 305-614-1819.
—————————————
This happened around 2am. There is way more than one dead.
 
One thing I read that I found creepy was that apparently the building was making loud noises for about 20 minutes before it collapsed. Sucks to know that people had a warning sign and enough time to get out, but lots of them probably weren't awake to hear it, or even if they did hear, probably had no idea what it meant :(
Most people probably don't realize, but if your building is making noises; noises that I'm going to assume were like some guttural whale song. Run, run for your life, because that's the steel beams failing to hold everything up.
 
Damn. My heart goes out to those killed and hurt in this. Gonna be interesting to know what caused the catastrophic failure of the building... Sinkholes perhaps? Florida is rather notorious for them.
 
Great news, this engineering masterpiece has a twin building right next door. It's a different color, so I'm sure it has better structural integrity.
33_th.jpg
 
The way it collapsed makes me think support beam failure. Sinkhole is possible, but authorities should know by now if it was one.

My guess is it was a combination of shitty construction work and lack of upkeep. The ocean side was the side that failed. That hints to me salt water damage along with high humidity. The roof being under maintenance may have accelerated the damage.

Either way, whichever company was responsible for building upkeep is fucked. Multiple million dollar lawsuits for injuries/deaths and lost property will happen. The asking price for one of those condos was 600-700k starting. Plus, I'm betting criminal charges for a few people.
 
Last edited:
This is a jew complex in a jew neighbourhood, built by jews. This article in the Jerusalem Post explains their interest. Beachfront, mostly used as second homes means that the death toll won't be as high as it could have been.

Knowing a little about how condos in FL work, I can tell you that likely the "sister" building was better cared for. Judging by the different paint colors one could assume that they have separate management. The condo board is ultimately responsible for this. At least one resident claimed to have expressed fear about the building's safety. It costs a shit ton of cash to keep an old, seaside building properly maintained. Salt and wind batter the concrete 24/7. My guess is that these residents chose to pay less maintenance and deferred major repairs.

My mom's condo on the west coast of Florida has a giant reserve fund, pays a monthly premium to a roofing company to ensure top priority after a weather event yet they change all their own light bulbs and do all the surface work themselves. It is extremely well-run and they do that by keeping frivolous costs to a minimum, paying big for the important stuff and charging more in maintenance than it costs to run the place so their reserve fund is always full in case a major repair is needed. You could safely bet a week's pay that the collapsed building didn't have a well-run board.
 
It passed with some bribing.

I don't have lots of knowledge in geology but does the soils of Southern Florida might have played a role in this?

Miami sits on top of a giant slab of limestone (mostly calcium carbonate) that also acts as the cities fresh water aquifer.

This geology tends to lead to a lot of sinkholes, as acidic water will eat away at limestone creating calcium chloride and CO2 gas, which escapes and then when the water level drops you have a hollow pocket just waiting to collapse.

I get the feeling this probably had something to do with the collapse, but poor building maintenance and construction could definitely be a contributing factor
 
All jokes, snark and such aside, holy shit this is nothing short of tragic. To think about how quickly it must have all happened to, somehow it makes it worse for me to know anyone who died probably did have a couple brief moments of being awake and their entire world collapsing underneath them before the pain of injury and death set in. Hopefully the death count will stay low but given the time it happened and the reality of it I'm expecting 100+.
 
That is really a crazy collapse. Must be a lot of people feeling unsafe in top of their buildings in the neighbourhood now.

Most people probably don't realize, but if your building is making noises; noises that I'm going to assume were like some guttural whale song. Run, run for your life, because that's the steel beams failing to hold everything up.
Sink holes don't melt steel beams.
 
Miami sits on top of a giant slab of limestone (mostly calcium carbonate) that also acts as the cities fresh water aquifer.

This geology tends to lead to a lot of sinkholes, as acidic water will eat away at limestone creating calcium chloride and CO2 gas, which escapes and then when the water level drops you have a hollow pocket just waiting to collapse.

I get the feeling this probably had something to do with the collapse, but poor building maintenance and construction could definitely be a contributing factor
Sinkhole was my first thought. It could've been weakening under the foundations for a while, and the concrete held up for longer than a wood beam suburban house would've, until it finally let loose.

This happened in Tampa:
1624568280858.jpeg


And two homes in Florida:
1624568426446.jpeg


I mean with the foundations required for highrises, I could see a sinkhole getting bigger and bigger, until it finally gave way. And until they move the rubble they might not see it.
 

UPDATE: 51 people remain missing after a 12-story Florida condo building collapsed, killing at least 1 person​

> "Ivanka" and "Jared" part of URL
Jesus christ, it's a building collapse, 51 people are missing, one is dead, and all you fuckers can do is make it political.
 
> "Ivanka" and "Jared" part of URL
Jesus christ, it's a building collapse, 51 people are missing, one is dead, and all you fuckers can do is make it political.
Apparently the headline writer wanted to screech "It killed the wrong people!" But someone sane kicked them in the teeth.
 
I'm gonna make a little dox hole here.

The name of the building is "Champlain Towers South" if anyone wants to join me in sleuthing.







This tweet didn't age well:


 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom